In his commendatory poem from the First Folio, Ben Jonson asserted that Shakespeare “was not of an age, but for all time.”Footnote 1 This has proved true, and Shakespeare has been able to speak to many succeeding generations of readers and theatregoers. This, however, is not because essential, unchangeable, and universal truths about human nature, the world, and experience lay hidden in his plays or his charactersFootnote 2 but (quite the opposite) because succeeding generations, over the centuries, have been able to appropriate, exploit, and reuse Shakespeare to make sense of their world and their lives. Shakespeare is for all time precisely because he has relentlessly changed over time. The author and his texts have been unceasingly reinvented, and a virtually infinite number of “alternative Shakespeares” has come to embody specific contemporary issues and conflicts.Footnote 3 As Jean Marsden put it in 1991, Shakespeare is the object of “an ongoing process of literary and cultural appropriation in which each new generation attempts to redefine Shakespeare's genius in contemporary terms, projecting its desires and anxieties onto his work.”Footnote 4 This is true for both the “dramatic” Shakespeare and the “theatrical” Shakespeare: Shakespeare's plays have been as tirelessly reinterpreted on the page by scholars (and others) as they have been reinvented on the stage by actors and directors. The fate of King Richard III, however, is peculiar from this point of view, insofar as an often-denigrated Restoration revision of Shakespeare's play totally replaced the “original” one in the theatre and held the stage for nearly 200 years. This peculiarity acquires interesting overtones when we look at the treatment the staged play received at the hands of the Romantics, who, in spite of the bardolatry prevailing at the time and their often-vented disesteem for the adapted version, apparently missed their opportunity to make Shakespeare's original play speak for their own time.
This seems really odd if we just think about the fact that Richard III was a character who appealed enormously to early nineteenth-century audiences, seduced by his “mental superiority” and, as Hazlitt put it, his “power to make others the playthings of his will.”Footnote 5 Richard's unwavering and unstoppable progress in blood caused awe and astonishment in the public and generated that chain of sensations that Edmund Burke related to the “sublime.”Footnote 6 The Romantics were attracted by exceptional but also ambiguous and contradictory personalities, and Shakespeare's archvillain—who “held on his way, unquestioned, ‘hedged in the divinity of kings,’ amenable to no tribunal, and abusing his power in contempt of mankind”Footnote 7—acquired almost superhuman connotations in their eyes and was associated with other Romantic mythic figures in literary and theatrical criticism, such as Napoleon, Milton's Satan, and the Byronic hero. Like them, he was no common being, and his major interpreter on the stage, Edmund Kean, with his “preternatural and terrific” acting,Footnote 8 also seemed to be in some way supernatural.
The roots of the Romantics' almost morbid fascination with the character of Richard III are to be found in the second half of the eighteenth century: first, in the emergence of medievalism as both an antiquarian endeavor and a popular cultural phenomenon (the Gothic Revival in art, architecture, and literature), which afforded the possibility of recreating an attractive if distant past; and second, in the unprecedented success of David Garrick in the role. Richard III was one of Garrick's favorite parts, and the role spanned his whole career, from his London debut on 19 October 1741 to his retirement in June 1776.Footnote 9 Garrick, however, like most actors up to the late nineteenth century, acted in Colley Cibber's adaptation of Shakespeare's play, which had been composed at the end of 1699. Cibber at the time was a quite established London actor who specialized in comic and fop parts. In total, he authored twenty-five plays, mainly comedies, either original or adapted. Later in his career, he also became the manager of Drury Lane and was appointed poet laureate. Yet for all his life, Cibber was obsessed by a desire to shine in tragic roles, and his alteration of Shakespeare's Richard III was designed precisely for this purpose. However, his plan to change his public image from comedian to tragedian was thwarted as audiences decreed him unfit to portray the character of Richard, and his tragic efforts were pitilessly ridiculed.Footnote 10 Although Cibber's adaptation fell short of its immediate goal, it nonetheless proved the most lasting of the many revisions of Shakespeare's plays that were produced during the Restoration.
When Cibber's Tragical History of King Richard III saw the light of day, the great age of adaptation was at an end.Footnote 11 Indeed, as Sandra Clark notes, “of all the adaptations, this is the most faithful.”Footnote 12 Cibber's adaptation followed Shakespeare's plot line. Unlike other revisers, Cibber did not change the ending, as Nahum Tate, for instance, had done with King Lear. No visual spectacle or special effects (like those in William Davenant's Macbeth) were added. Nor did Cibber introduce new characters (as John Dryden and William Davenant had done in The Tempest) or entirely new episodes—apart from the murder of Henry VI in the tower (from Henry VI, Part 3), an exchange between Richard and Lady Anne (Ann in Cibber) in which Richard cruelly communicates his detestation to his tearful wife to incite her to suicide, and a heartbreaking farewell between Queen Elizabeth and the princes.Footnote 13
Nevertheless, Cibber substantially modified the character of Richard and, more important as far as its stage history is concerned, made the play into the perfect vehicle to stardom. Although the part of Richard III was already a very big one in Shakespeare, since for number of words it is second only to the role of Hamlet, Cibber's version was even more centered than Shakespeare's on its title role.Footnote 14 Besides, since Cibber considerably reduced the number of the dramatis personae (he omitted the characters of Edward IV, Margaret, Clarence, and Hastings, to name the most notable), the focus was even more exclusively on Richard. Cibber also magnified Richard's iniquity (in the first three acts) and heroism (in acts IV and V). In addition, Cibber's Richard is simplified and conventionalized. Cibber's hero is far less complex and less ambiguous than Shakespeare's. His duplicity is played down, and he has become less subtle and more direct. Following the Restoration urge to rationalize motivation, Cibber added several monologues in which Richard's intentions are expressed and clarified. As usual with adaptations of the time, Cibber also introduced a love motif: Richard openly declares that he is in love with Lady Ann, and later on, he confesses his infatuation with Lady Elizabeth. Cibber also exploited pathos whenever possible.
