Now it must of necessity become very evil, because [Antichrist’s] time is coming quickly, just as it is written and has long been prophesied: ‘After a thousand years Satan will be unleashed.’…A thousand years and also more have now passed since Christ was among people in human form, and now Satan's bonds are very loose, and Antichrist's time is well at hand.Footnote 1
With these words, Archbishop Wulfstan of York warned the English of the proximity of the advent of the Antichrist and of the terrors of the Last Days of the world. Wulfstan was responding not only to the passing of the millennium but to the devastating Viking attacks which were to cost his king, Æthelred, the kingdom. Dramatic words indeed, but how should a historian understand them. Are they merely the rousing rhetoric of a gifted preacher? Do we know what impact they had? Was Wulfstan's apocalyptic urgency and anticipation shared by others in the kingdom?
The year 1000 is a significant marker in Christian understandings of the end of time because of the amalgamation of a number of Scriptural traditions. Revelations 20:4–6 declared that Christ would reign for a thousand years, then Satan would be freed from his imprisonment in hell to cause havoc on earth before his final defeat. The Bible account of the six days of creation gave rise to the idea that world history could be divided into six ages, followed by a seventh age, a sabbatical rest. Since Scripture also reported that a thousand years was in God's sight a day, each of the six world ages could be reckoned to last a thousand years.Footnote 2 The sixth age had been initiated by Christ's incarnation – dated either from his birth or from his death. These calculations made it possible to foretell, therefore, the date of the Last Judgement although such a prediction contradicted Christ's own words in the New Testament, where he stated clearly that the time of the End was unknowable to all, including himself, and was only known to God.Footnote 3 Millenarian speculations were a source of disquiet and division within the early church. A turning point in defusing the Book of Revelation of its disturbing chronological implications was made by St Augustine who, while affirming a belief in the historical reality of the Last Days and Final Judgement, put forward an allegorical interpretation of Revelation which identified the predictions of the coming of the heavenly kingdom and to Christ's advent with the current church.Footnote 4 The final events had therefore already been accomplished.Footnote 5 Augustine defused the magic number, 1000, by arguing that it was a perfect number and its significance was not literal but allegorical. Although millennial predictions could not be so easily banished, nevertheless, Augustine's teaching was accepted by the church which emphasised the unknowability of the time of the End.
Apocalypticism, millenarianism and expectations of the Last Judgement are enduring themes of human history and continue to feed more political movements and religious groups.Footnote 6 Scholarship on apocalyptic thought in the early Middle Ages is a very widespread and diverse field and cannot be reviewed comprehensively here; instead, two historiographical strands will be emphasised.Footnote 7 First, there are those scholars who might be called Millennial Maximalists and who see individual texts and references as evidence of much more widespread fears and anxieties concerning the imminence of the End of the World. They interpret the silence of the sources about apocalyptic fears as a deliberate suppression by the ecclesiastical hierarchy of evidence of popular movements.Footnote 8 Foremost amongst these is Richard Landes who has argued for apocalyptic fears as a very significant spur to widespread public action in France, provoking, for example, the Peace of God movement.Footnote 9 Then there are the Cautious Sceptics who stress that anticipation of the Last Judgement was a commonplace in early medieval spirituality and who stress the tenuous nature of links between expressions of apocalypticism and fears concerning the year 1000.Footnote 10
This debate highlights methodological issues – how far can we generalise from a minority of sources? Is it possible to detach specifically millennial anxieties from long-established traditions of eschatology? To what extent is apocalyptic imagery a rhetorical strategy harnessed for ideological purposes?Footnote 11 Debates over what has been called ‘the apocalyptic year 1000’ have stimulated a number of closely contextualised and nuanced studies such as that by Levi Roach on Otto III's deployment of apocalyptic imagery or that of Simon MacLean who has argued that the influential Frankish Letter on the Antichrist written by the monk Adso in the mid-tenth century was in part a rhetorical manifesto for monastic reform.Footnote 12
Anglo-Saxonists have been mostly reluctant to see their forefathers as in the grip of millennial anxiety. While Malcolm Godden has described the ‘imminence of the end of the world’ as a ‘framing concept…for Anglo-Saxon writers’, he has argued that for both Ælfric and Wulfstan concerns about the End of the World wan in the course of their careers and became more muted.Footnote 13 Simon Keynes has argued that Viking invasion was a greater preoccupation of the English than anticipation of the End.Footnote 14 By taking a fresh look at the homiletic texts and bringing some new evidence from the charters of King Æthelred, this article will argue that apocalyptic anxieties did intensify around the year 1000 and were a significant factor in courtly debate and in royal piety and policy.Footnote 15
