Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) argue that we should practice what we teach in our industrial and organizational (I-O) psychology and other classes. What we teach when we cover principles of training should be incorporated into how we conduct our classes. These principles apply equally to corporate training and university instruction. Our students should not be the shoemaker’s children who fail to benefit from our knowledge about training that we as a field freely share with everyone else. I will expand upon points made by Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) about applying what we know about training to the bottom-line issue of knowledge retention and how we can design our classes to maximize what our students will remember long after completing our course.
We know a great deal about learning that can inform how we design our classes for retention. Memory is not like a computer where once we learn something it remains in storage. Over time memories fade, but how we design our courses can help our students retain what they learned. I will focus on three elements in teaching that we should consider.
1. Amount of material covered
2. Overlearning
3. Spaced learning
Amount of material covered
There is a tendency for conscientious faculty to make classes as rigorous as possible by including as much material as it is feasible to cover. One of our USF undergraduates, Shelby Waymire, referred to this as turning students into information dumpsters (Spector & Howard, Reference Spector and Howard2019). There are two problems with the dumpster approach. It encourages cramming for examinations through rote memorization instead of understanding, and it leads to poor retention.
There is always a trade-off between breadth and depth in a course, but it would serve retention better to cover less material in more depth. In an undergraduate I-O class I spend a lot of time talking about KSAOs (knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics). From experience I know that most students can accurately define each component on exams. One day in class I asked the students to write down an example of a K, S, A, and O, as well as a job task, and I invited them to share their examples. What we all learned is that students could memorize definitions, but they did not really understand the concepts. The experience changed how I taught KSAOs and other concepts even though it meant sacrificing time for extra content.
Overlearning
It is widely believed that overlearning is an effective way to increase retention. In an educational setting, overlearning means giving students extra practice trials after they initially achieve a learning criterion—students learn and then overlearn. In the typical overlearning experiment, learners are randomly assigned to either just enough trials to learn the material or to extra trials after learning occurred. Such studies are consistent in showing that retention is better with overlearning (Driskell etal., Reference Driskell, Willis and Copper1992).
It should be kept in mind, however, that overlearning experiments are typically done using short time frames of a week or less. But does retention for say a week translate into long-term retention? Research by Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Taylor, Pashler, Wixted and Cepeda2005) suggests that it does not. They used the typical overlearning paradigm where learners, in this case college students, were randomly assigned to the learning versus overlearning condition. Retention was considerably higher for overlearners after 1 week, but that difference all but disappeared at 9 weeks.
The Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Taylor, Pashler, Wixted and Cepeda2005) results suggest that overlearning is not an effective strategy for long-term retention. Overlearning might be a reasonable strategy when short-term retention is the goal, such as when cramming for an upcoming exam. It is not an effective means for longer retention. Thus, the popular method of giving lots of practice problems to achieve overlearning is not a useful strategy for learning that extends beyond the next exam. To achieve longer term retention requires a different strategy, which takes us to the issue of spaced learning.
Spaced learning
If overlearning is not the answer to retention, what is? Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) mentioned the work of Pashler etal. (Reference Pashler, Rohrer, Cepeda and Carpenter2007), who studied the effects of spaced learning trials on learning, that is, spreading learning over days, weeks, and longer. The work by Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Taylor, Pashler, Wixted and Cepeda2005) addresses the effect of learning-trial spacing and how it affects long-term retention. In these studies learners are randomly assigned to conditions in which the length of time between learning trials, and the length of the retention interval are manipulated. Learners are given repeated learning trials on material that varied across studies from moments to months, and retention is investigated for periods that can span years (Bahrick etal., Reference Bahrick, Bahrick, Bahrick and Bahrick1993). In general across a number of studies, the longer the intertrial interval, the longer the retention (Rohrer & Pashler, Reference Rohrer and Pashler2007). Rohrer and Pashler estimated that the ideal gap between learning trials is 10%–30% of the retention interval. In other words, for retention of one year, the ideal interval would be between 7 weeks and 3.6 months.
This line of research suggests that for long-term retention, intertrial intervals should be quite long. This means that concepts that are learned across classes in different semesters are likely to have the longest retention. This has implications for curriculum design where coordination might occur among department faculty that are teaching different courses for their majors so that key concepts are covered in multiple courses. Within a single class, this strategy can be incorporated by revisiting concepts throughout the semester. Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) noted this approach in their discussion of incorporating themes into a course.
