On 28 November 1863, Richard Wagner dined with his friends Hans and Cosima von Bülow at the Hotel Brandenburg in Berlin. Wagner was in high spirits, having just relieved his usual financial worries by selling for ninety talers a gold snuff-box, a present from the grand duke of Baden. After dinner, Hans went off to prepare for a concert, while Cosima and Richard went for a drive ‘in a handsome carriage’. After a while, the latter recorded in his autobiography, they fell silent:
we gazed mutely into each other's eyes and an intense longing for the fullest avowal of the truth forced us to a confession, requiring no words whatever, of the incommensurable misfortune that weighed upon us. With tears and sobs we sealed a vow to belong to each other alone. It lifted a great weight from our hearts.Footnote 1
Although the relationship was consummated in the following June and a daughter, appropriately named Isolde, was born nine months later, they did not start living together until the spring of 1866. To lessen the pain of separation, Cosima presented her lover with a magnificent note-book, bound in brown leather, decorated with twelve gems of malachite and protected against prying eyes by a stout lock. In this Brown Book, Wagner recorded his most intimate thoughts and feelings for her to read later. As he was not writing with one eye on posterity (unlike when dictating his autobiography My Life to Cosima), it enjoys special authority.
On 11 September 1865, while living in Munich, Wagner wrote for Cosima: ‘I am the most German being. I am the German spirit. Question the incomparable magic of my works, compare them with the rest; and you can, for the present, say no differently than that – it is German.’Footnote 2 That seems unequivocal enough as an assertion of national identity, but – as so often with Wagner – complexity, if not confusion, lurked behind confident assertion. He went on:
But what is this German? It must be something wonderful, mustn't it, for it is humanly finer than all else? – Oh, heavens! It should have a soil this German! I should be able to find my people! What a glorious people it ought to become. But to this people only could I belong.Footnote 3
As this anguished doubting implies, Wagner's ‘Germany’ was an ideal construction which he despaired of ever seeing actually created.
Absence had not made the heart grow fonder. In August 1860, Wagner returned to Germany after eleven years in exile, but felt no patriotic emotion. To his friend and benefactor (and Cosima's father) Franz Liszt he wrote:
It is with a real sense of horror that I now think of Germany. . .May God forgive me, but all I see there is pettiness and meanness, the semblance and conceit of solidity, but without any real ground or basis. Half-heartedness in everyone and everything. . .I must also confess that setting foot on German soil again made not the slightest impression upon me, except, at most, a sense of surprise at the foolishness and unmannerliness of the language that was being spoken all around me. Believe me, we have no fatherland! And if I am ‘German’, it is no doubt because I carry my Germany around with me.Footnote 4
Wagner wrote so much, especially about himself, that all manner of conflicting views can be ascribed to him. In what follows, I shall address one particular aspect of his relationship with Germany that has not attracted the attention it deserves. It relates to his reading of recent German history. The context of the entry in the Brown Book just cited was a report published in an illustrated magazine of the jubilee celebrations of the Students’ Association (Burschenschaft) at Jena, the first and most famous of many similar organisations founded in German universities as Napoleon's empire in Germany collapsed. Liberal, democratic and nationalist, they soon fell victim to the reaction which followed the assassination of August Kotzebue in 1819, ‘the single most sensational act of the post-war decades in Germany’.Footnote 5 A popular playwright, Kotzebue was also a notorious reactionary and was suspected of being a Russian agent to boot. His assassin, Karl Ludwig Sand, was a member of the Jena Burschenschaft and became the great martyr-figure of the German student movement following his public execution by decapitation.
