The diva exudes singularity: whether she sings arias or popular songs, dances the ballet or the cakewalk, she always performs herself. This may explain why studies of female performers consider them so often in iconic isolation rather than as part of a broader celebrity culture. Moving Performances: Divas, Iconicity, and Remembering the Modern Stage remedies this problem with its analysis of four divas of early twentieth-century popular performance: Aida Overton Walker, Loïe Fuller, Libby Holman, and Josephine Baker. Jeanne Scheper's chapters are not merely case studies. They feel truly comparative, demonstrating how these women employed related performance strategies, followed similar touring circuits, and engaged in analogous archival practices. The result is a book as fascinating and self-aware as the women it studies.
Racial difference was a central framework for modern women's popular performance. We see how primitivism, colonialism, and orientalism shape both the possibilities of their performance choices and how they are interpreted. Scheper demonstrates how the mobility of these performers plays with and pushes back against the restrictiveness of fixed racial identity. These women “move their bodies in forms of kinesthetic critique” (5), and they are read quite differently depending on the sites of their performances. Josephine Baker offers the best example of this indeterminacy: as a black woman performing in Paris, she was read both as African American and, through a European colonial lens, as African (131). But this mobility has its limits, since we see that white performers Loïe Fuller and Libby Holman take on other racial identities in experimental and playful ways not granted to Overton Walker and Baker. Moving Performances is especially ambitious because it situates these tropes of racial difference on a timeline that reaches to the present day. It considers how these performers become even more complicated in our era, examining their afterlives in archives and in reimagined images.
One unifying framework for considering early twentieth-century performance was the craze for oriental-style dances dubbed “Salomania” (1). This trend allowed art dancers and vaudevillians alike to borrow the exoticism of the biblical dancer to further their own reputations. Scheper discusses this trend in her introduction, then further examines its impact on Aida Overton Walker in Chapter 1. Overton Walker was famed as a dancer of the cakewalk and a costar in musical comedies with her husband, George Walker, and his longtime partner Bert Williams. As a respectable black woman who made a living onstage, Overton Walker advocated for a more nuanced understanding of African American performers and performances. But when she performed an artistic, restrained Salome dance, her performance was nevertheless interpreted in restricted ways because of her race. Scheper astutely notes that “orientalism as a mainstream popular art form was already seen as the exclusive preserve of white performers” (49).
Loïe Fuller was one of those white performers for whom orientalism was seen as a more “natural” fit. Chapter 2 discusses the ways that Fuller deploys the image of the exotic East as a foundation for her technologically innovative dances, which used extended mechanical wands to swirl fabric into different shapes. Fuller invited Japanese actress Kawakami Sadayakko to share the stage at the Paris Exposition Universelle of 1900, both to amplify their international reputations and to establish the contrast between them. Sadayakko is a fascinating figure in her own right. Like the American divas, she embodies the contradictions of women's performance in this era, representing Western theatricality in Japan and performing Japanese material while touring in Europe.
In Chapter 3, Scheper discusses torch singer Libby Holman. Though she was born to a German Jewish family in Ohio, Holman's smoky voice and ambiguous looks raised questions about her racial identity. Holman embraced this indeterminacy, seeking a crossover sound that that redefined expectations about white and black voices and about the tastes of white and black audiences. The first act of Holman's career took place in the 1920s, when she performed on Broadway and sang Tin Pan Alley songs. In the mid-twentieth century, she sang traditional African American songs to a highbrow concert audience, most often to raise money for civil rights causes. Her performance still scrambled divisions between high and low culture—by wearing a designer peasant skirt, for instance. Holman tried to revise narratives about her earlier career and donated her papers to Boston University, the same archive that holds the Martin Luther King, Jr. Collection. Scheper shows, however, that a celebrity's attempt to control her own posthumous narrative doesn't always succeed. Holman's image persists most prominently in queer and campy plays that seldom acknowledge her complicated relation to racial politics.
The afterlives of Josephine Baker are more varied, as we see in Chapter 4. While some contemporary texts critique Baker's primitivist image, others show how it allows for transnational and cross-gender identification. Baker performed “the uncanny juxtaposition of primitive and civilized through her body” (139), Scheper says. Here the impact of modernism can be seen most directly: a tension between the normatively Western and the exotically othered is present in the public performances of all four divas, though it is undoubtedly clearest in Baker's work. Baker has the longest career of these women, and so she outgrows the banana-skirted image of her youth. Scheper outlines Baker's political activism and convincingly reads government files on her as “an ironic archive,” one that fails to construct a compelling interpretation of the diva it depicts (146). The most striking part of this history lies in the ways that Josephine Baker's late experiment in multiracial adoption (her “Rainbow Tribe”) influenced contemporary versions of diva motherhood epitomized by Angelina Jolie and Madonna (147–8).
Scheper concludes by asking readers to think in more complicated ways about these diva performers, both in their own time and in relation to ours. Her neologism of “retroactivation” (14) encompasses these thoughtful moves between past and present. To understand these divas retroactively, we must also engage in a critical form of activation, looking at the traces of these women's performances and setting in motion the circuits of desire they enacted onstage and off.