In a study of modern apocalyptic discourse, Stephen O’Leary argues that it serves to explain the problem of evil by placing it within a temporal framework.Footnote 16 In the early Middle Ages, the study of time was closely related to the debate over the End of the World as the work of Bede, for example, illustrates.Footnote 17 However, early medieval religious thinkers like Bede or Wulfstan were perhaps less concerned with the question of evil, but rather with that of sin – the unfailing propensity of man to disobey God and to be blind to the need to forgo worldly pleasures to win eternal joy. The prominence of Endtime anxiety in early medieval thinking derives from what Peter Brown has described as the ‘peccatisation of the world’ – the ‘definitive reduction of all experience, of history, politics, and the social order quite as much as the destiny of individual souls, to two universal explanatory principles, sin and repentance’.Footnote 18 The suffusion of everyday living and of political action by a sense of the sinfulness of human life and thought, and of the implacable judgement of Christ at the end of time necessitated a profound urgency in reminding the Christian faithful of the need to repent and make amends before it was too late. The study of early medieval apocalypticism must be related to that of eschatology. The salvation of the individual sinner at death was inextricably bound up with their salvation or damnation at the Last Judgement. There could be no confession and repentance after death – those who died with major sins, such as murder or adultery, unconfessed would be damned at Doomsday. Lesser sins could be forgiven and washed away before the Final Assize by purgation and posthumous intercession. Since the time of our deaths is unknown, Christians should live in a permanent state of readiness, both for death and for Judgement.Footnote 19
The responses to the year 1000 in England were varied and complex. There was no one clear message, even for Wulfstan, who is the most explicit and outspoken in his preaching. England possessed a rich eschatological tradition in which Anglo-Saxon thinking about the imminence of the End was rooted.Footnote 20 Tensions existed between the need for urgency and for the assertion of unknowability, resulting from the orthodox hostility to predictions of the time of the End, and the necessity of impressing upon the faithful the vital importance of readiness for their own individual and collective end. The different methods of reading the Bible, literal in understanding the predicted portents of the Last Days as genuine future events and allegorical in seeking to understand the thousand years as a metaphor for perfection, created dissonances. It was understood that all those living after the incarnation of Christ were living in the sixth and last age, but there was no common understanding about how to interpret the signs of the End or whether they would take place in rapid succession or unfold over a long period. Moreover, individual understanding of the Last Days changed over time and in response to external circumstances, not just to natural disasters and to political and military catastrophes but also to texts and their interpretations. What did it mean to be living in the last age? Deliberations about the Last Judgement and the End of the World operated in different registers and in different contexts, with no single agreed meaning. But these different discourses intersect and were produced in dialogue with one another.
The passing of the millennial year was noted in England as a significant moment not just by Archbishop Wulfstan whose words opened this article but also by his learned Benedictine colleague, Byrhtferth, a monk at Ramsey who, writing a tract on time and the computus around the year 1011, commented on the prediction that Satan would be loosed after a thousand years, writing – ‘The thousandth year has now been completed, according to the calculations of the human race, but remains to be determined in the presence of the Saviour. The number 1,000 is perfect: and he knows when it will come to completion, who created all things according to his command.’Footnote 21 Earlier, an anonymous Old English homilist writing in 971, in a discussion of Christ's teaching that the time of the End was unknown, warned that
We learn that the time is so secret that no man in this world be he ever so holy…has ever known when our Lord shall decree this world's end on Doomsday…Nevertheless we know that it is not far off, because all the signs and foretokens that our Lord previously said would come before Doomsday, are all gone by, except one alone, that is, the accursed stranger, Antichrist, who, as yet, has not come hither upon earth. Yet the time is not far distant when that shall also come to pass; because this earth must of necessity come to an end in this age which is now present, for [five of the ages of the world] have come to pass in this age; wherefore this world must come to an end, and of this the greatest portion [already] has elapsed, even nine hundred and seventy-one years, in this (very) year. These [ages] were not alike long, but in these were three thousand years, in some less, in others more.Footnote 22
These three authors all display not only an understanding that the millennium could be regarded as a possible mile post on the road to Armageddon but also a strong affirmation of the unknowability of the date of the End. These are not insignificant voices – Wulfstan and Byrhtferth were prominent figures and intellectuals – and their testimony shows that amongst the uppermost echelons of Anglo-Saxon society the significance of the millennium and its associated problems were well known.
Around the year 1000, England was in a crisis state. For over a decade, it had been under attack from Viking raids, which in the course of the first twenty years of the first millennium escalated to become campaigns of conquest under the Danish ruler Swein Forkbeard and his son, Cnut. In 1014, Æthelred was forced to flee and his restoration to the throne was only obtained when Swein died. Even then, it was shortlived as Æthelred himself died in 1016 and Swein's son, Cnut, was eventually able to take the throne.Footnote 23
External Viking attack caused internal controversy and dissent. Following the shocking defeat of the Battle of Maldon in 991, when the ealdorman Byrhtnoth was killed, Æthelred was moved to a new penitential style of kingship.Footnote 24 At a council of Winchester held at Pentecost 993, the king and his leading men sought the cause of the divine wrath manifest in the misfortunes of the English. Our knowledge of this meeting derives from a charter in favour of Abingdon Abbey which describes how the king examined his conscience and found a cause for their troubles in his sale of the abbacy of the monastery, violating the community's right to free election.Footnote 25 The king made recompense for this sin, and in subsequent years made a series of restitutions of property to a number of churches which had suffered alienations permitted by Æthelred in the years before 993.