Wagner was sympathetic to Sand and hostile to Kotzebue, whose plays he regarded as the ultimate in philistine superficiality. It was a prejudice which may have dated back to his idolisation of his uncle Adolf, a prominent Leipzig intellectual who had nursed a special loathing for Kotzebue for both political and aesthetic reasons.Footnote 6 Richard Wagner was only two years old when the Jena Burschenschaft was founded and only six when it was suppressed, but the jubilee of 1865 brought the memories flooding back: ‘I gave way to gentle tears’, he recorded in the Brown Book.Footnote 7 That the memories were imagined did not make them any the less powerful, for they were underpinned by a political narrative. In Wagner's view, the ‘War of Liberation’ of 1813–15 which threw off twenty years of French tyranny had been a popular rising in the cause of liberty and independence: ‘Anno 1813 in Germany. . .14-year-old boys, and 60-year-old men, went running to camp! It was a fervent, sacred cause: to which were sung songs that sounded almost pious. That was hope! A Germany was to come into being.’Footnote 8
It was a crusade which also had a musical dimension in Wagner's memory. Among the visitors to his widowed mother's house in Dresden during his childhood was Carl Maria von Weber, Kapellmeister to the Saxon court. In his autobiography, Wagner recorded:
when my mother introduced the nine-year-old boy to him, and he asked what I wanted to become and hinted that it might even involve music, my mother said that, while I was wild about [Weber's opera] Der Freischütz, she had nevertheless noticed nothing in me that might suggest a talent for music.Footnote 9
Weber was a fervent nationalist, who set to music the most popular of all patriotic songs of the period – Theodor Körner's ‘Lützow's wild, audacious pursuit’. This celebrated the feats of a force of volunteers led by Ludwig Adolf Wilhelm von Lützow, from whose black uniforms with red piping and gold epaulettes come the black–red–gold colours of the German national flag.Footnote 10 The final verse of Körner's poem runs:
This was the first piece of music that the young Wagner transcribed.Footnote 11 For contemporary Germans, the poem was given added piquancy by the knowledge that Körner himself had been killed in action as a member of the Lützow Freikorps at the age of twenty-one. His posthumous fame was assured by the quality of his œuvre, which proved to be one of the most anthologised of the nineteenth century, and also by the visual tribute paid by his friend and comrade-in-arms Georg Friedrich Kersting when he included him in his celebrated painting of 1815 ‘At the Advance Guard’ (Am Vorposten) as one of the three soldiers who gave their lives in the war against Napoleon.Footnote 12 All three are wearing the large black velvet berets, the emblematic headgear of German patriots and favoured by Wagner throughout his life.
Weber's Freischütz, which aroused the young Wagner's wild enthusiasm, was more than an opera. In the verdict of the leading musical periodical of the day, the Allgemeine Musikalische Zeitung, it was ‘a national event’. So colossal was its success that everything else was driven from the stage: ‘and where does this appeal, this awesome power come from? It comes from the national character which inspires the opera and from its uniquely German qualities.’Footnote 13 If it owed much of its appeal to its numerous attractive melodies and brilliant orchestration, it had a special resonance because of the contemporary context. If the nominal setting of the opera is Bohemia in the aftermath of the Thirty Years War, everyone in the audience knew that it was really about Germany in the aftermath of the Napoleonic wars.Footnote 14 Although there is no overt political message, most of the characters are simple country people and the music they sing is steeped in a folk idiom. Extra nationalist spice was added to the premiere in Berlin on 18 June 1821 by the location. It was staged, not at the Court Opera House on Unter den Linden, where the Italian Gasparo Spontini ruled the roost, but at the new Playhouse on the Gendarmenmarkt.Footnote 15
Just how much of an impact Der Freischütz had made on Wagner was revealed by a review he wrote of the work in Paris in June 1841 for the Dresden Evening News. It reveals so eloquently his immersion in romantic-nationalist semiotics that it deserves to be quoted rather than paraphrased:
Oh, my magnificent German fatherland, how can I help loving you, how can I help adoring you, even if only because it was on your soil that Der Freischütz was written! How can I help loving the German people, the people that loves Der Freischütz, that even today still believes in the wonder of the most naïve fairy-tale, that even today, when it has reached its maturity, continues to experience that sweet, mysterious trembling which made its heart throb when it was young! Oh, how wonderful is German dreaming, with its visions of forests, of the evening, of the stars, of the moon, of the clock on the village church striking seven! Happy is the man who can understand you, who can believe, feel, dream and share your rapture with you! How happy I am to be German!Footnote 16
Sitting in the auditorium of the Paris Opera, these thoughts had ‘pierced my heart like a thrust from a voluptuous dagger’ (a very Wagnerian image) and had prompted him to burst into tears. The French, he went on, would have found the reason for this emotional outburst simply risible; only the Germans would understand, when he told them that it happened at the end of Act One, when the troubled huntsman is left alone brooding as the rest of the peasants dance their way into the inn to the strains of the Walzer, the most folksy of all the folksy tunes in Der Freischütz.
