This survey faces a Herculean assignment: a summary of a millennium of Roman military activity from the fourth century b.c. to the seventh century a.d., based upon vast corpora of literary, epigraphic and archeological evidence, crammed into a slim and accessible monograph. A. D. Lee rises to the challenge, and the result is a cogent and readable synthesis of a dynamic subfield.
Ch. 1, ‘War and Peace’, examines the fundamental problem of Roman bellicosity, from the hyper-bellicosity of the republic to more staid militarisation during the empire modulated by external threats and domestic political requirements. A discussion of victory celebrations is juxtaposed to the problem of processing battlefield defeat, especially in a way that absolved the emperor from responsibility for any setbacks.
Ch. 2, ‘Military Service and Courage’, first examines the relationship between citizenship, property-holding and military service during the republican period. While the supposed reforms of Marius are appropriately played down, military service and property ownership were ultimately dissociated by the principate, only to be partially reconstituted in late antiquity through land grants to limitanei stationed along the frontiers. Notions of courage are examined next, where the ostentatious bravery of the republican elite with their penchant for monomachy carried through in modified form into the principate and beyond. A brief note at the end of the chapter considers how the concepts of virtus and andreia (‘manliness’) erected gendered boundaries around military activity; successful female commanders such as Boudicca and Zenobia were profiled by the sources to emphasise their transgressiveness and alterity.
Ch. 3, ‘Manpower and Money’, considers the sinews of war. The first section examines military recruitment, as the mass conscription of the republic gave way to the largely volunteer legions of the principate, with some recourse to provincial conscription for auxiliary units. The expanded size of the army by the fourth century a.d. again required widespread conscription, and the mandatory enlistment of soldiers’ sons. The fluctuating sizes of armies are detailed next, with peak republican mobilisations during the Hannibalic War requiring roughly a third of all adult male citizens (perhaps a sixth of the total citizen population), while the more stable deployments of the principate required a mere one per cent of the empire's total population. Finally, the material costs and benefits of war are considered: citizen tributum, loot and indemnity payments covered war costs during the republic; regular taxation funded the standing force of the principate, while territorial losses in the fifth century a.d. sent the western empire into a fiscal and military tailspin.
Ch. 4, ‘Authority and Allegiances’, considers the nature of command and governance. The first section considers the qualities valued in Roman generals (per Cicero): technical knowledge (scientia rei militaris), courage (virtus), leadership (auctoritas) and good luck (felicitas). Next, the question of loyalty, examining the military oath and routine discipline and exploring incidents of mutiny and their resolutions, usually with major concessions to the soldiers. The final section examines the thorny dilemmas of military loyalty during civil wars.
Ch. 5, ‘Society and Identity’, considers the social world of the Roman soldier. While the republican-era citizen militia allowed for virtually no military–civil divide, Augustus’ establishment of a professional force on the frontiers propagated a distinct military identity. While Roman soldiers could appear as bullies, there is also evidence for good relations between units and the communities where they were stationed. The last section considers the religious life of soldiers, focused upon the cults of Jupiter Dolichenus, Mithras, and eventually Christianity.
Ch. 6, ‘Culture and Communication’, considers technological and cultural exchange, including the Roman penchant for adopting foreign weapons, from Carthaginian ships to Celtiberian swords. Subsequent encounters with steppe riders prompted the introduction of cataphracts and horse archers, with the stirrup being a late product of this exchange. While careful to avoid a simple vision of the army as a force of ‘Romanisation’, L. reasserts the relatively conventional view that the Roman army was a culturally integrative locus, which can be attested in a variety of spheres, from religion, to bathing, to diet, although such homogenisation was never absolute. The chapter concludes with a discussion of military record keeping and evidence for significant rates of literacy within the ranks.
Ch. 7, ‘Experiences of War’, opens with the problem of pitched battle. It presents as a case study Sulpicius Galba's letter to Cicero (Fam. 10.30) that details his eyewitness account of the Battle of Forum Gallorum in 43 b.c., noting the difficulties commanders faced in effectively processing information during a rapidly shifting situation. Next, the impact of warfare on civilians during siege warfare, which placed them at the highest risk for death, enslavement and assault, as well as the effects of frontier raiding and the economic dislocations caused by protracted military occupations.
The book embodies an admirable fusion of erudition and economy, and L.'s lithe facility with the sources and scholarship makes the transition across themes, centuries and scholarly silos seem effortless. This book will be of great value to undergraduate students as an introduction, doctoral students as a survey and scholars as an overview.