Cibber's play, which was designed to feed its compiler's vanity, was perfect for a star actor. As George Bernard Shaw put it, Cibber's version was a “one man show,”Footnote 15 or, in the words of a modern editor, “an egomaniac's delight.”Footnote 16 The hypertrophy of the central character that is found in Cibber's text made it a favorite with actors and decreed its unparalleled success not only in Garrick's time but also in the Romantic period, when the theatre was the actor and authorship was subservient to acting.Footnote 17 Romantic actors loved Cibber's adaptation and capitalized on its title role, choosing it to launch their London careers.Footnote 18 Until 1820, the play was performed practically unaltered; only very slight changes were introduced by David Garrick, George Frederick Cooke, and John Philip Kemble.Footnote 19 Critics, however, had become increasingly dissatisfied with Cibber's version and seemed anxious to dismiss it altogether. William Hazlitt, for instance, asserted that “the manner in which Shakespeare's plays have been generally altered or rather mangled by modern mechanists is a disgrace to the English stage”Footnote 20 and variously called Cibber's play a “patch-work,”Footnote 21 a “miserable medley,”Footnote 22 and a “vile jumble.”Footnote 23 Charles Lamb defined Cibber's “improvements” as “ribald trash.”Footnote 24 Nonetheless, Cibber's Richard held its ground against detractors.
Up to this point there is little that is new. The Romantics' penchant for the Middle Ages, the central role of the actor in the Romantic theatre, and the popularity of Richard III at the time are well known. Nor is it a mystery that the Richard III of scholars and the Richard III of the theatre were quite different in the Romantic period, and that audiences up to the last quarter of the nineteenth century did not see the Richard “that Shakespeare drew”Footnote 25 on the stage but were thrilled by the powerful embodiments that Cibber's version of the character found on the boards. Much less known, however, are the pseudo-attempts that were made in these years to restore Shakespeare's “original” Richard III to the stage. The purpose of this study is to examine two texts produced in the Romantic age that placed themselves at the margins of theatre history: the ill-fated stage adaptations of King Richard III by Thomas Bridgman and actor William Charles Macready. These were born of a growing dissatisfaction with Cibber's version, but their spurious form and their failure to gain or hold the stage testify to the sway Cibber's Richard still held over actors and audiences alike. In addition, they show how, “at a period when Shakespeare [was] regarded almost with idolatry,”Footnote 26 a sort of anti-Shakespeare bias nonetheless existed with regard to King Richard III and how the age was unwilling to relinquish its “inherited Cibberism” despite its flaunted admiration for Shakespeare. The phenomenon that Marvin Carlson calls “ghosting” (i.e., the audience's memory of a performance)Footnote 27 can account for this paradox in part, but as we shall see, there is more to it than just theatrical déjà vu.
Thomas Bridgman's Adaptation
Thomas Bridgman's play was never produced: after being rejected by both Drury Lane and Covent Garden Theatre, it was privately printed in 1820. In his preface, Bridgman complained about the different fate Shakespeare's plays had received on the page (where editorial purism had been increasingly pursued) and on the stage (where they had been relentlessly bastardized). However, he admitted that his experiment was no mere restoration, since many of Cibber's alterations had been made “with the greatest discrimination and effect,” and said that his aim was simply to remove “faults, not beauties.” This declaration of intent blithely contradicted his previous claim that he intended “to make ‘Richard himself again’” (the words are Cibber's!)—namely, “to restore [Shakespeare's] beauties to the public eye” and “to omit that which [had] spuriously been inserted in their stead.”Footnote 28 The alterations by Cibber that Bridgman was unable to relinquish are those found in the last two acts, which greatly enhanced Richard's heroism and offered wonderful opportunities for his interpreters to display their talents to the fullest. In an age when the star actor was the unquestioned sovereign of the theatre, the respect for Shakespeare's poetry could in no way get the better of the actor's need to shine when the two were in conflict. Bridgman unabashedly subordinated the flaunted admiration for Shakespeare's original to a supposed superior playability of Cibber's text, since, as he declared, “throughout the fourth and fifth acts [Cibber's] general alterations certainly have served greatly to enhance the merits of the play” (vii). He even defended Cibber's alterations on aesthetical grounds: “It has been remarked of the plays of Shakespeare, that the three first acts, in general, are the best; the two last, especially the fifth, towards the conclusion, gradually fall off, owing to his eagerness to get them ready for performance as speedily as possible” (viii). He did not give the source for this remark but took its authority as beyond dispute.
The preface included an analysis of the character of Shakespeare's Richard in which Bridgman freely mingled Shakespearean traits with features deriving from the embodiment of Richard in the theatre. As was usual with eighteenth-century character criticism, the point of departure is the moral paradox that Shakespeare created a character “fully deserving of our bitterest hate, without rendering him an object of disgust” (vii). However, after stressing the complexity of (Shakespeare's) Richard, who is at the same time a “treacherous friend,” a “designing hypocrite,” a “dignified king,” a “base assassin,” and a “manly hero” (but this is obviously truer of Cibber's Richard), Bridgman contradictorily concluded his assessment with an observation that Shakespeare's Richard could hardly have provoked and that, conversely, seems again to be inspired by the protracted heroic exertions of Cibber's Richard in his final moments and the sympathetic involvement based on pathos that Cibber's Richard elicits throughout the play: “At last, when he is overpowered and killed by Richmond, after we have anxiously anticipated, and are most delighted with his defeat, yet are we, even then, almost inclined to pity” (vii). After all, Richard was an (almost) legitimate sovereign: how could he be rendered thoroughly detestable without offending the monarchy? The extraordinary bravery of Cibber's Richard helped reconcile the character with an honorable image of kingship and to some extent made up for his devilish wickedness.