However, the king's attempts to restore divine favour to his kingdom by acts of conspicuous piety failed to prevent the relentless increase in Viking attacks.Footnote 26 From 996, the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle records annual raiding until 1005, when a great famine forced the Vikings to move to the continent. The Vikings became an unstoppable menace and the return of their forces in 1006 and then in 1009–12 left many of the English in despair. The famine of 1005 and the increased Viking attacks provoked more soul-searching on the part of the English led by Archbishop Wulfstan. In 1007–8, new measures were taken – the payment of tribute to the invaders, the building of a new fleet and greater provision of military equipment. These secular measures were matched by a spiritual campaign. At Pentecost 1008, the king held a council at Enham, Hampshire, which enacted a comprehensive set of laws for the regulation of the Christian life.Footnote 27 These rulings were drafted by Archbishop Wulfstan whose hand also lay behind the decrees of the following year, 1009, which instituted a national penance of three days of fasting, almsgiving, expiatory processions and masses, and of confession.Footnote 28
Æthelred's kingship illustrates the way that, by the tenth century, royal actions and authority could be shaped by expectations of royal piety and of the proper conduct for a Christian king.Footnote 29 The successes of an invading army, many of whom were pagans, were seen as a judgement upon the sins of the English by God.Footnote 30 The success of a kingdom depended on the right rule of its king and monarchs could be held to account. But – as the national penance of 1009 demonstrates – Viking conquest prompted wider introspection and many, including Wulfstan and the homilist Ælfric of Eynsham, pointed to the sins of the people as a whole. Both viewed the Viking raids as a sign of God's anger at the wickedness of the English.
It is this intersection between the tribulations of the reign of Æthelred and the advent of the millennium which makes England so interesting a place in which to explore the currency of ideas about the End of the World. The sources do not make precise predictions of the time of the Last Judgement but evince a heightened sense of its imminence which influences their responses to the contemporary crisis. Biblical, exegetical and other texts such as Adso's tract on the Antichrist offered a rich reservoir of ideas and images concerning the Last Days which lent themselves to adaptation and manipulation in response to the needs of the time and their user's perspectives and anxieties.
This article will now explore ideas about the Last Judgement and End of the World in four different sources – the anonymous vernacular homilies of the tenth and eleventh centuries, in charters issued by King Æthelred the Unready and in the preaching of Ælfric of Eynsham and of Wulfstan of York. These four sets of sources illustrate the diversity of eschatological traditions within England. It will emphasise the dialogue between these different discourses and argue for a living set of interactions taking place around the royal court.
Both Ælfric and Wulfstan are best known for their composition of vernacular sermons. Ælfric never held high office in the English church but penned his three great series of homilies from c. 990 to 998 while he was a monk at Cerne Abbas in Dorset. Later, in 1005, he became abbot of the monastery of Eynsham, Oxfordshire. He was a highly influential figure, dedicating his homilies to Archbishop Sigeric of Canterbury, corresponding with Archbishop Wulfstan, and enjoying the patronage of two of the most powerful nobles of the day, the ealdorman Æthelweard and his son Æthelmaer.Footnote 31
While Ælfric was perhaps a backroom boy, politically influential behind the scenes, Archbishop Wulfstan of York was a major public and political figure. Promoted to the see of London in 996, he was archbishop of York until his death in 1023, holding also the bishopric of Worcester until 1016.Footnote 32 While details of his training and background are opaque, I have argued recently that it is most likely that he was a Benedictine monk, trained at Peterborough.Footnote 33 His life is best known through the survival of nearly fifty sermons authored by him, and by the lawcodes and other writings attributed to him on stylistic grounds. These evidence the influential role he played at court as a councillor of the king, drafting lawcodes for both Æthelred and for Cnut.
However, first the tradition of eschatological preaching found in the anonymous homilies needs to be discussed because this provides the backdrop to the discourses found in Æthelred's charters and to the sermons of Ælfric and Wulfstan, and gives an spiritual context in which to locate them.Footnote 34
The eschatological tradition in Old English preaching before Ælfric and Wulfstan
The two oldest collections of vernacular sermons, the Vercelli Book and the Blickling Homilies, can both be dated by their manuscripts to the late tenth century, but the homilies within them were collected from different sources and must have circulated independently before their transmission in these manuscripts.Footnote 35 These homilies are anonymous compositions, usually translations or vernacular adaptations of Latin texts and to some extent characterised by their reliance upon apocryphal and Irish writings.Footnote 36 They can be contrasted with the works of Ælfric and Wulfstan who both consciously eschewed many of these sources and rely instead upon the Fathers, especially the works of Augustine, Jerome, Gregory the Great and Bede, often mediated through Carolingian sermon collections.Footnote 37 However, these new and more polished sermons by Ælfric and Wulfstan did not displace the anonymous traditions which continued to circulate into the eleventh century and beyond.
The sermons in the Blickling Homilies and Vercelli Book are exhortatory and moralising.Footnote 38 A significant number dwell upon the terrible Day of Judgement as a stirring prompt to penance and conversion from sin. The five out of the twenty-three sermons in the Vercelli Book, for example, describe the Day of Judgement or dwell upon the events presaging the End of the World.Footnote 39 Fear of Judgement Day provides a menacing motivation for repentance and Christian reform in this life. The homilies frequently remind their audience that at the final reckoning, men and women will present themselves to the great Judge, shorn of their earthly wealth and prestige and dependent for their fate only upon their good or evil deeds. While the role of intercession for the dead is acknowledged and encouraged, the audience is admonished that this will be ineffective unless the sinner has repented and striven to lead a good life. But the sinner will face Judgement alone – the support of earthly wealth and of friends and family will avail him or her nothing at Doomsday.Footnote 40 The horror of the body's decay on death is presented as a constant reminder to men of the pressing need to repent.Footnote 41 The aging and decay of the body announces the end of this life and the imminence of Doomsday.Footnote 42 The things of the world are transient as the earth too decays and hastens to its end.
