Kalpana Ram's book Fertile Disorder: Spirit Possession and Its Provocation of the Modern is ambitious in scope, as Ram aims to use ethnographic research and analysis of the experience of possession in South India as a means to open up new ways of theorizing about the human experience more broadly. In the process, she advances the discussion on the gendering of possession. Faced with the question of why women seem to get possessed more often than men, theorists have tended to either psychologize and medicalize (leading to therapeutic interventions), or they have used sociological frameworks that posit that possession is one of the few arenas available to women in patriarchal societies to express their anger about the gender discrimination they endure daily. Possession thus becomes an outlet for social tension but one that cannot change the structures of patriarchy. For Ram, such theories are anemic insofar as they are only capable of viewing human agency in terms of individual will and choice wherein possession becomes a (failed) strategy of resistance to patriarchy.
Based on ethnographic research in Dalit Hindu and Christian communities in Tamil Nadu from the 1980s through the early twenty-first century, Ram argues that possession does articulate notions of injustice but not in terms of the Marxist or feminist understandings of power on which critiques of patriarchy are predicated. For the women in Ram's research, possession is an affective experience in response to an arbitrary, tragic loss and an abrupt end to the ripening of the fullness of intimate family relationships that are essential ingredients to a good life for women. Such losses can produce ghosts, and “these creatures have a horrifying agency” (p. 86) and “hunger for human beings who will bear witness” (p. 87) to human injustice.
As is often noted in the literature on shamanism, women who become possessed in Tamil Nadu are thought to have a unique “capacity to be affected by the suffering and violent end of others. . . . These individuals lend their own bodies and voices to allow the ghosts to communicate with a wider public” (p. 88). Some go on to cultivate this capacity for possession and become spirit mediums. Ram points out that this is not by choice, but rather involves a process of accommodation and habituation whereby women “attune” themselves to “the spirit with which they have developed an intimacy” (p. 133). While possessed, these mediums take on the role and tone of precolonial divine rulers and dispense justice accordingly. The complaints presented at the courts of these mediums center on crises in intimate social relations. These are not complaints about discrimination caused by patriarchal, caste, or capitalist exploitation. Rather, “for them, the primary injustice is the failure of the family, kinship, and marital relations to provide them with the nurturance and love that their culture professes” (p. 205). Healing is accomplished when women who bring these complaints to this court feel that the goddess embodied in the medium knows and cares about such suffering (p. 208).
Above and beyond this rich ethnography on possession, drawing on the tradition of phenomenology (particularly Merleau-Ponty's ideas about phantoms), Ram hopes to push social theory to take these women's experiences of possession at face value rather than only rationalizing them within frameworks of pathos, power, and resistance. As she writes, “A society that understands emotions as ‘ghosts’ rather than as ‘psychology’ comes closer . . . to understanding the phenomenology of emotions” (p. 105). Similarly, she suggests that possession can provide us with a more accurate way of theorizing and understanding human gender performance. As she says (contra Butler), “To some extent, lived gender more closely resembles the less-than conscious performativity of ‘possession’ rather than the performance of drag” (p. 245). Above all, she argues that possession can help expand our conceptualization of agency. Through her analysis of possession, she hopes to show that agency is not only about choice and consent but can and should also be viewed as the process of “making room for” or accommodating and adjusting oneself to “that which is alien, disturbing, afflictive, or simply foreign” (p. 255). She considers anthropology to be “possibly unique among academic disciplines in that it depends on such understanding” (p. 275). While these are worthwhile and engaging theoretical debates, some would argue that these more nuanced ways of theorizing agency are not so new.
As the subtitle of the book suggests, in the first part of the book Ram shows how possession among the lower-class and lower-caste communities of Tamil Nadu provokes discomfort among middle-class intellectuals—demographers, public health planners, and medical practitioners—engaged in the management of fertility-related issues who consider possession to be counterproductive to becoming rational, modern subjects. By the end of the book, Ram hopes to have similarly provoked the reader (and other modern intellectuals) to de-exoticize possession and to realize that possession may indeed provide an escape not from patriarchy but from an overly rationalistic, incomplete, and inadequate understanding of the human experience. Whether she has succeeded in this transformative agenda or not will be left to readers to decide. But along the way she has provided compelling and dramatic insights into possession in South India. Ram has written an extremely dense, theoretical book that would be a heavy lift for undergraduate students but will provide much food for thought for graduate students and scholars of anthropology, religion, gender, and South Asia.