In the prologue to his adaptation, Bridgman's outspoken advocacy of Shakespeare similarly appeared to be contradictory in view of the fact that he retained so much of Cibber's material in his adaptation. The opening is straightforwardly bardolatrous with its quotation of the first stanza of the prologue Samuel Johnson wrote for David Garrick to read at the opening of Drury Lane Theatre in 1747:
Bridgman followed Johnson's quotation and his own equally high-flown praise of Shakespeare with an invitation to “discard all foreign Melo-Drames and stuff” and go back to “the glorious founder of the English School.” (xv) Accordingly, in the captatio benevolentiae that concludes the piece, Bridgman confidently proposed himself as an unwavering advocate of the Bard who was ready to sacrifice himself for his sake:
Bridgman continued his condemnation of the foreign influence on the English stage in the epilogue, where he emphatically defended the English theatrical tradition, embodied by Shakespeare, in another exhortation to “strive to expel from [the stage] the vicious rules/Of both the German and the Gallic schools,” since it is “shameful on that stage to bring,/Where Shakespeare's ever acted, a Gnome-King” (76). Bridgman's complaint vaunted a long tradition, since the poisonous influence of German drama (and of August von Kotzebue in particular) on British morality had become a leitmotif in the Tory press after the French Revolution. As a correspondent (“Juvenis”) in The Anti-Jacobin Review and Magazine argued:
The flimsy nonsense (to say the least of it) of most of our own play writers has been succeeded by a deluge of German errors, German inconsistencies, German politics, and German blasphemies: no trifling evils have been done to this country by this importation and acting of German plays; and the applause bestowed upon the repeated performances of these miserable productions, is at once a lamentable proof of our depravity in taste, sense, and virtue; and when it is considered, that one of these German productions (I mean Pizarro) has employed so many translators, has been so often performed with the greatest applause, has exercised the talents of a British Senator, and has run through so many editions in the press, what can be thought of our progress in taste, sense, or virtue?
That the immortal bard of Britain should give place, on our Theatres, to the mad effusions of such distempered heads as Kotzebue, Schiller, &c. &c. is a most mortifying reflection to every Briton, capable of appreciating the merits of literary productions.Footnote 29
Strangely enough, Bridgman's ardent defense of Shakespeare in his prologue remained generic. Neither there nor in the epilogue did Bridgman defend the (partial) attempt at restoration he was proposing. In the prologue, he limited his attacks to trends coming from abroad, whereas the epilogue censured both the arrogant pretension of contemporary playwrights that they were reforming society and their neglect of the stage, which, Bridgman argued, was badly in need of reform (once again owing to foreign influence). Bridgman seemed to be using Shakespeare's name primarily out of national pride. At the same time, however, he continued to capitalize on the popular appeal of Cibber's version, as the preface and the text itself show. Thus, after having condemned in the preface the “marked indifference” toward the form in which Shakespeare's plays “have been suffered to come before the public” (v), Bridgman himself fell victim to the same error, and in the two spaces statutorily assigned to the dramatist for the presentation and the promotion of his work he did not devote a word to the defense of his experiment or to exposing the faults in Cibber's “mélange” (vi). This is surprising in view of the fact that the opening lines of the epilogue prove that he was obviously aware of its role in the economy of the play and that he was critical of contemporary dramatists for neglecting to talk of their plays in the epilogues:
In both the prologue and the epilogue, Bridgman seemed to defend Shakespeare less on aesthetic grounds than as an emblem of abused and threatened Englishness.
Bridgman's adaptation eliminated the spurious first act of Cibber's tragedy, in which (drawing mainly from King Henry VI, Part 3) the murder of the old king in the tower was portrayed, in obedience to the Restoration preoccupation with symmetry, which required a good ruler as a counterpoint to the villainous Richard.Footnote 30 The cut may be due to the fact that staging regicide had become risky after the notorious events of the French Revolution. Bridgman also reintroduced some central characters Cibber had omitted, namely Clarence, King Edward IV, and Hastings. He did not restore the character of Margaret, even though he carelessly reintroduced some references to her curses. Bridgman's reintroduction of whole scenes Cibber had left out is obviously connected to the restoration of these characters. These include the arrest of Clarence (but not his dream and murder), the (pseudo-)reconciliation scene that takes place in the presence of the sick Edward IV, and both the exchange between Hastings and Catesby and the council scene, in which Hastings is accused and then arrested.Footnote 31 On the other hand, he retained the confrontation Cibber had introduced in which Richard brutally communicates his hatred to his wife in order to induce her to commit suicide.Footnote 32 This is clearly at odds with the image of Richard as a heroic figure worthy of pity that Bridgman offered in the preface to the play. In this instance, Bridgman sacrificed coherence of character to dramatic effect and presented Richard as a diabolical plotter. Bridgman did eliminate Cibber's heartrending farewell in the tower between Queen Elizabeth and the young princes (in the presence of the Duchess of York and Lady Ann “in tears”), which was Cibber's most extensive pathetic interpolation,Footnote 33 and—counterintuitively, given the patriotic potential of the speech—Richmond's deferential epitaph over Richard's corpse, which in Cibber had replaced Shakespeare's ruthless comment: “The bloody dog is dead.”Footnote 34
Although Bridgman sometimes preferred Shakespeare's wording in places where Cibber had given “[Shakespeare's] thoughts in the best dress [he] could afford ‘em,”Footnote 35 he retained many of the speeches Cibber had added. When he included a speech Cibber had borrowed from Henry VI, Part 3, Bridgman even inserted a footnote of justification:
Although this speech, together with the lines which immediately precede the entrance of the two Murderers, is not to be found in the original, yet, as I consider it rather contributes to improve the piece, than otherwise, I have retained it; which I have not scrupled to do in many more instances, where I thought the interpolation conducive to improvement. (17)
Bridgman thus acknowledged that his “restoration” of Shakespeare's text was partial. Only rarely was his fidelity to Cibber merely functional, as when glosses were needed to compensate for omissions. For instance, he retained five of the seven substantial soliloquies Cibber had provided for Richard.Footnote 36 In act II (Cibber 2.2.128–40), Richard exultantly and self-confidently “counts his gains” and assures the audience that young Prince Edward will never be crowned king. In act III, Bridgman combined two of Cibber's soliloquies, conflating the lines in which Richard triumphantly discusses his success in getting the crown (Cibber 3.2.270–80) with a soliloquy in which he argues against conscience (Cibber 3.1.157–78), as was appropriate for the conventional eighteenth-century villain. In act IV, he retained the second speech on conscience (“the busy something, here”) that takes place while the princes are being murdered (Cibber 4.3.19–38), although he omitted the direct reference to the murder that concludes the speech in Cibber, which evidently pushed Richard's careless brutality too far (“Hark! The Murder's doing; Princes farewell,/To me there's Musick in your Passing-Bell”; Cibber 4.3.36–8). Finally, Bridgman chose Cibber's version of the tent scene, which opens with the last poetical soliloquy Cibber had inserted (5.5.1–25), which is based on the Chorus's speech in Shakespeare's Henry V at the beginning of act IV.