A number of sermons describe the final days and Last Judgement. One sermon in the Blickling Homilies, which immediately precedes the homily composed in 971 cited earlier, announces the approaching End of the World and that the signs predicted in the Gospels have taken place, giving an idiosyncratic list of signs – ‘monstrous plagues and strange deaths’, terrible wars prompted by evil, ‘various diseases in many places of the world’ and a flourishing of evil and a cooling of love towards God.Footnote 43 But the homilist is less concerned to identify the signs of the End with present disasters than to use them as a springboard for admonitions to lead a virtuous Christian life, to give alms, do good and keep peace. The liturgical season of Easter provided the occasion in the Blickling Homilies for a detailed description of the Last Judgement, prompted by the belief that Christ's second advent would take place at Eastertide. It gives a lovingly long description of the harrowing of hell and of Judgement Day with an elaborate account of the six days leading up to it, adapted from the apocryphal Gospel of Thomas.Footnote 44 It closes with a chilling call to repentance in this life:
Wherefore we must now consider, the while we may and can, our soul's need, lest we lose this opportune time and desire to repent when we are no longer able…For God himself shall then take no heed of any man's penitence, and no intercession shall avail us there; but he will then be more relentless and remorseless than any wild beast, or than any anger might ever be. And as much as man's might was greater and he was the richer in this world, so much the more then shall the supreme Judge require from him.Footnote 45
Apocryphal texts and traditions were a significant element in Anglo-Saxon eschatology, particularly the Visio Pauli and other accounts of the afterlife. Footnote 46 One idiosyncratic tradition, probably derived from apocrypha concerning the Virgin Mary, recorded the belief that St Mary, St Peter and the Archangel Michael would successfully intercede for the forgiveness of sinners at Judgement Day itself.Footnote 47
Despite their fondness for such ideas, the anonymous homilies maintain a careful silence over the exact time of the End. But their concern is not to warn the world of the time of its End, but rather to impress upon individual sinners their pressing need for action. This they do with great vitality and dramatic colour which lends these texts real urgency and impact.Footnote 48 Their teaching was a powerful force in Anglo-Saxon religious life in the late tenth and eleventh centuries as the wide manuscript circulation of such homilies attests.
King Æthelred the Unready and the Day of Judgement
The discourse of the anonymous Old English homilies and the learned Latin of Anglo-Saxon charter diplomatic are usually confined to different and separate scholarly boxes, with the homilies the preserve of literary specialists and the charters reserved for hard-core historians.Footnote 49 However, the diplomatic formulae are suffused by eschatological motifs and ideas common to the anonymous homilies, and belonging to the same religious thought world. The proems in Anglo-Saxon charters are very often couched as a religious discourse, providing a motivation for the grant. Their sentiments often draw upon the same themes – the transience of earthly life, happiness and wealth and the need to exchange worldly riches for heavenly treasures and the decrepitude and final decay of the world.Footnote 50 In a charter of 994, for example, drafted by Archbishop Sigeric of Canterbury, the king is made to allude to his meditations on the transient earthly things and the eternal endurance of the spiritual. This follows a lengthy and elaboration preamble on the history of creation and of the Fall, which refers also to Christ's coming into the world after 5,000 years.Footnote 51
The religiosity of Anglo-Saxon charter diplomatic seems often to fit ill with the overtly secular nature of the transactions themselves, such as sales of land or apparently entirely secular grants to the laity. But, after 993, the diplomatic of a number of Æthelred's charters becomes more discursive and at times their proems have a clear thematic unity with the grant itself. These charters issue from the royal chancery and can be linked, as Pauline Stafford has suggested, with royal policy.Footnote 52 Levi Roach has made a strong case too for a performative context for their issuance.Footnote 53
Some charters place introspective sentiments in the mouth of the king, describing his motivation for the grant. These often include a desire for the expiation of the king's sins sometimes linked to a fear of divine judgement and to the need for the intercession of the saints. These charters are manifestations of the penitential style of Æthelred's kingship and these topoi are found in his charters restoring ecclesiastical lands. In a charter, returning property to Old Minster, Winchester, dated to 997, the king is made to say that his donation is motivated by the fear of the heavenly judge and of his provocation of the anger of Saints Peter and Paul, the patrons of the cathedral whose land had been despoiled with the connivance of the king. The charter proem cites a passage from Mark 13:19, concerning the tribulations which will precede the coming of the Kingdom.Footnote 54 Æthelred's need to appease the patron saint of the church which he had allowed to be robbed and to gain his suffrage is recorded again as a motive in a charter of the following year, 998, a restoration to Rochester Cathedral. Here, the king desires to win the favour of St Andrew who prayed for those who crucified him.Footnote 55
Both these donations of 997 and 998 were made in the season of Easter, either just after the feast or at Easter itself. It is an interesting, if speculative, exercise to consider their penitential stance and expressed fears of judgement in the light of the sermon for Easter Day contained in the Blickling Homilies, with its pressing exhortations for Christians to consider the fates of their souls at the Final Assize and not to lose the opportunity to make reparations for their sins before it is too late. One might recall the closing words of the homily with their admonition to the rich and powerful that more is expected of them at the Last Judgement than of lesser men.Footnote 56 This may be conjectural but there is a clear link between the Rochester charter and the apocryphal texts so favoured by the anonymous homilists in the appeal which Æthelred is made to make to St Andrew referring to the saint´s merciful stance at his crucifixion, which must be an allusion to an apocryphal passion of the saint.Footnote 57 It is worth noting that in allowing Old Minster, Winchester, and the Abbey of Abingdon to suffer at the hands of the laity, Æthelred might be thought to have offended against both St Peter and St Mary whom, as we have seen, were credited with a special role in saving sinners at Doomsday.
