Helen Schneider's Keeping the Nation's House is a timely publication when there have been increasing concerns over the impact of education on students in China today. Among activists and scholars who yearn for academic freedom, nationalistic education is seen negatively as a type of “brainwashing” that is likely to affect the younger generations' ability to think independently. In this context, Schneider shows us that the state's attempts to change the populace through education can be traced back to the early twentieth century. She examines the politics of the development of home economics as an academic subject in China from the 1920s to the early 1950s. Soon after its inception as a formal subject, it was co-opted by the state and transformed from a means to maintain domestic order to an academic discipline, and finally to a political ideology that would help create a stable society and strengthen the Chinese nation. The goal of home economics was to train women to become household managers. During the Nationalist era, hygiene, efficiency, and scientific management became crucial factors of modernity that would make families happier. Women's success in housework and household management was measured by their ability to make the home an environment in which children could be raised to become law-abiding, well-behaved, hard-working citizens.
Women's education had been a topic of discussion since the late Qing. However, educators could not agree on what kind of education would be suitable for women and what purposes women's education should serve. Schneider's impressive book shows a continuity in the discourse on women's education. She meticulously delineates the ways reformers, policy makers, intellectuals, and the media defined the expectations for women through the construction of the discipline of home economics. Moreover, Schneider reveals that the subject itself evolved transnationally. The Japanese ideology of “good wife, wise mother” was integral to the early development of the idea of good housewives. Later, Chinese home economists were influenced by the Americans, especially when the Christian-founded Yenching University established the first long-running department of home economics in 1924. It institutionalized the subject and stressed social scientific education, connecting home management to social reform.
Schneider's breadth of primary source materials is impressive; they include popular women's magazines and journals, educational debates, and home economics curricula. She also uses archival materials from Nanjing, Beijing, Chongqing, Hunan, Shanghai, and Tianjin. The wide array of sources from different locations allows her to compare the way home economics was implemented differently in various areas. Keeping the Nation's House is also filled with detailed analyses of how regional educational policies were implemented. The images in the book, especially the illustrations from the educational and popular publications during that period, are captivating visual supplements to her description of the discourses and contents.
Each chapter can also be read independently. Chapter 1 shows how publications from theoretical to “glossier” magazines defined what domestic management entailed. Through these intellectual and popular discourses, intellectuals developed the ideology of the “happy family” and set up the criteria for modern housewives, which include child rearing and providing the basics for the family. Chapter 2 ties the contents of women's education to home management by focusing on the intellectual elites, mainly the educators and administrators, who created educational policies in the 1920s, after the initial education reform and the increase in the number of schools for women. Chapter 3 shows how educators further redefined the concept of “home economics” by promoting hygiene, child rearing, and scientific management, reinforcing their important role in solving China's problems. Chapter 4 examines the Nationalist Party's institutionalization of home economics from the 1920s to the 1940s, especially through analyzing the Nationalist Ministry of Education. By that time, the discipline could help women not just perform well in their own households but also develop professional careers that could carry out the social reform initiated by the state. Chapter 5 turns from the urban centers to the experimental zones in the provinces of Sichuan and Gansu. It explains the mission of educated women in civilizing the rural women through moral and social reform. Chapter 6 describes the decline of the field of home economics after the Second Sino-Japanese War. All Chinese home economics departments were disbanded, and the discipline was reorganized into different departments during the time of reconstruction. In the conclusion, Schneider points out that one important legacy of home economics education was that it produced new public careers for women. Graduates from the programs became social workers, teachers, chemists, nutritionists, and public workers. However, these careers reinforced the distinctiveness of women's careers as being nurturing or related to care.
This book makes an important contribution to the scholarship of gender and politics during the Nationalist period. In the past decade, there has been a rising interest in women's roles in various state-building projects. This important work contributes to this scholarship by showing how the home was politicized in the Republican period. Scholars who are interested in women's education, urban history, and the World War II era will also benefit from the insights of this well-researched study. Keeping the Nation's House sheds new light on the gender politics of the Republican era by showing the overlaps and conflicts between the state project of national salvation and the intellectual movement for women's right to work. It is also recommended for anyone who is interested in social spaces, home economics, and feminism.