On other occasions, Bridgman's retention of Cibber's additions was more restricted but equally significant. This happens with the simile in act IV in which Richard compares the young princes to “two spiders,/Crawling upon my startled hopes” (Cibber 4.2.14–18), which was possibly one of those “beauties” Bridgman admired in Cibber's text; with Queen Elizabeth's aside that clears up the ambiguity in Shakespeare about her apparent consent to her daughter's marriage with Richard (Cibber 4.4.111–17), which obviously renders the queen's seemingly inconsistent behavior more intelligible to the audience (and more appropriate for a royal figure); and with Richard's gruesome order regarding the burial of the princes that replaces Shakespeare's vagueness on the subject. Here, instead of Tyrrel's elusive answer to Richard's inquiries in Shakespeare's text:
K. Rich.: And buried, gentle Tyrrel?
Tyr.: The chaplain of the Tower hath buried them;
But where, to say the truth, I do not know.Footnote 37
we find this bloodcurdling exchange:
Glo.: And buried, my good Tyrrel?
Tyr.: In that I thought to ask your grace's pleasure.
Glo.: I have it—I'll have them sure—get me a coffin
Full of holes—let them be both cramm'd into it:
And, hark thee, in the night-tide throw them down
The Thames—once in, they'll find the way to the bottom.Footnote 38
The vivid detail of Richard's pitiless order could produce a sublime frisson that audiences could still appreciate over a century after Cibber wrote this dialogue.
Bridgman's adaptation also retained one of Richard's heroic speeches in the conversation between the king and Catesby, concluding act IV. As has already been noted, actors built greatly on the increased bravery of Cibber's Richard, and audiences were so accustomed to this aspect of the character that it was deemed unthinkable to go back to Shakespeare's original. Bridgman may have felt that Richard's heightened heroism was appropriate for a character who was an English monarch:
Similarly, in the last scene of his adaptation, Bridgman maintained Cibber's exchange between Richmond and Richard that precedes their fight (and opens with a line from Henry VI, Part 2) and the defiant dying speech of Richard, which, with its invocation to “the first-born Cain,” perfectly suited Cibber's archvillain and is, in part, taken from Northumberland's speech in Henry IV, Part 2 (1.1.155–60):
Finally, Bridgman preserved Cibber's introduction of a romantic motive in the conclusion of the play, which was intended as an anticipation of a happy ending that promised more than a mere dynastic arrangement, perhaps because Bridgman felt that it would still appeal to the women in the audience:
Blunt: My lord, the queen and fair Elizabeth,
Her beauteous daughter, some few miles off
Are on their way to ‘gratulate your victory.
Rich.: Ay, there indeed, my toil is well rewarded.Footnote 41
Thus, Bridgman's flaunted restoration of Shakespeare's text appears, at best, to be a tentative experiment. It is full of contradictions and is both ambiguously presented and only half-heartedly pursued. Despite its ostensible defense of the superiority of Shakespeare's original, it is a compromise between Shakespeare and Cibber. All this is symptomatic of the author's ambivalent attitude: although Bridgman could hardly recognize the Richard “that Shakespeare drew” in Cibber's adaptation, he was reluctant to abandon it, as Cibber's text was still very successful from a theatrical point of view. As we shall see, a similar ambivalence is evident in contemporary public opinion.
William Charles macready's Adaptation
William Charles Macready's experimentFootnote 42 was apparently much more self-conscious, but again the outcome is a compromise between the theatrical effectiveness of Cibber, which still ensured overflowing houses whenever it was performed, and the acknowledged aesthetic superiority of Shakespeare. Unlike Bridgman's text, Macready's play was brought to the stage, but just for two nights, on 12 and 19 March 1821.Footnote 43 An assessment published in the Morning Chronicle on the day after the first performance of the play contrasts action and poetry, showing how, in a seemingly bardolatrous age, a sort of anti-Shakespeare bias nonetheless existed with regard to King Richard III and how the public was not really willing to surrender its “inherited Cibberism.”Footnote 44 The reviewer wrote, “As some interpolations are still retained, we cannot give our unqualified praise to an attempt which has fallen short of its professed object, and which, even if it had been executed with strict precision, might possibly have injured the action as much as it must have benefited the poetry of the drama.”Footnote 45 Of course, prejudice based on the supposed unplayability of Shakespeare's text was limited to those among the theatrical public who were aware of the fact that what was put onstage at the time was not Shakespeare's play, and they were probably not many, since the name of the adapter was seldom mentioned in playbills: then, as now, the name of Shakespeare held an unquestioned legitimating power. Thus, the announcement on the playbill for the 1821 performance of Macready's adaptation that “Of the Tragedy hitherto acted under the Title of King Richard III. more than half [was] the exclusive composition of CIBBER” came as quite a shock to theatregoers.Footnote 46 The surprise the notice caused is recorded in the review of the performance in The British Stage and Literary Cabinet: “It was curious to hear the expressions of surprise which the announcement of this experiment in the Bills, drew from many persons who would fain be thought intimately acquainted with Shakespeare's plays, but who, previously, entertained not the slightest suspicion that the one usually performed was not entirely his production.”Footnote 47
The authorship of the adaptation has sometimes been disputed. The name of the adapter was not mentioned in the playbill or on the title page of the edition that was published in the same year, and the text was not immediately recognized as Macready's. The Champion talked vaguely of “the compiler, whoever he may be.”Footnote 48 On 17 March, Bridgman himself wrote a heated letter to The Morning Post in which he accused Macready of plagiarism.Footnote 49 Then, in January 1844, in a letter to the editor of The Times, Edmund Lewis Lenthal Swift presented himself as “the partial restorer of Richard III as produced in March 1821 at Covent Garden,” complaining that “justice was not done to him on the publication of the piece, for his name was not so much as mentioned.”Footnote 50 He returned to the subject almost a quarter of a century later, in another letter to the editor of The Times in which he invariably referred to the play as “my adaptation” and acknowledged only the aid of his friend Macready's “taste, judgement and theatrical experience” in the enterprise.Footnote 51 The mystery was apparently solved in Macready's Reminiscences, which were published in 1875—two years after his death. There, Macready explained that Mr. Swift had sent him an alteration of Cibber's adaptation of King Richard III but that it “var[ied] so little from the work it professed to reform, that [he] was obliged to extend the restoration of Shakespeare's text.”Footnote 52 Still, this account fails to lay the mystery to rest because in his 1844 letter Swift had said the exact opposite, namely that “more of Cibber was retained in the production than he had designed.”Footnote 53 It is possible, then, that the preface to the published edition of the play is Macready's and the adaptation itself was a joint enterprise, despite the tradition that has always ascribed the play to the actor.