One concept that can be incorporated into courses is interleaving, that is, mixing different kinds of problems during learning trials. Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Dedrick, Hartwig and Cheung2020) demonstrated the superiority of this effect in a field experiment of middle school mathematics instruction. The typical way that mathematics concepts are taught is sequentially, one concept at a time. In a statistics course for example, the instructor might cover z tests in class and then assign six practice problems. Next would be dependent t tests with six practice problems, then independent group t tests and six practice problems, and so on throughout the course. Interleaving means mixing the practice problems so that as new concepts are covered, practice problem sets include old as well as new concepts. For example, after covering independent group t tests, there would be two practice problems for that test, and then there would be practice problems for the previously covered z test and dependent t test. The interleaving results in spacing the practice trials, and it requires deeper cognitive processing. Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Dedrick, Hartwig and Cheung2020) were able to show that interleaving produced superior retention on a surprise quiz over the material.
Incorporating spacing into your own classes is not always easy. Carpenter etal. (Reference Carpenter, Cepeda, Rohrer, Kang and Pashler2012) present three ways to build in spacing. Keep in mind, spacing does not have to only occur during class.
-
Incorporate brief reviews of earlier material each day in class. This would be only a few minutes and would focus on important concepts that you want to be sure students retain.
-
Homework assignments can address earlier material in the course. This can be a good way to consolidate understanding by assigning active learning exercises.
-
Give cumulative examinations that include material from earlier in the course. Students can be given guidance about the important concepts that they must know from earlier parts of the course rather than expecting them to recall everything (note the earlier discussion about overdoing content).
I will add a fourth suggestion.
-
Integrate topics across the course that will result in older material being reintroduced. For example, you can talk about employee selection in the context of many other topics, such as selecting for job satisfaction, for motivation, or for safety. Diversity can be linked to many different topics, such as selection, leadership, and teams.
Teaching for retention
When we teach training, we explain the importance of transfer from the training setting back to the job. For our teaching this means that students retain material beyond the class so they can transfer it to their lives. The same principles of training that enhance transfer can be applied to university teaching. Father Guido Sarducci, the comic character created by Don Novello, recognized the retention issue in university teaching with his tongue-in-cheek 5-minute university routine. At the 5-Minute University, students learn in 5 minutes everything the average college student will remember 5 years after graduation. If we incorporate what we teach about training into our own teaching, we can give our students a shot at retaining what we teach for 5 years and beyond.
Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) argue that we should practice what we teach in our industrial and organizational (I-O) psychology and other classes. What we teach when we cover principles of training should be incorporated into how we conduct our classes. These principles apply equally to corporate training and university instruction. Our students should not be the shoemaker’s children who fail to benefit from our knowledge about training that we as a field freely share with everyone else. I will expand upon points made by Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) about applying what we know about training to the bottom-line issue of knowledge retention and how we can design our classes to maximize what our students will remember long after completing our course.
We know a great deal about learning that can inform how we design our classes for retention. Memory is not like a computer where once we learn something it remains in storage. Over time memories fade, but how we design our courses can help our students retain what they learned. I will focus on three elements in teaching that we should consider.
1. Amount of material covered
2. Overlearning
3. Spaced learning
Amount of material covered
There is a tendency for conscientious faculty to make classes as rigorous as possible by including as much material as it is feasible to cover. One of our USF undergraduates, Shelby Waymire, referred to this as turning students into information dumpsters (Spector & Howard, Reference Spector and Howard2019). There are two problems with the dumpster approach. It encourages cramming for examinations through rote memorization instead of understanding, and it leads to poor retention.
There is always a trade-off between breadth and depth in a course, but it would serve retention better to cover less material in more depth. In an undergraduate I-O class I spend a lot of time talking about KSAOs (knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics). From experience I know that most students can accurately define each component on exams. One day in class I asked the students to write down an example of a K, S, A, and O, as well as a job task, and I invited them to share their examples. What we all learned is that students could memorize definitions, but they did not really understand the concepts. The experience changed how I taught KSAOs and other concepts even though it meant sacrificing time for extra content.
Overlearning
It is widely believed that overlearning is an effective way to increase retention. In an educational setting, overlearning means giving students extra practice trials after they initially achieve a learning criterion—students learn and then overlearn. In the typical overlearning experiment, learners are randomly assigned to either just enough trials to learn the material or to extra trials after learning occurred. Such studies are consistent in showing that retention is better with overlearning (Driskell etal., Reference Driskell, Willis and Copper1992).