Explicit references to the Last Days are found sporadically, in a couple of charters in the late 990s, but what is more striking is the appearance of a distinctive set of diplomatic formulae around the year 1000 which culminates either in invocations of the Last Days or of the coming of the heavenly kingdom, and which coincides with donations made expressly for the salvation of Æthelred's family. Footnote 58 This is used in three grants of 1001, 1002 and 1004. Its last outing in 1004 took the form of the foundation charter for Burton Abbey, a Benedictine house. The grandiloquence and topicality of this style was probably why it was used for this solemn transaction.Footnote 59 However, the two donations of 1001 and 1002 are the most important in this discussion. These are grants to royal nunneries and Æthelred manifests in them a concern for the spiritual salvation of his family, a motivation also found in another charter from around the year 1000 concerning his father Edgar's bequests, but one which does not use this distinctive diplomatic.
The first of these donations (S 899) is a grant for Shaftesbury Abbey, a nunnery closely connected to the royal dynasty, to which the body of Edward the Martyr, Æthelred's murdered brother, had just been translated.Footnote 60 Æthelred made the gift of the church and estates at Bradford-on-Avon as a refuge against Viking attacks for the nuns and for the relics of his brother. This, the community's largest estate recorded in Doomsday Book, represented a very significant gift.Footnote 61 The proem culminates with the prediction of the signs of the End of the World from Luke 21:31–3 and the Gospel exhortation to give alms by selling one's goods. According to the charter, Æthelred's grant was prompted by frequent reminders on the part of his counsellors of these biblical exhortations. The grant is made not only for the expiation of his sins but also for those of his lineage, both past and future.Footnote 62
The second donation drafted in this way was made in 1002 to another royal nunnery, Wherwell in Hampshire, a foundation patronised by Æthelred's mother, Ælfthryth.Footnote 63 Here, the proem culminates in John the Baptist's exhortation, ‘Repent for the Kingdom of Heaven is at hand’, followed by the biblical commandments to honour one's father and mother. These penitential urgings have a direct connection with the grant itself which was probably made shortly after the death of the dowager queen. Æthelred not only makes a grant of privileges to the community, but confirms their possession of 70 hides of land at Wherwell, and added land elsewhere at Æthelingadene in Sussex. These lands had been held by the queen and it would appear that Wherwell sought Æthelred's donation in order to confirm its possession of the lands and to avoid their alienation to the new queen.Footnote 64 Æthelred is said to make the gift prompted by his fear of the Last Judgement and the donation is made for the souls of his parents, Edgar and Ælfthryth. By this grant, the king was not only protecting the community from the possible loss of the property but also his mother from the consequences of failing to secure the lands for the nunnery.
The king's explicit concern for the salvation of his family is also found in another remarkable donation, probably made in 999.Footnote 65 This was an act of compensation to Abingdon Abbey for land bequeathed by King Edgar but confiscated by the counsellors of his son, King Edward the Martyr. The property had been reserved for the benefit of the aethelings, the heirs to the throne, so must have been enjoyed by Æthelred and his sons. The king is made to explain in the charter that he feared his father's curse for the failure to fulfil his wishes, and Æthelred hopes to win by this grant the intercession of the Virgin Mary, the house's patron, and benefits for the souls of himself, his family and of Edgar.
These three transactions make manifest a notable concern on the part of Æthelred for the salvation of his family. In the Abingdon and Wherwell grants, he takes measures to ensure that property formerly in the hands of his parents was held by the religious communities who claimed it. Through the grant to Shaftesbury, the king sought the prayers of the community for his living, dead and future family, emphasising too the importance of his martyred brother's intercession. The grants to Shaftesbury and Wherwell are said to have been prompted by the urgings of his leading men and by thoughts of the Last Days and of the Final Judgement. Did the preaching of the anonymous homilies concerning the lonely fate of the soul at judgement, alone without the assistance of family and friends, play a part?