Macready made the idea behind the revision very clear in the preface: “To restore the Character of Richard and the Language of Shakspeare to the Stage has been the sole object of this re-arrangement.”Footnote 54 As was usual in contemporary dramatic criticism, Macready's focus was Richard; he had no doubt that “Shakspeare's Richard is a play of character” (v). According to him, Cibber's fault was precisely that he had lost sight of this (v). Because Cibber's Richard was neither the historian's (Thomas More's) nor Shakespeare's, the new adaptation intended “to bring back the original character of Richard in all its bearings—his original language and the fidelity of the action to history” (vii). So the theatrical version of the play was revised with a purpose, one already evident from Macready's first interpretation of the role on 25 October 1819, when he had performed in Cibber's text while endeavoring to infuse it with the spirit of Shakespeare. Richard was Macready's first great Shakespearean success. He had been forced into it by the Covent Garden manager, Henry Harris, who, having decided that it was time for Macready to challenge Kean on his own ground, advertised the performance without even consulting the actor.Footnote 55 Thus, Macready was obliged to use Cibber's script. However, as he wrote in his Reminiscences, for this first portrait of the character he went “direct to the true source of inspiration, the great original, endeavoring to carry its spirit through the sententious and stagy lines of Cibber.”Footnote 56
Macready's idea of Richard was also based on the sources. As he wrote in the preface, his aim was to restore “that ‘alacritie and mirth of mind’ instanced by More, which is prominent throughout Shakspeare, [but] is hardly any where discernible in Cibber” (vi). Both More's and Shakespeare's creations had evident connections with the theatrical Vice,Footnote 57 the allegorical character who had developed in a popular context and, in Tudor interludes, not only devised plots to make the human character fall into sin and be damned but also was a source of mirth and provided the audience with comic relief. However, the Vice's popular laughter, his desecrating language, and his debunking spirit could hardly find a place on the Restoration stage, which felt evident discomfort when faced with Shakespeare's tragicomic approach.Footnote 58 Thus, the Restoration adaptation played down Richard's jocularity. In Cibber's Tragical History of King Richard III, the hero's roots in the merry-making Vice are no longer discernible. He becomes “stern Richard” (Cibber 1.1.216, 2.2.61, 5.3.32, and 5.9.30). Macready borrowed the words of Charles Lamb, “one of the best critics that ever loved, and taught others to love the beauties of Shakspeare,” to complain that “in Cibber's alteration we seek in vain for ‘the rich intellect which Richard displays; for his wit, his resources, his buoyant spirits, his vast knowledge and insight into character’” (vi).Footnote 59 In his review of the 1819 performance, Leigh Hunt bore witness to Macready's success in conveying this idea of the character: Kean's Richard was “the more sombre and perhaps deeper part of him,” whereas Macready's was “the livelier and more animal part”:
The one has more of the seriousness of conscious evil in it, the other of the gaiety of meditated success. . . . Mr Macready's is more sustained in his troubled waters by constitutional vigour and buoyancy. . . . We certainly never saw the gayer part of Richard to such advantage. His very step, in the most sanguine scenes, had a princely gaiety of self-possession.Footnote 60
Thus, the “quality of unrestrained mirth,”Footnote 61 an acute embarrassment to eighteenth-century moral criticsFootnote 62 but the pillar of Charles Lamb's portrayal of Richard (in antithesis to George Frederick Cooke's “butcher-like”Footnote 63 conception of the character), was finally brought to light in Macready's playing of the role. What Macready objected to in Cibber's Richard were his moral scruples and constant self-questioning: in other words, that heightened emphasis on conscience that eighteenth-century critics and audiences had greatly appreciated but that had begun to sound outdated since the turn of the nineteenth century. In Macready's opinion, Cibber had impoverished Richard's character, and in rejecting his “bold originality of thought and expression” (vi), he had reduced him to a stock figure.