The setting of Der Freischütz shortly after the end of the Thirty Years War played an important part in Wagner's historical narrative of Germany, for it was then, in his view, that an existing pernicious development had become irreversible. He set out his version of German history since the sixteenth century on several occasions, most explicitly in the ‘diary entries’ he wrote for the benefit of King Ludwig II of Bavaria. The rot had set in, he opined, with Charles V, the multi-national, unGerman emperor who had supported the decadent papacy against Luther's Reformation. Until then, the German princes had marched largely in step with the German spirit but now, with very few exceptions, they increasingly whored after foreign models and fashions. Any remaining ties with the people were then severed by the devastation inflicted by rampaging foreign armies after 1618: ‘from the end of the Thirty Years War Germany in effect ceased to exist’.Footnote 17 Chief among the princely renegades arraigned by Wagner was Frederick the Great of Prussia, who despised his people and everything to do with Germany, devoted himself exclusively to French culture, spoke only French and even thought only in French. His example was followed by all the other princes, great and small, the only variation being that those in the south followed Austria in finding Italian and Spanish models more seductive.Footnote 18
This collective act of cultural treason had persisted until Wagner's own day. The great movement of the eighteenth century, which had brought forth, among others, Bach, Lessing, Goethe, Schiller, Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven and Kant, went unnoticed by the rulers, with very few exceptions. It was from the reviving spirit of the German people that this revival came and, between 1813 and 1815, it inspired them to rise up and throw off the yoke imposed by their French conquerors. Alas, the princes failed to understand what was happening: like Frederick the Great, they viewed their subjects merely as cannon fodder and so expected them to return to their subservient status once the Napoleonic wars ended. They judged everything by French standards and so saw in the enthusiasm of the German people only Jacobin subversion. From ‘this terrible misunderstanding’, Wagner lamented, Germany had gone on suffering until the present day, leaving the princes just as purblind as they had ever been. In all of history, he thundered, there could be no blacker story of ingratitude than the treason of the German princes: the German people had got rid of the French oppressors only to find that their princes had reinstated French civilisation!
The battlefields which had resounded to Körner's songs were still reeking of the blood of martyred German patriots when the princes resumed their addiction to foreign fashions. It was Italians such as Rossini and Spontini who were summoned to Vienna and Berlin to provide entertainment. Nothing had changed since then: still today (in 1865), he complained, if the king of Prussia or the emperor of Austria wished to lay on a gala for a visiting dignitary, then it was always a French play or an Italian opera that was staged. The great Schiller celebrations of 1859, when nearly 500 German towns had commemorated the centenary of the great poet's birth, had shown what could be done, but none of Germany's rulers had noticed. Only in Bavaria, Wagner flatteringly told Ludwig II, had successive kings recognised a mission ‘for the salvation of the German people’.Footnote 19
This was actually more than flattery, for the most spectacular tribute to German culture sponsored by a German prince had indeed been made by a Wittelsbach. Between 1830 and 1842, Ludwig's grandfather, King Ludwig I, had built ‘Walhalla’, a classical temple on the banks of the Danube near Regensburg, containing ninety-six busts of great Germans. Its purpose was proclaimed by its creator at the opening: ‘May Walhalla foster the strengthening and expansion of German feeling. May all Germans, from whatever region they may come, always feel that they share a common fatherland, of which they are proud and to which they contribute with all their might for its greater glory.’Footnote 20 Among the original honorands was of course Schiller. Although Shakespeare and Beethoven are usually given pride of place on the rather short list of people Wagner admired unequivocally, Schiller must also be included. In all the voluminous writings by and about Wagner, his name appears again and again. For example, Opera and Drama (1851), the most important of the ‘Zürich reform writings’, reveals that Wagner knew Schiller's works inside out. He observed Schiller's birthday on 10 November every year ceremonially. The exception that proved the rule was 1869 when it got forgotten in the intensive work on the composition of Twilight of the Gods. Reminded by Cosima a day later, Wagner had a good answer: ‘well, yesterday was the very day on which, while I was working, I felt inwardly pleased by Schiller's picture hanging on the wall opposite me, and I pictured to myself his whole essence’.Footnote 21 Perhaps the ultimate tribute he offered was to consider staging Schiller's trilogy Wallenstein at Bayreuth.