Æthelred's penitential restitutions of ecclesiastical land evince both a personal and public response to teaching about the Last Judgement. His gifts were made for the benefit of the souls of himself and his family but this demonstrative piety was a public gesture, articulated before his council and recorded in royal diplomas. Does the use of eschatological references and language in their formal diplomatic reflect intensified anticipation of the Last Days around the millennium? One explanation for these references is to see them as the outworkings of pressure placed upon the king by a group of monastic reform advocates at court, both clerical and lay, who included Aelfric's patrons, Æthelweard and Æthelmaer. The appearance of these references, like that of the restitutions themselves, coincides with the prominence at court of these men from 993 to 1006 and, as we have seen, the charters refer to the urgings of the royal councillors.Footnote 66 But this explanation does not exclude the possibility of the exploitation of millennial fears. Indeed, the solemnity of the grants and the very necessity for the transactions themselves would have been increased by its deployment. It was precisely this strategy of invoking the imminence of the Apocalypse to reinforce calls for reform which was used so skillfully only a few years later by Wulfstan of York.
Ælfric and the Last Days
The pressure of living in the Endtime weighed heavily upon Ælfric.Footnote 67 In the preface to his very first publication, the first series of Catholic Homilies, probably completed between 991 × 994, Ælfric sets out at some length an account of the Last Days, the Day of Judgement and the coming of the Antichrist. He opens this by setting out why he has taken upon himself the task of composing this set of sermons
because men have need of good instruction, especially at this time, which is the ending of the world, and there will be many calamities among mankind before the end comes, according to what our Lord in his Gospel said to his disciples, ‘Then shall be such tribulations as have never been from the beginning of the world. Many false christs shall come in my name, saying “I am Christ”’, and shall work many signs and wonders to deceive mankind…Everyone may the more easily understand the future temptation, through God's support, if he is strengthened by book learning, for they shall be preserved by faith to the end.’Footnote 68
Ælfric fears the deceptions and devilish seductions of the final age and seeks to arm the faithful against the wiles of the Antichrist by the provision of sound teaching. His writings show a frequent anxiety about erroneous teachings, which he labelled ‘gedwyld’, that is ‘heresy’.Footnote 69 This concern was partly prompted by the anonymous homilies with their reliance upon apocryphal and heterodox texts. Ælfric's recurrent concern for heretical teachings is linked to his understanding of the Endtime and its lessons. Moreover, he possibly shared the belief, evidenced in other reformed Benedictine writings, that the virgin order of monks would join the holy virgins, in the account of Revelation, who judge with Christ at Doomsday.Footnote 70 Thus, Ælfric's sense of his own identity was shaped by the looming presence of the Last Days. The economy of salvation was underpinned by the Last Judgement and the place of the monastic order within that economy was interpreted by reference to the Last Judgement.
Ælfric saw himself and his audience as living in the times of tribulation predicted in the Gospels. In one sermon, he noted carefully how many of the predicted signs of the End had occurred, checking them off against the Gospel passage –
But when Ælfric comes to the portents in the sun, moon and stars, he provides a careful analysis, arguing that lunar and solar eclipses and comets are portents but they are not the harbingers of the End, because they are not the unprecedented and extraordinary occurrences to which Christ referred. These and the turmoil of the sea have not yet happened so the time of the Antichrist has not yet come. His sense of the Last Day is also a long one – the universal earthquakes which he notes have happened are said to have taken place in the reign of the Emperor Tiberius.Footnote 71 This rather cool and clear-eyed approach to the signs of the End meshes with his reluctance to identify contemporary tribulations and catastrophes with the Gospel signs of the Last Days. This sermon draws upon the writings of Gregory the Great and the Carolingian exegete, Haimo of Auxerre, but Ælfric suppresses their statements about how disasters in their own times fulfil the Scriptural prophecy.Footnote 72 His approach here is to discourage portent-spotting.Footnote 73
But while Ælfric is reluctant to identify current catastrophes with the signs of the End, he sees the parlous state of society as a symptom of the Endtime. This is a period of great danger because the devil, furious that his time is now short, increases his attacks on mankind. Evils flourish as a presage of the greater evils to come, and society becomes more wicked. In his sermon, the Prayer of Moses, Ælfric identifies contemporary wickedness with the evil behaviour at the End of the World, in ideas and words drawn from the Bible. ‘This time is the last time, and the end of the world, and men are made unjust amongst themselves, so that father contends with his own son, and one brother with another, to their own destruction.’Footnote 74
Ælfric's reluctance to seek portents in his own age belongs to his deep sense of the unknowability of the time of the Last Days. His major eschatological sermon, on the Feastday of the Virgins, is partly devoted to the suppression of apocalyptic speculation.Footnote 75 He borrows from St Augustine to emphasise that signs of the End may appear to happen, but still Christ does not come.Footnote 76 This sermon impresses upon the believer the need for vigilance since death can come at any time. The sinner must repent and correct himself in this life to avoid eternal damnation. Christ's judgement on the Last Day is final and the damned are beyond help. Ælfric digresses explicitly to condemn the idea we have seen expressed in a homily in the Vercelli Book that the Virgin Mary would be able to save sinners at Judgement Day, describing this story as heretical.Footnote 77
This sermon seems to have acted as a vehicle for Ælfric's desire to suppress heterodoxy concerning the Apocalypse. He returned to it in around the year 1005, adding a few lines to the effect that the Antichrist would not come until the Roman Empire had fallen. Here, his meaning must be to point to the continuation of the Empire under the Franks and Ottonians, a view probably derived from Adso.Footnote 78
The imminence of the Last Judgement was as pressing for Ælfric as it was for his colleague Wulfstan, but his response to this pressure was rather different. With his concern for orthodoxy, Ælfric emphasised the unknowability of the time of the End. His concern for teaching on the Last Things did not diminish throughout his career, but manifested itself in renewed teaching in opposition to apocalyptic speculations.Footnote 79 And his audience for these admonitions is likely to have included the English religious and secular elite.