In spite of this, Macready was rather ambiguous about Cibber's interventions. Having paid Cibber “the just praise of having formed a very clever Play from his great materials” (v), he declared that his effort was made “under [the] impression of Cibber's causeless innovations on the character, but with a full and perfect sense of his great skill in retrenching and reducing the play to a representable form” (vii). Macready was far less cautious in his Reminiscences, where he attacked “the coarse jests and ad captandum speeches of Cibber” and dismissed the popular passages he himself had retained “in deference to the taste of the times” as “claptraps” and “bombast.”Footnote 64 The ambivalence toward Cibber was even more obvious in the playbill for Macready's performance, where the desire not to offend the sensibility of theatrical audiences by attacking their favorite became obsequiousness and Cibber's “alteration” was defined as “ingenious.”Footnote 65 Such a wavering attitude toward Cibber undeniably contributed to dooming the experiment, as did the manager's short-sighted decision not to provide new scenery and costumes. “Not one farthing was expended upon either the one or the other,” The British Stage and Literary Cabinet complained.Footnote 66 This perhaps proved a fruitful lesson to the young Macready, who would pay great attention to these two aspects of performance when he was manager of Covent Garden (1837–9) and Drury Lane (1841–3). As Richard Schoch notes, he became “committed to pictorial mise en scène,” a mode of production that was especially identified with Shakespeare revivals and “entailed not only highly elaborate scenery, but also detailed costumes and properties, spectacular scenic and lighting effects, and the frequent use of tableaux vivants.”Footnote 67
The triumphal statement announcing the second performance of the play proclaimed that “The Life and Death of King Richard the Third, in its altered state, was received with very great applause—and MR MACREADY never more successful than in the character of Richard.”Footnote 68 But this sounds like puffery. As Macready sadly admitted in his Reminiscences, his adaptation (which he referred to as “the experiment”) “was partially successful—only partially.”Footnote 69 The adaptation was silently shelved after only two performances. The press was divided. The London Literary Gazette exultantly announced: “The pinions of the Swan of Avon have at length been disenthralled from the swathing bands in which manager Cibber took so much trouble to involve them, and ‘Richard's himself again!’”Footnote 70 The New Monthly Magazine and Literary Journal called the performance “an experiment of happy audacity,” spoke of a “regenerated Richard,” and claimed that its author had “removed much of the dross cast on Richard [by Cibber], and almost brought him back to his original brightness.”Footnote 71 Other newspapers were far more cautious, even hostile. Although The Times acknowledged the advisability of rescuing “the original text of [Shakespeare's] plays, from the omissions and interpolations which successive ages [had] accumulated,” it labeled Macready's version as “merely another arrangement, and certainly inferior, in dramatic effect, to that of Cibber.”Footnote 72 The reviewer of The Champion, though he was an advocate of “the dismissal of Colley Cibber's trashy and incongruous melange, and the restoration of the original Richard the Third,” was dissatisfied with what he called a “pretended revival of Shakespeare's Richard III” that omitted and interpolated materials, “injudiciously” transposed scenes, and curtailed speeches.Footnote 73 Macready seems to have lost his battle both with the public and with the critics. If the attempt was received rather coldly by the audience it was probably because of “the influence of habit, and the erroneous idea generally entertained of the character of the hero.”Footnote 74The Champion review helps explain the often unfavorable reception of the “experiment” in the press:
In short, in whatever light we regard this new arrangement, as it is called,—whether as an abridged revival, or as a compilation from Shakespeare's tragedy and Cibber's melange, it is equally open to censure, as having done at once too little and too much; and, we confess, that we lament so much the more the want of taste and judgement in the present experiment, because we very much fear that the imperfect result may rather check than encourage those other restorations of original text of our immortal bard, by every true admirer of the old English drama “so devoutly to be wished.”Footnote 75
Reviewers, however, were far from unanimous in wishing for a return to the original script. An anonymous one who appears to have been more worried about the integrity of Shakespeare's texts than about the vogue for “adapting them better to representation” candidly declared:
It is true that Cibber, in adapting King Richard III to the modern stage, has suppressed many striking beauties of the original; and that the transposition and abridgment which he thought it advisable to make, have perhaps compelled him, for the sake of connexion, to incorporate somewhat too much of his own composition with the dialogue of Shakespeare. But how sacrilegious soever these liberties may be deemed by bigoted and idolatrous critics, experience has shown that the popularity and dramatic effect of the Tragedy have not been diminished by the alterations of Cibber.Footnote 76
In his Reminiscences Macready himself admitted that “to receive full justice, Shakespeare's Life and Death of King Richard III should [have been] given in its perfect integrity, whereby alone scope could [have been] afforded to the active play of Richard's versatility and unscrupulous persistency.”Footnote 77 However, he did not have the courage to go that far. As George Vandenhoff, a player who acted with Macready later in his career, sarcastically remarked, Macready was not ready to pass up the many opportunities a version such as Cibber's offered a star actor to amaze his public:
The truth is, Mr Macready valued an author as far as the author served him; and he respected the text, as far as it answered his purpose; so that his Shaksperian Revivals, which were got up with great care and attention, might have been designated, as far as integrity of text went, “Restorations of so much of Shakspere as suits Mr. Macready.”Footnote 78
In obedience to his declared intention “to restore the Character of Richard . . . to the Stage” (iii), Macready (and Swift) endeavored to omit “no incident whatever, bearing upon [his] character” (iv). Thus, the hypertrophy of Cibber's Richard was preserved, and even if Clarence, Hastings, and the character of Margaret were restored,Footnote 79 they were not reintroduced for their intrinsic significance. Margaret, for example, appeared in only one (much-curtailed) scene, Macready justifying the reduction of her role (which The Champion defined as “a palpable absurdity”)Footnote 80 by claiming that it “was reluctantly made, under the apprehension that the cause of her grief, being so very remote, would prevent the audience from commiserating or sympathising with its expression” (iv). Consequently, although some of Shakespeare's characters were retrieved, the emphasis of the play did not shift very much. Cibber had dropped characters who could compete with his protagonist and thus transformed the play into a drama of a single personality; but Macready and Swift understood that more characters were needed to counterpoint Richard and set him off to greatest advantage. This is the same approach Macready would use in 1838, when he famously reintroduced the Fool to King Lear, which he had already partially restored in 1834. On that occasion, as John Forster noted, Macready's Lear was “heightened by his introduction of the Fool to a surprising degree.”Footnote 81
Some scenes Macready and Swift restored to King Richard III were very effective. This was the case with Clarence's dream (which Bridgman did not restore) and the council scene, which Macready retained in his later performances, after he had returned to Cibber's text. As for Cibber's interpolated scenes, Macready and Swift cut the assassination of Henry VI in the tower and the second confrontation between Richard and Lady Ann(e), which Bridgman kept. They did not have the courage to leave out Cibber's pathos-loaded encounter between Queen Elizabeth and her sons in the tower (4.3), even if they did manage to introduce some of Shakespeare's language into the scene, in an attempt, perhaps, to legitimize a decision that was blatantly at odds with the declared aim of their undertaking. Even more strangely, five of the seven new soliloquies introduced by Cibber survived,Footnote 82 as did the gory instructions for the burial of the princes (Cibber 4.3.47–52) and the heroic speech that concludes act IV. Moreover, the revisers were quite incapable of renouncing the heightened heroism of Cibber's Richard. Again, the reverence for Shakespeare's poetry yielded to the actor's need to display his powers to the utmost. Thus in act V they kept both Richard's defiant challenge to Richmond and a portion of the exchange between the two antagonists that Cibber had adapted in part from Henry IV, Part 2 and Henry VI, Part 2:
K. Rich.: What, ho! young Richmond, ho! ’tis Richard calls:
I hate thee, Harry, for thy blood of Lancaster:
Now,—if thou didst not hide thee from my sword;
Now, while the angry Trumpet sounds alarms,
And dying groans transpierce the wounded air,
Richmond, I say, come forth, and single face me:
Richard is hoarse with daring thee to arms!Footnote 83
K. Rich.: Of one, or both of us the time is come.
Richm.: Kind heaven, I thank thee; for my cause is thine;
If Richard's fit to live, let Richmond fall.
