Two misconceptions of the social and political thought of Pope Francis are not uncommon in the United States. The first arises from the Catholic Left, that is, those who railed against the excesses of the previous two popes, especially in their dim view of Latin American liberation theology. In this view, Francis has set a decisive new course that retrieves the lost progressive heritage of the Second Vatican Council. The second arises from conservatives. They are disturbed not only by the outcome of the Synods on the Family in the pastoral care of the divorced and remarried (and moral questions in general) but also by the Peronist economics of the Argentine pope. In the words of Steve Bannon, delivered fittingly in an interview conducted via Skype to a group assembled at the Vatican, Pope Francis knows only “crony capitalism” and is inevitably bound to favor that South American aberration over the more market-friendly economic heritage of the Judeo-Christian West.
Thomas R. Rourke is a disciple of Yves Simon who has also written a book about the social thought of Pope Benedict. He traveled frequently to Argentina in the time of Cardinal Bergoglio (his wife is Argentine) and can speak on the basis of pre-episcopal and episcopal sources as well as from direct experiences of Argentinian social and political life. His portrait explodes both the liberal Catholic and conservative myths. Its most distinctive feature is the insistence on the nonliberal and even premodern frame of Pope Francis's politics. Bergoglio is not just a creator of media-savvy public gestures and unscheduled trips to prisons and the urban slums. There is a method to the madness, which is brought into relief by a close look at the Argentine sources.
As it turns out, the Argentine sources are not exclusively Argentine. The thought of Romano Guardini on modern technology and political power and Pope Paul VI's Evangelii Nuntiandi are pivotal reference points. Rourke offers a reliable overview of how, in the wake of the Second Vatican Council, a distinctive teología del pueblo (“theology of the people”) arose in Argentina under the leadership of Lucio Gera, Rafael Tello, and Juan Carlos Scannone, SJ. While most Latin American progressives were wont to use European post-Enlightenment social analysis to give voice to the struggles of the poor, the Argentine school placed an equal emphasis on the local cultural determinants of both poverty and unbelief. As a result, the enculturation of the Gospel stood at the center of the social-justice efforts of the socially engaged priests that Bergoglio emulates.
To this mix, Rourke argues, one must add two additional factors. The first is the absolutely decisive paradigm of enculturation evinced in the Jesuit reductions in Paraguay, which were later found to conflict with the imperialist designs of the Bourbon monarchs and for that reason provoked the suppression of the Society. According to Rourke, that mode of enculturation still motivates Pope Francis as a defender of a renewed Suarezian democratic theory of popular sovereignty and as a guardian of the native wisdom of baptized indigenous peoples. The second catalyst was the social thought of the highly eccentric Uruguayan philosopher Methol Ferré, a “wild and integrative Thomist” who assimilated into the Latin American context the antimodernism of Augusto del Noce. Ferré was an early critic of the anomie that arises via pornography and championed both the continental aims of la Grande Patria and the building of urban Marian sanctuaries as a culturally specific and localized antidote to the nascent “libertine atheism.” Most of all, Ferré brought attention in a manner quite different from contemporary postcolonial theorists to the idea of the emergent ecclesial reality in Latin America not just as a Spanish-speaking vessel of European learning but as a “source Church.”
Rourke convincingly demonstrates that the so-called cultura de encuentro (“a culture based on genuine encounters and not just chance meetings”) is the key to Bergoglio's hope for social reconstruction. According to Bergoglio, Christian faith purifies and enriches cultures. From Puebla to Aparecida, the Fifth General Conference in which Bergoglio served as the redactor of the final document, CELAM emphasized that inculturation is aided greatly by the wisdom of the people embodied in their religious practices. This insight is also crucial in Bergoglio's recipe for social reconstruction. He preached about social questions on the Feast of Saint Cajetan, especially in the midst of “the Argentine Dialogue,” a seven-month dialogue about civic participation he helped to facilitate. The religious culture of a people for Bergoglio is never a relic. It is an opportunity to move forward the temporal life of God's emissaries in order to allow for greater empowerment and interaction for and among the broadest array of social groups.
The ingredients that Rourke highlights in the domain of political theory are not new: the common good, a prudential but still critical role for the state, vigorous social solidarity, subsidiarity, human rights, and freedom. These elements of modern Catholic social teaching have been discussed by previous popes. The particular configuration in the native context, which culminates in a political reading of the parable of the good Samaritan, is nonetheless distinctively Bergoglian. It was the beginning of a period of public conflict with the Peronist leader, Nestor Kirchner, and Cardinal Bergoglio urged the entire nation to play the role of the good Samaritan. He also recognized that both the state and the church face the temptation to be passersby or even assailants. How we see ourselves in relationship to the parable will determine the political outcome of the construction of a nation. Situating oneself in the place of everyday life and retaining the common memory of a people ward off the destructive impulses of ideological abstraction. Rourke weaves together this narrative masterfully and applauds the interplay of unapologetic evangelization and sharp political critique.
Bergoglio is no economist. Nor does he shy away from pronouncements about the ill effects of economic globalization on the poor and marginalized. Ideology intervenes when one absolutizes the free operation in a market economy of the desires of an individual consumer or the regulation of the markets by the state. The authentically Catholic understanding of the universal destination of all goods allows for neither unchecked neoliberalism nor the dictatorial outcomes of unjust social planning. Francis's preferential option for the poor is rooted in a vision of transparency and justice that extends beyond and criticizes a welfare mentality. The state is limited in its actions by the principle of subsidiarity, and one can also pursue with due prudence the humanitarian and entrepreneurial gains of a globalized economy. Such is the context for Francis's sometimes apocalyptic pronouncements on how capitalism today excludes the vulnerable and turns them into disposable byproducts of a system designed to generate maximum profits for the owners of the means of production. The church of Bergoglio sides with the people, not with a particular social class. Particularly enlightening is Rourke's treatment of Bergoglio's characteristically austere lecture on how “social debt” is the nation's greatest debt, greater even than Argentina's massive external debt.
Rourke analyzes the depth and the breadth of the Jesuit's deeply Ignatian vision of a Christian society and of a global culture of dialogue and fraternity. Most will be surprised at what he unearths. I still retain my quibbles. Why does he not acknowledge the role of Archbishop Victor Manuel Fernández, the cardinal's and now pope's ghostwriter? Furthermore, the Peronist background is still better treated by Austen Ivereigh in The Great Reformer and in the work of Argentine scholars like Carlos María Galli and Emilce Cuda. There is also a tendency to fill in the blanks in Bergoglio's vision with Rourke's own North American personalism in the manner of Simon. On the other hand, the program of Pope Francis is a work in progress and sometimes lacks the unified vision and seamless integration into the framework of the natural, moral law that Rourke supplies. Whereas Pope Benedict in his Reichstag address confronted this question squarely, Pope Francis sometimes seems to acquiesce to a historicist view of absolute moral norms. The global vision of Pope Francis by its very nature invites synodality, a walking together of a church on a journey. Rourke's local reading of Francis's political vision is thus both fitting and timely.
