Hamid Dabashi has written a provocative work that challenges misconceptions about Iran. In a Nietzschean fashion, Dabashi wishes to rescue Iranian history from the “binary opposition between ‘tradition’ and ‘modernity”’ (p. 10) and offer an account of Iran that is “more historically nuanced, culturally multifaceted, and materially grounded” (p. 10). In the broadest sense, this work is conceived as an “act of restitution” (p. 7) or an attempt to dismiss inaccurate “grand narratives” (p. 4) provided by other scholars.
The work is divided into seven chapters, where Dabashi presents approximately 200 years of Iranian history, including discussions of the Qajar dynasty, the Constitutional Revolution, the Pahlavi dynasty, the Iranian Revolution, the reconstruction era and reform movement, and the inauguration of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. The first chapter provides some theoretical background for the remainder of the work. Dabashi begins by building on Benedict Anderson's definition of the modern nation as a “fusion of conflicting ‘facts’ stuffed under the artificial and meaningless construct called a ‘nation”’ (p. 19). According to Dabashi, Iran is a “state of mind, systemically set to contradict itself” (p. 6) due to the fact that the mere notion of Iran as a “singular cultural identity” (p. 20) fails to incorporate “subnational, multicultural, multiethnic, multifaceted, syncretic, and hybrid fusion of divergent traits” (p. 20).
It is only natural that as a postcolonial specialist, Dabashi blames colonists and their imperial practices for this condition. Although Dabashi does not explicitly define colonialism and imperialism, he does express how these two concepts have affected Iranians. Compared to other cases of colonialism and imperialism in the Middle East, Iran's encounter was much different. For Dabashi, colonialists and imperialists in Iran have operated through academics who seek to discount the struggles of various subaltern groups and rewrite Iranian history in order to realize their goal of domination: “Denying the very course and causal condition of history (beginning with the history of the beleaguered empire itself) is the first step in paving the way for this pernicious global domination” (p. 9). In order to counteract this goal, it is necessary to focus on the peoples' struggles with these colonial and imperial empires and ensure that contemporary historical narratives include these struggles (p. 9).
Dabashi's bête noire in this book is the idea of “colonial modernity” (p. 10), where Iranians experienced modernity and colonialism simultaneously (p. 46). Dabashi demands that Iranians undergo a “decolonization of the mind” (p. 46), in which modernity is critiqued in light of colonial and imperialist overtones in order to silence this pernicious paradox of colonial modernity. Dabashi suggests moving toward an “anti-colonial modernity” (p. 98) that challenges the “false binaries” (p. 227) of tradition and modernity and has the ability to resurrect Iran's “cosmopolitan history” (p. 248). However, the path to achieving an anticolonial modernity is difficult and can be earned only in the “battlefields of their collective [anticolonial] struggle for emancipation from domestic tyranny and foreign domination alike” (p. 227).
I have two criticisms of this work—one textual and the other stylistic. First, there are a few inconsistencies in the text, in nomenclature and dates: Mohammad Saleh and Mirza Saleh appear on the same page (p. 32) in such a way that it is unclear if these are the same or different figures; various dates are given for the establishment of the Safavid dynasty (1500 on p. 23, 1501 on p. 36) and the death of Nasir al-Din Shah (1896 on p. 70, 1898 on p. 62); the establishment of SAVAK (National Intelligence and Security Organization) is erroneously attributed to 1958 (p. 130), although the correct year is 1957; and the reign of Muhammad Ali Shah is stated to have begun in 1906 (p. 79) despite the fact that his father was alive during this time. Furthermore, there seems to be some confusion as to which countries originally comprised George W. Bush's “Axis of Evil” in the 2002 State of the Union address. Dabashi mistakenly replaces Iraq for Syria (p. 202); Syria was included only some time later in the writings of former U.N. ambassador John Robert Bolton. I suspect that an obvious error of this kind, by a distinguished scholar, was perhaps intentional, considering Dabashi is against the “illegal and immoral” (p. 7) American-led invasion of Iraq in 2003.
Second, I cannot help but question Dabashi's introduction, which seems excessively opinionated and pugnacious and can prove quite exasperating, in places reading almost like a rant. Dabashi denounces his colleagues and describes Francis Fukuyama and Samuel Huntington as “self-delusional” (p. 4) historical reductionists, and he suggests bringing Kenneth Pollack to the International Criminal Court on charges of “crimes against humanity” (p. 7) for his supposed role in the 2003 American-led invasion of Iraq (p. 7). The reader interested in understanding the nuanced history of Iran is likely to find the litany of name-calling distracting. Also, his claim that he possesses more knowledge about Iran than various American and Iranian institutions seems not only suspect but hubristic: “I know things they do not know, or do not care to know, or would rather forget, or never learned, or would not tell you” (p. 11). It is unfortunate that, despite this grandiose promise, such details never emerge in his work.
Dabashi's purpose for writing this book is to dispel distorted historical views and provide a “straight history of Iran” (p. 11). Instead, Dabashi diverges from this straight path and presents his readers with inconsistencies, misconceptions, and unsubstantiated opinions. The fact that Dabashi provides almost sixty pages of detailed notes—including primary, secondary, archival, and Internet sources—does not preserve the book from becoming a soundboard for Dabashi's condemnatory comments and personal political views. These issues not only distract but also force the reader to question the validity and reliability of Dabashi's perspective. Readers who seek an objective account of Iranian history should perhaps consider another book.