K. Rich.: Thy gallant bearing, Harry, I could plaud
But that the spotted rebel stains the soldier.
Richm.: Nor should thy prowess, Richard, want my praise,
But that thy cruel deeds have stamp'd thee tyrant:
So thrive my sword, as heaven's high vengeance draws it!
K. Rich.: My soul and body on the Action both. [Alarums.]
Richm.: A dreadful lay! here's to decide it.Footnote 84
What the adapters did cut was the dying speech of Richard: their hero died in silence. This was probably the only occasion when, for the sake of the original script, Macready was brave enough to set aside his vanity, passing up the opportunity to shine offered him by the invocation to “the spirit of the first-born Cain” (from Henry IV, Part 2, 1.1.155–60).
In the preface, Macready claimed that of the 1,960 lines of his text no more than 200 were Cibber's (v). Yet the impression one has while reading the play is not one of fidelity to Shakespeare's original. In fact Macready and Swift took a great many liberties: they included many lines from other plays; they freely transposed speeches and scattered fragments of soliloquies throughout the text; they even changed the order of entire scenes or portions of scenes—for example, transferring the courtship of Lady Anne to the second act of the play, after the death of Clarence. The outcome is that, at times, the text appears to be a collage in which lines are freely assembled from various Shakespeare plays and from Cibber's adaptation. The soliloquy preceding the appearance of Lady Anne with King Henry's corpse gives an idea of the patchwork nature of the enterprise:
Glos.: ’Twas her excuse, to avoid me. Alas! [Cibber 2.1.31–35]
She keeps no bed;—
She has health enough to progress far as Chertsey,
Though not to bear the sight of me.
I cannot blame her:
Why, Love forswore me in my mother's womb; [Henry VI, Part 3, 3.2.153–
And, for I should not deal in his soft laws, 160 (already in Cibber)]
He did corrupt frail nature with a bribe,
To shrink my arm up, like a wither'd shrub;
To make an envious mountain on my back,
Where sits deformity to mock my body;
To shape my legs of an unequal size;
To disproportion me in every part:—
And am I then a man to be belov'd? [Cibber 2.1.45–46]
O, monstrous thought! more vain than my ambition!—
Then, since the heavens have shaped my body so, [Henry VI, Part 3,
Let hell make crooked my mind, to answer it! 5.6.78–79]
And since it seems I cannot prove a lover, [Richard III 1.1.28 (altered)
I am determined to prove a villain!– [Bell tolls.] and 30] But see! my Love appears.— [Cibber 2.1.54 and 60–61]
’Tis true, my form, perhaps, may little move her;
But I've a tongue shall wheedle with the devil.
Why, I can smile, and murder while I smile, [Henry VI, Part 3, 3.2.182–185
And wet my cheeks with artificial tears, (183 and 184 inverted)]
And cry, content, to that which grieves my heart,
And frame my face to all occasions. [Bell tolls.]
[Enter Lady Anne, Stanley, Brandon, Officers, Guards, Friars, Ladies, and Pallbearers, with King Henry's body.]
Yet, hold; she mourns the man that I have kill'd: [Cibber 2.1.62–66]
First let her sorrows take some vent: Stand here:
I'll take her passion in its wane, and turn
This storm of grief to gentle drops of pity
For his repentant murderer. [Retires.]Footnote 85
So much for Macready's idea of “restor[ing] the Character of Richard and the Language of Shakspeare to the Stage” (iii). Despite Macready's conviction of the superiority of Shakespeare's text and his poor opinion of Cibber's revision, this joint adaptation, like Bridgman's play, was no more than a medley. Once again, the supposedly superior theatrical effectiveness of at least some of Cibber's revisions won the day, with the result that this new adaptation too fell short of its declared purpose.
Interestingly, a footnote to the preface to the play claimed that “the propriety of restoring Shakspeare's Richard (with curtailments) to the stage, was first suggested by a criticism, which appeared some years ago in the Morning Chronicle” (iii). This is probably a reference to Hazlitt's comment in 1814 on the “mangl[ing]” of Shakespeare's plays “by modern mechanists,” of which Cibber's “patch-work Richard III” was “a striking example.” The indignant critic, after admitting that the original play was “too long for representation,” was categorical in recommending only curtailments: “The only rule, indeed, for altering Shakespeare, is to retrench certain passages which may be considered either as superfluous or obsolete, but not to add or transpose any thing.”Footnote 86 If the enterprise really was prompted by Hazlitt's criticism, then the outcome utterly betrayed the intentions of its original inspirer. On the basis of Swift's adaptation, Macready tailored a text he thought would allow him to come across at his best. At the same time, passing the adaptation off as a straightforward restoration of Shakespeare had the double advantage of pleasing the purists who from time to time vented their dissatisfaction with the alteration of Shakespeare's plays and arousing curiosity in those spectators who had no idea that the play as staged was not Shakespeare's original creation.
