In 1901, four men from Booker T. Washington's Tuskegee Institute arrived in Togo to establish cotton production in the German colony. Over the following seven years, the delegation from Alabama helped develop a system that subjugated West Africans. The Tuskegee personnel opened an experimental farm, provided seed to all of Togo, and even ran a school whose students and graduates were forced to cultivate cotton. Other historians have recognized that this expedition has the potential to illuminate the histories of the three continents, but Andrew Zimmerman places it at the center of an impressively conceptualized and rigorously researched work that has the potential to be a paradigm shifter for historians of race, work, power, and ideas.Footnote 1 He argues that when Germans and African Americans applied the New South's lessons in economic domination to West Africa, they invented a Global South, propagating a regime of systematic exploitation theorized by an international community of social scientists and embraced by the League of Nations after World War I.
Alabama in Africa begins in the U.S. South with the struggle to control labor following emancipation. In a rich style sustained throughout the book, Zimmerman integrates the natural history of agriculture and the cultural history of race into an analysis driven by economic ideas. Relying chiefly on secondary and published primary sources for the American section, he describes the “biological-social complex” of cotton agriculture (21). Sharecropping travestied African American aspirations for autonomy, and cotton production continued to be understood as black work. In this context, Zimmerman naturally sees Booker T. Washington's blueprint for vocational training as “an attempt to redirect African American efforts at self-education into channels supportive of the political and economic status quo” (22).
Washington's encounter with Togo was mediated by German colonization, a process Zimmerman anchors in Europe. In 1886, the Prussian Settlement Commission settled German-speakers in Polish regions of the empire, at once thwarting the nationalist aspirations of the Poles and dictating the farming practices of the newcomers. Here Zimmerman pairs deep archival research with his talents as an intellectual historian of Germany. The settlement plan found supporters at the Verein für Sozialpolitik, an association formed in 1872 to convert social science into policy, but Marxists in the German Social Democratic Party rejected its authoritarianism. Germany extended its imperialism in Africa, where the Tuskegee expedition participated in imposing a “Negro” identity on African peoples. Zimmerman uses evidence from African archives to show that New South ideology served as “a weapon against specific forms of African economic and political autonomy in Togo” (155).
Alabama in Africa culminates with the argument that the ideas deployed in Togo “quickly became a central element of a liberal imperialism that has shaped global politics ever since” (173). Academics, including Chicago School sociologists, created “a racism of exploitation and subordination rather than a racism of conquest and annihilation,” and the League of Nations agreed that Togo was a model of benign colonialism (206). Where Daniel T. Rogers's Atlantic Crossings emphasized the creative potential of transatlantic reform, Alabama in Africa reveals the sinister side of international collaboration.Footnote 2 One of this book's many achievements is to bridge the historiographies of reform and empire.
Understood within the framework of imperialism, Booker T. Washington's accommodationism only appears more costly. Zimmerman's interpretation corroborates Louis R. Harlan's critical appraisal of the black leader and sustains Kevin K. Gaines's observation that many proponents of racial uplift reinforced economic hierarchies.Footnote 3 Americanists will be intrigued by the argument that Washington's involvement in Togo diverted him from the more “emancipatory” path he was contemplating in the late 1890s, but the larger point that Washington styled himself a “leader of colonized people everywhere” is ultimately more convincing and significant (60, 179).
As his assessment of Washington suggests, Zimmerman is more concerned with ideologies of control than with methods of resistance. Alabama in Africa includes sensitive descriptions of the struggles of black sharecroppers, Poles, and Africans, but its heroes are intellectuals who critiqued global capitalism, particularly Marxist anti-imperialists such as W. E. B. Du Bois. Historians accustomed to documenting mundane and incremental resistance might find this approach disconcerting, but Zimmerman provides new conceptual tools for those scholars too. By examining the control of work, he suggests the radical potential of free labor. Instead of focusing on whether governments acted to alleviate poverty, Alabama in Africa asks whether individuals would have the power to labor—or not labor—as they chose. Zimmerman's Marx is not an advocate of government action, but a man possessed of “a belief in free labor greater than that of any other economist” (68). The question becomes “whether free labor meant the autonomy of workers or new regimes of labor control” (66). Worker agency, it turns out, is more important than ever.