Most fundamentally, Wagner admired Schiller because of his advocacy of an aesthetic approach to politics, best summarised in his two celebrated aphorisms: ‘the jurisdiction of the stage begins where the realm of secular laws ends’ and ‘if man is ever to solve the problem of politics in practice, he will have to take the aesthetic route, because it is only through beauty that man makes his way to freedom’.Footnote 22 Wagner also shared Schiller's fundamental aversion to utilitarian considerations playing any role in culture. In his Letters on the Aesthetic Education of Mankind of 1794, from which the second of the two aphorisms just quoted is taken, Schiller excoriated utility as ‘the great idol of our age, for which all forces must slavishly labour and all talents must worship’.Footnote 23 He took Kant's definition of aesthetic experience as ‘pleasure without any practical interest’ and built on it a programme for moral and, eventually, political liberation.Footnote 24 Wagner took this further but gave it a nationalist twist. It had been a German achievement, the achievement of Winckelmann, Lessing, Goethe and, of course, Schiller, to rediscover the non-utilitarian aesthetics of classical antiquity. Whereas the Italians had just plundered it for what they could easily imitate, and the French had then taken from the Italians what suited their national obsession with elegant forms, the Germans had recognised what was ‘purely human’ (reinmenschlich) and completely divorced from utility.Footnote 25 In The Artwork of the Future, Wagner stated firmly that the arts ‘can only initiate creative work in partnership with artistic humans, not with those who are bent on utilitarian ends’.Footnote 26
But Wagner's sense of affinity with his hero also derived from a sense of fellow-suffering. Born a subject of the duke of Württemberg, Schiller had been given a good education at an elite military school but had also felt the heavy hand of princely despotism, including a ban on any further publications after his first sensational success, The Robbers. In 1782, he had fled, eking out a wandering existence until settling in Jena in 1787. This unhappy history intensified Wagner's often-expressed loathing of the German princes. It was of course enhanced by his own perceived persecution by the king of Saxony, which in 1849 sent him into exile pursued by an arrest warrant. Cosima's diaries contain many irate expostulations about the princes. In July 1869: ‘a violent outburst against the German princes, who lend their support to nothing, to neither talent nor natural gifts, they let everything truly German die of neglect’. In August 1869:
when one thinks that our courts are nothing but imitations of the court of Louis XIV, which meant something in the France of his day, and now all these little Napoleons can think of is to surround themselves with the same hocus-pocus! No nobler ambitions, in art only what is most vulgar; and for that they spend all their money, yes, even spill blood.