All things considered, Bridgman's and Macready–Swift's versions do not appear to have offered a viable alternative to Cibber, whether in terms of fidelity to Shakespeare's original or the ever-felt need to make the Bard our contemporary. The early nineteenth century was an age of virtuoso performance, and the star actor was the undisputed monarch of the theatre. As has already been observed, the Romantic era witnessed what Jane Moody has termed “the tyrannical usurpation of authorship by stage celebrity.”Footnote 87 The persistence of Cibber's revision in the period can be related to the fact that at a time when the actor was acknowledged as a creator in his own right,Footnote 88 the actual script was to a degree marginalized; it was the player who created his own performance text with his “new readings” and “points” and, quite autonomously, managed to make it fit his times. Although these two theatrical adaptations were little more than abortive attempts, actors succeeded in adapting the play to the spirit of the age. The fact that they acted in Cibber's version did not seem to be an obstacle, and they made the play resonate regardless of its lack of fidelity to an original. Unlike his great predecessors in the role, for example, Edmund Kean did not change even one line of the version tradition had handed down to him (he retained only Garrick's and Cooke's additions and some of Kemble's cuts); it was his innovative style of acting that made the difference. With him, the actor as original creator was born, and like the Romantic genius, he was deemed almost godlike in his unrestrained creative freedom.Footnote 89 He truly seemed to embody the artist as a supremely individual creator. He was not simply a vehicle for the author's text; he recreated it, adding his own poetry to the role. In 1821, for instance, Richard Dana wrote: “When [Mr. Kean] plays out of Shakspeare, he fills up where his author is wanting. . . . He seems at the time to have possessed himself of Shakspeare's imagination, and to have given it body and form.”Footnote 90Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine went so far as to compare him positively to Shakespeare, asserting that his performance of Othello was “without comparison, the noblest exhibition of human genius we ever witnessed. It evinced a kind and a degree of talent . . . only, and not much inferior to that which was required to write the character.”Footnote 91
One aspect of Kean's interpretation of Richard that reflected the spirit of the age and was quite independent from the script in which he was acting can be detected in the final duel with Richmond, who, as John Genest testified, was forced to play the fool by Richard's extraordinary vehemence:
Richard was Kean's best part—but he overdid his death—he came up close to Richmond, after he had lost his sword, as if he would have attacked him with his fists—Richmond, to please Kean, was obliged to stand like a fool, with a drawn sword in his hand, and without daring to use it.Footnote 92
Reducing Richmond, who was militarily supported by the French, to imbecility obviously acquired patriotic overtones at a time when France was still considered the public enemy. Indeed, Richard's increased heroism in Cibber's version was even of help in making him the scourge of the French. Cooke had paved the way by adding nationalistic hints to the performance of Richard when in 1804 (four years after his debut in the role) he “bestowed some new study” and “judiciously introduced some lines from Shakespere's text . . . in [Richard's] address to his army, on the approach of Richmond's forces.” The reviewer of the Monthly Mirror found this “extremely apposite to the patriotic sensations of the present moment”:
While Cooke's and Kean's actorial choices ingeniously appealed to national feeling, Bridgman and Macready unwisely eliminated from their adaptations another variation that Cibber had introduced and that could have proved appropriate to the new political climate—Richmond's reverent obituary for Richard:
Aggrandizing Richard at the expense of Richmond (as Cibber did and Kean even more so) undeniably entailed undermining the Tudor myth and overturning the political import of Shakespeare's play; but it nevertheless was, like Cooke's restoration, “extremely apposite to the patriotic sensations of the . . . moment.”
Cibber's “improved” text outlived all other Restoration adaptations, and Richard III had to wait until nearly the end of the nineteenth century before he could be properly allowed “to be himself again.” In February 1845, Samuel Phelps experimented with a severely cut and partially rearranged version of Shakespeare's text at Sadler Wells that ran for twenty-four nights, but he went back to Cibber for his final production of the play in 1861. Charles Kean invariably used Cibber's script, even for his magnificent production at the Princess Theatre in February 1854. Cibber's adaptation endured virtually unchallenged until Henry Irving, first in 1877 and then in 1896, produced his own version of the play at the Lyceum Theatre. This was a heavily cut but otherwise almost “pure” Shakespeare. Cibber's version, however, could still be seen in the twentieth century, and probably, as Hazelton Spencer declared in 1967, “has never been quite driven off the stage”—in spirit, at least.Footnote 95 In 1909 Alice Wood asserted that “Cibber's form” was “still holding the stage,”Footnote 96 and as late as 1930 Arthur Colby Sprague witnessed a performance of Cibber's Richard III in Boston, although it was clearly advertised as Shakespeare's text.Footnote 97 Cibber's two most famous claptraps—“Off with his head! So much for Buckingham” and “Conscience avant; Richard's himself again”—even found their way into Laurence Olivier's 1955 film version. But what are the reasons behind the extraordinary longevity of Cibber's adaptation of Shakespeare's play, which defied all nineteenth-century attempts at restoration?
In 1992, Terence Hawkes argued that “Shakespeare doesn't mean: we mean by Shakespeare”; that is, “Shakespeare's plays have no essential meanings, but function as resources which we use to generate meaning for our own purposes.”Footnote 98 To the fluidity of the meaning of Shakespeare's plays we could connect what Margaret Jane Kidnie has called the elasticity of their ontological boundaries.Footnote 99 As the meaning of Shakespeare's plays is negotiated and renegotiated over time, so are the boundaries between plays and adaptations. This would help explain the exceptional resilience of Cibber's Richard. As Kidnie argues, the yardstick we use to judge the authenticity of Shakespeare's creations (or the lack thereof) is always changing, and at any given moment “Shakespeare's play is whatever a dominant consensus of voices agrees to recognise as Shakespeare's play.”Footnote 100 Even if we are accustomed to think of the Romantic age as an inescapably bardolatrous era, it seems that in the early nineteenth century Cibber's Richard could still be accepted, and a return to Shakespeare's “original” was not deemed essential. With a few notable exceptions, most people seem to have thought that such a heavily modified version of the play was more enjoyable, more performable, and even more authentic than Shakespeare's own script. Both actors and managers still wanted to capitalize on the undeniable popular appeal of Cibber's adaptation—provided of course that it was marketed as Shakespeare. It was his name that truly mattered, as is still the case today. The shortcomings of the “real thing”—the difficulty of Shakespeare's language or the excessive length of the plays, for example—could be tacitly adjusted without scandal. In the end, Cibber's text was a flexible vehicle for actors’ variations, the only ones that really seem to have mattered at the time. In fact, in spite of the poor opinion Hazlitt had of Cibber's “mangled” text, in which more than half the lines were Cibber's invention,Footnote 101 he could still recognize Shakespeare's Richard in the Richard of Kean, who acted in Cibber's version. In the same way, Macready could assert that “Kean's conception [of Richard] was decidedly more Shakespearean” than Cooke's, although the two acted in the same text.Footnote 102 Similarly, in 1819, Macready was able to infuse Cibber's script with Shakespeare's spirit and satisfy a demanding critic such as Leigh Hunt, precisely because the boundaries of what we deem “Shakespeare” shrink and expand over time as much as public opinion and critical estimation will allow.
