This is G. E. R. Lloyd's second collected edition of articles, following on from Methods and Problems in Greek Science (Cambridge, 1991), in which were collected the most important of his articles from the previous three decades. This volume contains fifteen papers published between 1987 and 2005, presented in the variorum format, i.e. as originally published, with the original page numbering, footnoting and so on, but with updated supplementary bibliographies at the end of each section, and some supplementary notes at the end of the volume. There are three sections: the first on ‘Greek medicine’, the second on ‘Greek mathematics and philosophy’ and the third on ‘Greek and Chinese comparisons’. Lloyd himself (pp. ix–x) analyses the volume into three conceptual themes: disciplinary boundaries, what and where they are, and how one field is to be contrasted with another; polemics, and how ancient scientific authors can be more concerned with legitimacy and prestige than with their subjects; and open-endedness and unpredictability in ancient scientific investigations. ‘There was nothing inevitable’, judges Lloyd, ‘about the way they developed’ (p. ix).
The first section contains five papers, two on broad questions in ancient medicine and three focused more narrowly on Galen. ‘The transformations of ancient medicine’ concentrates on the history of the reception of Greek medicine, and how changing interpretations of ancient medicine have influenced the theory and practice of modern medicine. The authority of the ancient authors was such that as late as 1833, at Oxford, bachelors of medicine were examined on two out of the four principal ancient writers. Next up is ‘The definition, status, and methods of the medical technē in the fifth and fourth centuries’, which explores the arguments surrounding just what the technē of medicine was, who had the authority to practise it, and how iatroi were distinguished from other medical practitioners such as midwives. ‘Scholarship, authority and argument in Galen's Quod animi mores’ carries on the study of the authority and scope of the medic, with a look at how Galen inverted the arguments of Gorgias to prove that the doctor, rather than the philosopher, is best able to cure people. In ‘Theories and practices of demonstration in Galen’, Lloyd studies Galen's focus on advocacy of proper scientific method and, especially, demonstration, and his insistence on proper training in logic. And in ‘Mathematics as a model of method in Galen’, Lloyd similarly concentrates on Galen's logic and scientific method.
In the second section there are six papers on quite a variety of topics, from Hippocrates of Chios to ancient theories of the origin of species. In ‘The alleged fallacy of Hippocrates of Chios’, Lloyd investigates what fallacy Aristotle, Eudemus and Alexander accuse Hippocrates of Chios of using in his work on the quadrature of lunes, and sets out to argue that, indeed, Hippocrates himself is to be exonerated from any fallacy. ‘The Meno and the mystery of mathematics’ examines ‘the maze of interpretation’ surrounding the method of hypothesis outlined in Meno 86e ff., and concludes not only that Plato is being deliberately obscure, but that the gates of the Academy should have been inscribed not with mēdeis ageōmetrētos eisitō, but with lasciate ogni speranza voi ch'entrate – a conclusion this reviewer heartily endorses. In ‘Plato and Archytas in the seventh letter’, Lloyd enters another tangled web – the debate over the authorship of the seventh letter – and argues that Plato should not be entirely ruled out as the author, suggesting that, whoever the author is, he seems to ‘seek to dissociate Plato from Archytas and to stress his independence from Pythagoreanism’ (VIII.173). The next piece, ‘Philosophy and medicine in ancient Greece: cognitive models and their repercussions’, studies the themes of alliance and rivalry between philosophy and medicine, stressing the importance of the alternatives to Platonism put forward in some medical writers. In ‘The pluralism of intellectual life before Plato’, Lloyd asks the question ‘what is Presocratic philosophy?’, concluding that even into the fourth century ‘the boundaries between disciplines in many instances remained both contested and fluid’, and that in any area of intellectual endeavour – philosophy, ‘sophistry’, mathematics, medicine and so on – ‘there was exceptional room for manoeuvre as to what these activities should comprise’ (X.12–13). Finally, in ‘The evolution of Evolution: Greco-Roman antiquity and the origin of species’, Lloyd investigates ancient theories of the origin of species, arguing that we should take care to avoid projecting our own concerns back onto the history of these ideas and thus turning ancient theories into ‘forerunners of Darwin’ and so on. This is a very stimulating paper first published in Spanish in 2001, and it is simply unfortunate timing that its first publication in English should have been overshadowed by David Sedley's masterly Creationism and Its Critics in Antiquity (Berkeley, 2007).
Four papers on Greek and Chinese themes make up the third section. In ‘Appearance versus reality: Greek and Chinese comparisons and contrasts’, Lloyd shows how, unlike the Greeks, Chinese thinkers never saw any great disjunction between appearance and reality, and recognized no special truth that could be achieved by reason alone. Similarly in ‘Mythology: reflections from a Chinese perspective’, Lloyd well explains how for Chinese thinkers there was no major distinction made between rational and mythological modes of thought or modes of exposition. Again Greece and China are contrasted in ‘Literacy in Greek and Chinese science: some comparative issues’. The Greek setting of rhetorical competition for prestige in the production of wisdom was, we learn, quite absent in China, where consensus, authority and harmony dominated. Finally, in ‘Is there a future for ancient science?’, Lloyd gives us his valedictory lecture on his retirement from teaching in 2001. The answer, of course, is ‘yes’!
The question with such an edition is always, of course, whether it is really more than the sum of its parts. The answer with this volume is a guarded positive; having them all together provides a richer reading experience than hopping between them separately would but, at the same time, the wide range of themes of the papers does make it difficult to train them all together into a well-behaved book.
