Jennifer Waldron's Reformations of the Body: Idolatry, Sacrifice, and Early Modern Theater begins with examples from John Foxe's Actes and Monument and by introducing the Wycliffe follower Margery Baxter, who with outstretched arms declared herself ‘the true crosse of Christ’ (p. 39). Through a description of the body as ‘the true cross’, Waldron brings new insights to moments in secular drama that countermand the often-quoted jeremiads against the theatre by the likes of Stephen Gosson and Phillip Stubbes. Indeed, these anti-theatrical tracts have so come to dominate our understanding of church reformists’ relation to the stage that Waldron's study enables us to see how our received understandings have obscured our knowledge of reformist theology as well as the early modern theatre's view of it. Instead, Waldron describes a theatre aware of conversation about ‘dead idols and lively images’ within reformist movements as it encapsulates these debates on the stage. She thus shows a much more dialogic and dynamic history of ideas as it enters early modern performance.
Waldron convincingly reads moments in The Winter's Tale, Doctor Faustus, The Spanish Tragedy, Titus Andronicus, Othello and several works by Thomas Dekker in which actors’ bodies come to enact the ‘alignment of theology and theatre’ (p. 88). With this sweep from Thomas Kyd and Faustus through to the late plays of William Shakespeare and the Jacobean oeuvre of Dekker, she demonstrates how the history of early modern theatre is reflective of critical moments in theological developments. More particularly, as she locates the very crux of revenge tragedy, the seed of many tragedies to follow, within this theology, we thus come to see the religious roots of secular drama generally.
Before she begins her chronological movement from early Elizabethan to late Jacobean examples, Waldron provides a concrete and thus illuminating example as she demonstrates how Hermione's act of becoming a ‘lively image’ moves her out of her position as Marian statue before which one must kneel, and into the Protestant ideal of parental blessing. The body of the actor playing Hermione thus enacts the transition from idolatry to the true piety heralded by reform. This compelling analysis also illuminates the difference between the A-text and the B-text in Marlowe's Faustus, as the absence of Mephistopheles, Lucifer and Beelzebub in the A-text (against their presence in the B-text) presents a ‘psycho-theological cause’ divergent from morality play precedents in which such causes were consistently differently embodied. Again, it is the actors’ bodies, or absence thereof, that make possible this understanding. Throughout Waldron's deft readings, we realize again and again how actors' bodies do not manifest as ‘dead idols’ but rather live and breathe on the stage. In their liveliness, they present a challenge to the critiques that would deem them otherwise.
