In our folklore as well as much of our scholarship, the rural people of the Upland South hold an exceptional place in the national story. In the usual telling, after the Civil War the small farmers of the hill country, dedicated to protecting their local communities and rural traditions, developed an innate distrust of the federal government, and engaged in a century-long resistance to the encroachments of its centralizing power. By its title a reader might assume that this book is another telling of the usual story of populist hillbillies raising hell against federal authority. But this is an unusual—and wonderful—book with a different and vital story to tell.
Its author, J. Blake Perkins, an Ozark native, challenges the usual portrayals of the rural people of his region. Far from being “exceptional” and standing “apart,” he argues, the mountaineers of the Upland South were right in the thick of national developments (3). The small farmers and laborers of the hill country engaged in bitter and often violent conflicts with federal authorities, yet Perkins contends that these conflicts had little to do with a rural traditionalism or “inborn cultural suspicion of federal power” (4). Rather, conflicts arose when the federal authorities took the side of local elites in “local conflicts over political power and economic justice” (7).
Divided in three parts, Hillbilly Hellraisers recounts local incidents and developments that took place mainly in one or several Ozark counties over the course of the long twentieth century. Part One, “The Populist Ethic,” explores the political world of the Ozarks at the end of the nineteenth century. This was a racially divided world, where a brutal “hillbilly racism” moved in step with national trends. And it was a world riven by local conflict between merchant creditors and cash-strapped debtors, town dwellers and country folk, prosperous agriculturalists and middling and small farmers. Small holders often looked to the federal power to regulate and direct the economy—as exemplified by populist demands—as a means to strengthen their position within this local conflict.
The heart of the book is in Part Two, “Rural Resistance,” where Perkins recounts four “microhistories” or case studies of hill folk in confrontation with federal authorities. The first of these stories tells of the 1897 murder of two federal lawmen by moonshiners in the backwoods of Polk County. The familiar tale of moonshiners defying G-men has shaped assumptions about independent mountaineers and their anti-government culture. But Perkins points out that, while some farmers set up stills for the regional liquor market, many other Polk County farmers supported federal control and even prohibition of the liquor trade. The federal lawmen made the mistake of stepping into a conflict of “competing local interests and visions” (65).
In another display of defiance of federal authority, rural Ozarkers widely resisted military conscription during the First World War. But here, too, there was a local cleavage, with local political and town elites controlling the draft boards, and with draft defiance strongest among small farmers and laborers with ties to the Socialist Party and the Industrial Workers of the World. As Perkins notes, draft resistance in the Ozarks was linked to “a broad international ideology and criticism of the political economy of war” (95).
One of Perkins's most fascinating case studies involved the U.S. Department of Agriculture's tick eradication program. Presumably, the USDA's efforts at ridding cattle herds of Texas fever would be welcomed by Ozark farmers. But it provoked resistance, including the 1922 murder of a farmer employed as a federal tick inspector. Small holders, with their scrub cattle, sought opportunity in the low-end market for canned beef, and viewed federal tick control policies as favoring the wealthy cattlemen, who raised high quality breeds for the top end of the beef market. The fight over tick eradication, in Perkins's telling, was not about encroachment on local rights as much as it was a local conflict inflamed by the postwar agricultural panic.
The New Deal brought the federal government into the Ozark economy as never before. Landless hill farmers suffered under the Agricultural Adjustment Act. But federal jobs programs drew strong support. So did dam building projects, with the exception of the small number of farmers who would lose their properties to the dams. In the main, the New Deal conformed to the populist ethos.
By the 1960s, however, federal power in the Ozarks played into a different dynamic, the subject of Part Three, “Toward a New Defiance.” Small-scale farming was rapidly being replaced by a new economy based on cheap labor, and local business elites viewed the War on Poverty and similar interventions as a threat to their interests. Unlike previous federal programs, the War on Poverty and its Office of Economic Opportunity circumvented the local and state governments where the business elites held sway. Moreover, with its links to Civil Rights organizations the OED was vulnerable to the charges that it served as a special interest for the black communities of eastern Arkansas.
Local business elites, in the name of local control and opposition to federal tyranny, struck back against the anti-poverty programs of the 1960s and ‘70s. The result was what Perkins describes as an “Anti-Populist Legacy,” a legacy inherited by the pro-corporate and white nationalist Tea Party conservatives of the twenty-first century (192).
Perkins writes these local stories of his Ozarks with compassion and deep knowledge, and within a thoughtful and broad analytical framework. His stories carry a lot of freight in explaining the political transformations of the last century, and perhaps too much freight in places. Nonetheless, Perkins has written a smart, provocative, and important book. In recent years, a series of titles about populists and hillbillies of neglected places have shot to the top of best-seller lists as readers search for answers as to how the United States landed in its present political dilemma. Hillbilly Hellraisers is an essential contribution to that literature.
