Movement, or certain kinds of movement, are high on the agenda of Western liberal states. In the context of the current “refugee crisis,” the anxiety about terrorists “slipping” through immigration controls, and the increasing securitization the US-Mexico border, the regulation of migrants, migrant bodies, and “flows” seems central to the politics of modern government. Hagar Kotef's latest book provides a timely intervention in the current environment characterized by increasingly tighter restrictions on what liberal states deem “tolerable” movement. To Kotef, the contemporary regulation of mobility that we see manifest in numerous strategies of liberal government reflects a more fundamental relationship between movement and liberalism. The categorization of people and the decision to let certain bodies move and to contain others are neither reduced to a “response” to globalization nor the pursuit of illiberal practices. Instead, Kotef ultimately proposes that the politics of liberalism, as a political philosophy, an account of subjectivity, and a style of government, is always a politics of human mobility.
Rather than explicitly contributing to the increasingly large body of critical work on the politics of migration and border studies (see Nick Vaughan-Williams, Europe's Border Crisis [Oxford University Press, 2015]; Sandro Mezzadra and Brett Nielsen, Border as Method, Or, The Multiplication of Labor [Duke University Press, 2013]), Kotef explores how movement has been central to the emergence and development of liberal thought and rule. Eschewing a narrow focus on “(territorial) borders,” she examines how the regulation of movement is integral to the network of strategies and technologies of ordering in liberal states, a set of techniques which promote the “freedom” of some while always disciplining and controlling certain others. This is an analysis of global and historical circulations which connect colonial practices of land dispossession to the practice of sovereignty via the spaces of gated communities, checkpoints, fences, and other methods of temporal and spatial control.
This is not only a well researched and written book, it is also informed by a political-ethical commitment against injustice. As with other critical accounts of liberalism (Dominico Losurdo, Liberalism: A Counter History [Verso, 2014]; Wendy Brown, Regulating Aversion [Princeton University Press, 2008]), there is a strong focus on the raced, classed, gendered matrix through which violent exclusion emerges in liberal states; however, what is novel about Kotef's analysis is how this is mapped out continuously through different accounts of movement. It is the types of movements embodied by certain subjects that leads to inclusion/exclusion, she argues. In this way, not only does Kotef offer a fascinating critique of the liberal claim to enhance mobility and circulations, but this equally contributes to our understanding of the spatial dimensions of liberal projects of security and government (Martina Tazzioli, Spaces of Governmentality [Rowman and Littlefield, 2015]; Stephen Legg, Prostitution and the Ends of Empire [Duke University Press, 2014]). It is not borders, bodies, populations that are governed but mobility itself.
This provides a fascinating (re)reading of liberalism which is pursued through an intriguing twofold analysis: one focusing on the enactment of the regulation of movement in Israel and Palestine; the second exploring a genealogy of liberalism and mobility through the work of Hobbes, Locke, Mill (as well as William Blackstone and Hannah Arendt). This somewhat unorthodox approach to structuring a political theory text is one of the highlights of the book and opens it up to multiple audiences. While the book is not a study on the Israel-Palestinian conflict, the fine-grained analysis of control in the Occupied Territories provides an eye-opening account of how Palestinian mobility is shaped in day-to-day encounters with Israeli state authority. It also provides a further corrective to studies of liberal government which still too rarely expand beyond Northern Europe and America (although see Jonathan Joseph, “The Limits of Governmentality,” European Journal of International Relations 16, no. 2 [2010]: 223–46 and Carl Death, “Governmentality at the Limits of the International,” Review of International Studies 39, no. 3 [2013]: 763–87 on this point). Setting up the problematic of movement/order/freedom in the context of the Occupied Territories, Kotef retraces the history of the liberal subject and its illiberal “other” through the corporeality of movement. This is the main contribution that the book poses to a political theory audience. Rather than autonomy, rationality, will, the key typology of the liberal subject presented here is one that connects (bodily) movement and freedom. This is a distinctly materialistic reading of liberal thinkers (Hobbes, Locke, Mill, and Blackstone in the main) who, to Kotef, recognize the universal subject as a living, moving body. This account of the human is the basis on which restraint, regulation, and control are made possible because while movement is tied to freedom, order is imagined through the stabilization of movement (and with it security, property, production). This stabilization or restriction can both be self-regulating (as exhibited by the civilized citizen) and can demand active disciplining (as represented by a host of others—the poor, Amerindians, colonized subjects, unwelcome migrants, Palestinians). The importance of this tension to Kotef is realized in those who embody an unrestrained, unregulated form of movement that is not reflected of “freedom” (because it is unrestrained) but becomes a threat to civilized liberal order itself. Thus the exclusory power of modern liberalism which we see encoded in the emergence of nation-states and sovereign citizenship not only works along classed, raced, and gendered axes, but these axes are shaped by the stratification of (un)regulated movement.
Kotef poses a powerful argument which demands interdisciplinary engagement and deserves to be read by political theorists interested in the history of liberal thought as well as researchers in political geography and international relations—in fact, by anyone concerned with the injustice of the contemporary politics of movement. The text has a similar incendiary quality to it as seminal work such as Netz's Barbed Wire (Wesleyan University Press, 2009), which equally explores coloniality, space, and violence. Where Kotef has resonance but leaves things underdeveloped is the connection to the sovereign politics of migration control. Work on autonomy of migration has explored familiar genealogies of modern liberalism which both are materialist and focus on the politics of mobility; however, Kotef misses an opportunity to engage with this equally vital body of work. Furthermore, while the strengths of Kotef's analysis are found in her ability to complement fine-grained empirical analysis (of what she calls subjectivization) with a broader (re)reading of liberal theorists, I would have liked to have seen her return to the “parable” of Israeli practices of regulation towards the end of the book. While the sketch of the raced, classed, and gendered axes of movement are convincing, the historical circulations which link workhouses, colonial enclosures, and nation-states are not self-evident. An engagement with how these circulate through (familiar) liberal practices of control in Palestine would be welcome.
To return to the problematic of liberal borders through which I began this review, Kotef's argument helps us realize that it is not enough to merely protest the restrictive policies of liberal states, through the logic of taking in or “tolerating” more “refugees.” Instead, reading this through the broader history of regulated movement as freedom, we need to consider the very fabric which sorts and categorizes mobility itself. It is the relevance of this argument to day-to-day injustice which makes this book an essential read.