Wulfstan and the loosening of Satan's bonds
At the core of Ælfric's homilies lies a pastoral duty towards the individual Christian and his salvation. The preaching of Wulfstan, however, is rather concerned with the condition of society and calls for the spiritual reformation of the English people. It is he who preaches most urgently about the imminence of the Last Days and who clearly identifies the present with the signs preceding the coming of the Antichrist.Footnote 80
Wulfstan composed five sermons in Old English on the Last Days.Footnote 81 These have been considered to be some of his earliest compositions and dated to around the year 1000. Dorothy Bethurum even surmised that Wulfstan owed his elevation to the see of York in 1002 to his prowess as a Doomsday preacher.Footnote 82 However, Malcolm Godden has recently pointed out on the basis of strong textual evidence (borrowings from the homilies of Ælfric) that the last of his five sermons must date to after 1006 and may have been composed as late as 1012, and that his fourth and penultimate homily very probably dates to after 1005.Footnote 83 While this revised chronology appears only a slight shift, it has significant consequences. For rather than Wulfstan's Doomsday sermons being an early period in his preaching career, a kind of apocalyptic phase (or even apoplectic) which he got over, rather they belong to the period of his archiepiscopacy and to the time when he was a major influence at Æthelred's court. Indeed, not only is at least one version of his famous sermon, the Sermo Lupi ad Anglos, preached probably in the years after 1012, heavily eschatological, but Joyce Lionarons has pointed out that a later sermon of Wulfstan's with significant apocalyptic content was perhaps preached at Cnut's court in 1018.Footnote 84
Wulfstan's five eschatological sermons show him reacting and responding to the increasingly desperate times of the first decade of the millennium. The first of his sermons is a fairly straightforward paraphrase of Matthew's Gospel on the signs of the End. He warns of the terrible times to come but states confidently that the End will not happen until the Gospel has been preached around the world, a fact which he appears to forget in his later preaching.Footnote 85 His second sermon represents a very significant shift as the archbishop identifies the Viking attacks as the Gospel sign of the Last Days that ‘Nation will rise up against nation.’ This sermon continues, alluding obliquely to Isaiah 24, by explaining that the English are being punished for their sins by the infertility of the earth and by the dearth caused by storms.Footnote 86
Like Ælfric, Wulfstan was influenced by Adso's tract on the Antichrist which provided the theme for his last three sermons. The first of these, in Latin and Old English, exploits the idea of the Antichrist to denounce false Christians, those who profess Christianity but do not practise it. In this sermon, the time of terror is less proximate – he states that many alive today will not live to see the Antichrist.Footnote 87
But his mood shifts in his last two sermons. His fourth, perhaps written after 1005, displays great urgency: ‘Now it will very quickly be Antichrist's time.’ Wulfstan warns his audience that, because the Antichrist will come so soon, his persecution of the good will have to be very terrible to purge them of their sins before the Final Judgement: ‘Those who have been dead for a hundred years or even longer may now be well cleansed. We may need to suffer more harshly, if we must be clean when judgement comes.’Footnote 88
His final sermon contains the striking warning of the closeness of the End by its description of Satan's loosening bonds, quoted at the beginning of this article.Footnote 89 It begins by identifying the present wickedness of the English with St Paul's account in 2 Timothy of the intense evil of the Last Days when men's love of God cools: ‘No one loves God as a person should. No one remains faithful to anything, but injustice rules far and wide, and loyalty among people is uncertain, and that is seen in many ways, let him know it who can.’Footnote 90
The revised dating of these sermons allows us to see them in the longer context of the desperate times of the first decade or so of the first millennium, in the context of the great famine of 1005, the escalation of Viking raids after 1006 and set them alongside the lawcodes and penitential measures of 1008 and 1009. Indeed, there may be some direct correspondences between them and these events. Wulfstan's words explaining how storms and destitution of the earth represent God's punishment could refer to the dearth of 1005, which the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle described as ‘such that no man had ever remembered one so cruel’.Footnote 91 Wulfstan's final sermon remarks how Antichrist will work many illusions through sorcery, and an interpolation in his fourth sermon, which may well be authorial, warns specifically against the wicked actions of the devil in the past through sorcery.Footnote 92 These were a symptom of the Antichrist's deceit and hypocrisy. One version of Æthelred's lawcode promulgated at Enham in 1008 demands that sorcerors and magicians should be driven from the kingdom. Is this a coincidence? This Latin text was drafted by Wulfstan, and was perhaps specifically intended for the higher clergy.Footnote 93 It concludes with a statement that the king had decreed these measures to extirpate evil and injustice from the land so that truth and justice might prevail, and peace and plenty be restored to the kingdom.Footnote 94 This code was the first drafted for Æthelred by Wulfstan himself and it sets out his programme for the Christian renewal of the kingdom, and imposes upon the English obedience to God's commands. Its extensive regulation of the Christian life can be seen as a response to Wulfstan's cataloguing of contemporary sins in his eschatological sermons.Footnote 95 Patrick Wormald described this code – with his usual panache – as ‘throbbing’ with Wulfstan's ‘millenarian expectations’.Footnote 96 He argued that Wulfstan took up authorship of Æthelred's lawcodes precisely because of his apocalyptic preaching and vision.Footnote 97
As archbishop, Wulfstan was charged with the provision of moral leadership to the religious and secular orders. His response to the question of the Last Days attended to the condition of English society and it is no coincidence that it was he who was emboldened to identify present evils with signs of the End and to deploy explicitly the coming of the year 1000 to intensify the urgency of his preaching.
