During the past few decades, scholars have published several urban histories of Ottoman Istanbul. Some have been overviews that focus on the city's social history (Ebru Boyar and Kate Fleet, A Social History of Ottoman Istanbul [New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010]), others have looked at issues of violence, crime, and punishment (Roger Deal, Crimes of Honor, Drunken Brawls, and Murder: Violence in Istanbul under Abdülhamid II [Istanbul: Libra Kitap, 2005] and Fariba Zarinebaf, Crime and Punishment in Istanbul: 1700–1800 [Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 2010]), while still others have explored architecture and urban planning during the 19th century (Zeynep Çelik, The Remaking of Istanbul: Portrait of an Ottoman City in the Nineteenth Century [Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 1986] and Empire, Architecture, and the City: French-Ottoman Encounters, 1830–1914 [Seattle, Wash.: University of Washington Press, 2008]). Noémi Lévy-Aksu's new book is a very welcome addition to this growing literature. Although this is the author's first monograph, Lévy-Aksu has been making significant scholarly contributions to the study of urban policing, public order, violence, and discipline in the late Ottoman Empire for almost a decade, with the publication of two co-edited volumes and several book chapters and journal articles.
Lévy-Aksu's book is based on a variety of rich source material that includes the local, foreign, and imperial press, state documents from the Ottoman Ministry of the Interior and Police, memoirs, professional police journals, travel literature, consular reports and other diplomatic correspondence, and local court records. These sources allow the author to develop a much deeper perspective on issues associated with social control and discipline for this time period than has been presented in previous scholarship. Most of the recent work on this topic has been from the perspective of the state, particularly in relation to its police forces (see Ferdan Ergut's Modern Devlet ve Polis, Osmanlı’dan Cumhuriyet'e Toplumsal Nenetimin Diyalektiği [Police and the Modern State: The Dialectic of Social Control from the Ottoman Empire to the Republic of Turkey] [Istanbul: İletișim Yayınları, 2004] and several articles by Nadir Özbek on internal security within the Ottoman state and the gendarme forces). Lévy-Aksu, however, focuses on both state institutions and societal actors as they pertain to the urban spaces of Istanbul. Her approach to public order is very nuanced and dynamic, because she integrates state-centered efforts, legislation, and institutions with local forces and interests in the quarters of the city, particularly the district of Tophane. These local actors include religious leaders, administrative officials, night watchmen (bekçi), and local powerbrokers or gangs (kabadayı).
This approach provides insights into conceptualizations of deviance, crime, order, and urban space during an extremely volatile period in Istanbul's history. From 1830 to 1909, Istanbul's population nearly tripled to over one million inhabitants. Rapid urbanization, industrialization, the introduction and spread of capitalist market relations, the huge influx of Muslim refugees from the Balkans and Caucasus, European imperial encroachment, significant attempts at imperial administrative, political, and cultural transformation, and severe violence throughout the empire, particularly among the Armenians of Eastern Anatolia, had an enormous impact on the social and political fabric of the Ottoman capital. It is within this nexus that Lévy-Aksu situates her study, starting with the creation of the first formal police force in 1879 and ending with the deposition of Abdülhamid II and the creation of the Directorate of Public Security in 1909.
Her study is broken into three parts. The first section deals with the concepts and vocabulary of order and disorder in 19th-century Istanbul in order to demonstrate their fluidity and plurality and their intersection with physical space, moral issues, security concerns, as well as the political and social cultures of the day, thus setting the context for the rest of the study. The second section looks at state efforts at defining and exerting social control and discipline on Hamidian Istanbul through the creation and refinement of centralized policing institutions and forces from 1879 to 1909. This section pays special attention to continuity and change of discourse and action associated with urban order and disorder.
Finally, building upon the two previous sections, the third section investigates the interactions between the state and official as well as unofficial local actors during the state's attempt to create public order in Istanbul's Tophane district. The author attempts to uncover the nuanced discourse and developments that surround the different conceptualizations and practices associated with urban/public order and disorder. She argues that new conceptualizations of crime, criminal behavior, dangerous persons, nightlife, immigration, internal security, and identity developed and transformed over the course of the 19th century until the Second Constitutional Period. These developments and transformations were not unilaterally imposed by the state upon local residents of Istanbul, but were contested, co-opted, and augmented by local actors, many of whom were directly affected by the incredible demographic, economic, and social changes occurring within Istanbul. The voices and influences that Lévy-Aksu uncovers in the Tophane district demonstrate the convoluted and contested realities and conceptualizations of order and disorder within the empire's capital that previous scholarship ignored or was unable to uncover as a result of its state-centered focus. The creation and expansion of Ottoman policing throughout the empire, but particularly in its capital, was not linear, but consisted of a blending of older local institutions, such as night watchmen and local powerbrokers, together with fledgling state institutions. The insights and dynamics that Lévy-Aksu uncovers fill a major gap in our understanding of late Ottoman Istanbul's urban history.
This reviewer has two quibbles with the work. The first concerns Lévy-Aksu's problematic and repeated use of the term “Young Turk” to signify an opposition movement against Sultan Abdülhamid II. This term is misleading and incorrect. Members of the various opposition groups located within the empire rarely if ever referred to themselves as “Young Turks,” especially because the term is foreign and, more particularly, of Western/French origin. They also consisted of ethnically, linguistically, religiously, and politically diverse constituencies united in their opposition to Sultan Abdülhamid II. The term obfuscates this diversity and presumes an anachronistic ethno-nationalist predilection that was not widespread at this point in the empire.
My other quibble concerns the book's woefully inadequate index that consists of only forty-one terms. The benefits of a well-constructed and thorough index cannot be overemphasized, especially for a text of such rich description, varied source material, and complex terminology. Fortunately, the book does include a very serviceable glossary, but the book's usefulness to scholars and students alike is hampered by its paltry index.
Let me emphasize that this book makes a major contribution to the study of the late Ottoman Empire, particularly in terms of urban studies, criminal justice, policing and crime, governmentality, and social history. It is clearly written, thoroughly sourced, and convincingly argued. It effectively links both the imperial and local together and represents many of the best developments in Ottoman studies today. I have already assigned it to graduate students and enthusiastically recommend it to students and scholars alike.