It should be kept in mind, however, that overlearning experiments are typically done using short time frames of a week or less. But does retention for say a week translate into long-term retention? Research by Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Taylor, Pashler, Wixted and Cepeda2005) suggests that it does not. They used the typical overlearning paradigm where learners, in this case college students, were randomly assigned to the learning versus overlearning condition. Retention was considerably higher for overlearners after 1 week, but that difference all but disappeared at 9 weeks.
The Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Taylor, Pashler, Wixted and Cepeda2005) results suggest that overlearning is not an effective strategy for long-term retention. Overlearning might be a reasonable strategy when short-term retention is the goal, such as when cramming for an upcoming exam. It is not an effective means for longer retention. Thus, the popular method of giving lots of practice problems to achieve overlearning is not a useful strategy for learning that extends beyond the next exam. To achieve longer term retention requires a different strategy, which takes us to the issue of spaced learning.
Spaced learning
If overlearning is not the answer to retention, what is? Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) mentioned the work of Pashler etal. (Reference Pashler, Rohrer, Cepeda and Carpenter2007), who studied the effects of spaced learning trials on learning, that is, spreading learning over days, weeks, and longer. The work by Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Taylor, Pashler, Wixted and Cepeda2005) addresses the effect of learning-trial spacing and how it affects long-term retention. In these studies learners are randomly assigned to conditions in which the length of time between learning trials, and the length of the retention interval are manipulated. Learners are given repeated learning trials on material that varied across studies from moments to months, and retention is investigated for periods that can span years (Bahrick etal., Reference Bahrick, Bahrick, Bahrick and Bahrick1993). In general across a number of studies, the longer the intertrial interval, the longer the retention (Rohrer & Pashler, Reference Rohrer and Pashler2007). Rohrer and Pashler estimated that the ideal gap between learning trials is 10%–30% of the retention interval. In other words, for retention of one year, the ideal interval would be between 7 weeks and 3.6 months.
This line of research suggests that for long-term retention, intertrial intervals should be quite long. This means that concepts that are learned across classes in different semesters are likely to have the longest retention. This has implications for curriculum design where coordination might occur among department faculty that are teaching different courses for their majors so that key concepts are covered in multiple courses. Within a single class, this strategy can be incorporated by revisiting concepts throughout the semester. Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) noted this approach in their discussion of incorporating themes into a course.
One concept that can be incorporated into courses is interleaving, that is, mixing different kinds of problems during learning trials. Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Dedrick, Hartwig and Cheung2020) demonstrated the superiority of this effect in a field experiment of middle school mathematics instruction. The typical way that mathematics concepts are taught is sequentially, one concept at a time. In a statistics course for example, the instructor might cover z tests in class and then assign six practice problems. Next would be dependent t tests with six practice problems, then independent group t tests and six practice problems, and so on throughout the course. Interleaving means mixing the practice problems so that as new concepts are covered, practice problem sets include old as well as new concepts. For example, after covering independent group t tests, there would be two practice problems for that test, and then there would be practice problems for the previously covered z test and dependent t test. The interleaving results in spacing the practice trials, and it requires deeper cognitive processing. Rohrer etal. (Reference Rohrer, Dedrick, Hartwig and Cheung2020) were able to show that interleaving produced superior retention on a surprise quiz over the material.
Incorporating spacing into your own classes is not always easy. Carpenter etal. (Reference Carpenter, Cepeda, Rohrer, Kang and Pashler2012) present three ways to build in spacing. Keep in mind, spacing does not have to only occur during class.
Incorporate brief reviews of earlier material each day in class. This would be only a few minutes and would focus on important concepts that you want to be sure students retain.
Homework assignments can address earlier material in the course. This can be a good way to consolidate understanding by assigning active learning exercises.
Give cumulative examinations that include material from earlier in the course. Students can be given guidance about the important concepts that they must know from earlier parts of the course rather than expecting them to recall everything (note the earlier discussion about overdoing content).
I will add a fourth suggestion.
Integrate topics across the course that will result in older material being reintroduced. For example, you can talk about employee selection in the context of many other topics, such as selecting for job satisfaction, for motivation, or for safety. Diversity can be linked to many different topics, such as selection, leadership, and teams.
Teaching for retention
When we teach training, we explain the importance of transfer from the training setting back to the job. For our teaching this means that students retain material beyond the class so they can transfer it to their lives. The same principles of training that enhance transfer can be applied to university teaching. Father Guido Sarducci, the comic character created by Don Novello, recognized the retention issue in university teaching with his tongue-in-cheek 5-minute university routine. At the 5-Minute University, students learn in 5 minutes everything the average college student will remember 5 years after graduation. If we incorporate what we teach about training into our own teaching, we can give our students a shot at retaining what we teach for 5 years and beyond.