Conclusion
O’Leary has suggested that
apocalypticism cannot be only understood as a series of movements with discrete and identifiable causes in historical events, but must also be seen as a tradition, a textually embodied community of discourse founded in the canon of Western sacred Scripture and occasionally augmented by the production of new revelations and interpretative strategies.Footnote 98
His observation agrees with the Anglo-Saxon eschatological and apocalyptic evidence. The writings of Ælfric and Wulfstan are commentaries, informed by the exegesis of earlier Fathers, upon the Sacred Scripture. But these textual traditions are not static and unchanging but dynamic – Wulfstan interprets the teachings of Gospels to refer to the Viking attacks. Ælfric reuses the writings of Gregory the Great and Haimo of Auxerre but suppresses their identification of contemporary disasters with the Gospel signs of the End. But Ælfric writes in response to the apocryphal teachings of the anonymous homilies which, he fears, misled the faithful into complacency concerning the Final Judgement.Footnote 99 His own words in his preface on Antichrist were borrowed by Wulfstan for his fourth homily, which he then himself reshaped to create his fifth homily.
Adso's tract on the Antichrist provided a significant impetus to apocalyptic discourse. Both Wulfstan and Ælfric were advocates of monastic reform but their use of Adso was very different and, at one point, in conflict. Ælfric used the Antichrist in his preface to Catholic Homilies I to assert the need for his learning over the dangers of the deviant doctrine of others. Wulfstan exploited the potential of the terrors of the time of the Antichrist to ratchet up fears of the Last Days and to press for immediate reform. But Ælfric could use Adso's teaching to the opposite effect, to dampen down apocalyptic expectations by pointing out the Empire must fall before his coming.
These are not just textual interactions but must in some way represent and reflect living dialogues and personal encounters. Ælfric's correction of apocryphal stories about the Last Judgement was a response not just to texts in circulation but to current preaching. His addition c. 1005 concerning the Empire and the Antichrist looks like a response to contemporary speculation fuelled by the dire situation of the English. Ælfric was reacting to live issues, perhaps even to the preaching of Wulfstan. Through the later dating of Wulfstan's five apocalyptic homilies, we can see too the evolution of Wulfstan's thought. His thinking was shaped by recent disasters and he in turn tried to influence current events by his appeal for social reformation. Wulfstan's apocalyptic sermons are more than the powerful rhetoric of an inspired preacher – the translation of his preaching into legislative action indicates his seriousness in this respect.
Wulfstan's 1008 code was issued at a royal council of religious and secular magnates, and promulgated by the king.Footnote 100 His eschatological ideas must have been discussed at court where they may have met with both acceptance and resistance. Certainly, the evidence for apocalyptic speculation in England around the year 1000 points to elite deliberation, not popular. The use of apocalyptic citations in Æthelred's charters may well reflect courtly concerns and a heightened awareness of the proximity of the Last Days. From his elevation to the see of London in 996, Wulfstan will have been a powerful figure in the royal council. The charters of Æthelred reveal the anxieties of a king who faced Judgement Day with a greater burden of responsibility than his people. The penitential discourse of the charters is a testimony to the intersection of royal policy and personal piety. Early medieval lay piety was heavily focused upon the family and the obligation of the kindred to obtain intercession for their dead. In the years around 1000, Æthelred took special measures to provide for the salvation of his family, showing special solicitude to rectify any omissions or failures with respect to the disposition of lands earmarked for the church. Did his anxiety reflect a feeling that Satan's bonds were indeed loosening and that the time for expurgation was running out? The right ordering of the family was an essential aspect of kingly conduct. It may have come into greater scrutiny at a time where the conflict of brother against brother and father against son was seen as a sign of the extreme evil of the Last Days.
Anglo-Saxon England in the late tenth and eleventh centuries was a place of many and often conflicting ideas about the Last Days and Final Judgement. These four examples exemplify different but interlocking and overlapping discourses. They each show anxiety about the Endtime but respond to it in different ways. Thinking about the Apocalypse was influenced not just by chronology. The unremitting Viking successes coupled with the terrible famine of 1005 provided a stimulus to apocalyptic thought. But then so too did traditional piety and the circulation of new texts, like the tract of Adso. While the responses of my three subjects, Æthelred, Ælfric and Wulfstan, reveal contrasting reactions to the imminence of the Last Judgement, for all of them it was a pressing concern and an essential element in their lives and conduct.