In November 1871: ‘in the evening read Plato's Republic to R. with much enjoyment. – before that R. read from Freytag's book about the times of the war of liberation, always delighting in the German people and being shocked by the wickedness of the German princes’.Footnote 27
Wagner's version of recent German history was both populist and radical. It found expression in his operas in a number of ways. Chronologically, the first was Rienzi, the Last of the Tribunes, based on the novel by Edward Bulwer Lytton. Later disowned by Wagner himself, never performed at Bayreuth, mischievously dubbed ‘Meyerbeer's best opera’ by Hans von Bülow and invariably presented as a fascist parable whenever it is staged, it nevertheless contains much memorable music, notably the overture, the conclusion to Act Two and ‘Rienzi's prayer’ which opens Act Five. It also gave Wagner an early opportunity to portray the German princes in all their brutal selfishness, lightly disguised as the noble factions competing for the domination of fourteenth-century Rome. In Act One, as the Orsinis try to ravish Rienzi's sister Irene, a street brawl threatens to erupt when they are stopped by the rival Colonnas. Rienzi intervenes and takes the opportunity to denounce all noble factions:
What crime is there left to you? You have turned Ancient Rome, the Queen of the World, into a den of thieves, desecrating the Church, so that the Pope had to flee to distant Avignon. No pilgrim dares to make his way to Rome to celebrate the great festivals of the Church, for like highwaymen you lie in wait to rob them. Exhausted, impoverished, once-proud Rome is wasting away, and you even take from the poorest of the poor what little they still possess. Like criminals, you break into homes and places of work, cutting down the men and ravishing the women. Just look around you and see what you have done. Look around you – these ancient temples, these great columns, tell you of the time when Rome was free and great, when it ruled the world and its citizens could call themselves the kings of kings. Tell me, you bandits, are there still Romans?Footnote 28
Opposed by the nobility, betrayed by the church and deserted by the people, Rienzi dies with Irene at the end of the opera, as the Capitol goes up in flames, but not before he has made one last declaration of love for his fatherland. In response to Irene's jibe that he does not know what it is to renounce a love because he has never loved a woman, he furiously responds:
‘Or Germany’, Wagner might well have added. The vision of a once great nation torn apart by factional feuding kept recurring, although it would of course be reductionist to try to include every one of his operas in this interpretive scheme, or even to present it as his main concern. In Tannhäuser (1844–5) it is apparently peripheral. The ruler of thirteenth-century Thuringia, Landgrave Hermann, is presented sympathetically as an eirenic patron of the arts. In his address to the knights of his court before the singing contest, however, he reminds them of the recent bad times, when they had been forced to wage bloody war to assert the majesty of the German Empire against the ferocious Guelphs and domestic discord.Footnote 30 Moreover, it soon becomes clear that all is not well in Thuringia. Tannhäuser has returned from the fleshpots of the Venusberg (mons veneris) to find a complacent, hidebound, inward-looking society which mistakes the formal expression of love for the real thing. No great acumen is needed to spot that this is Wagner returning from Paris to Dresden in 1842. Just as Tannhäuser was expelled from the Wartburg for telling the truth about the essential carnality of love, so was Wagner driven into exile by the king of Saxony for joining the revolution in 1848–9.
He took his critique a step further in Lohengrin, written and composed in Dresden between 1846 and 1848, although not performed until 1850 (at Weimar by courtesy of his friend Franz Liszt). Although set in an even earlier period, it was also more topical. In 932 ad, the German king and duke of Saxony Henry the Fowler has terminated a truce with the Hungarians. To rally support for the impending war, he goes to Brabant, the westernmost territory of the German Empire, to rally support. On arrival, he proceeds to berate the local nobility, assembled on the banks of the river Scheldt outside Antwerp:
But his ringing appeal – ‘The time has come to defend the honour of the Empire, and that applies in equal measure to everyone, east and west!’ – falls on deaf ears. His Saxon and Thuringian followers shout their support, but the Brabanters stay glumly silent: Hungary is a long way away, and what business is it of theirs? It is only when the charismatic hero, Lohengrin, appears from nowhere, defeats the evil Frederick of Telramund in single combat and adds his voice in support of Henry's crusade that they respond. Even then, there remains a dissenting group:
First Noble: Listen to him! Does he mean to take us away from our land?
Second Noble: To fight an enemy who has never been a threat to us?
Third Noble: We must not let him get this underway!
Fourth Noble: But who will stop him when he orders us to march?
Frederick of Telramund: I shall.
They fail. When King Henry musters the men of Brabant in the final scene, he is greeted with unanimous shouts of ‘Hail!’ His speech of thanks which follows is one of the few overtly nationalist passages in all of Wagner's œuvre:
All present then roar out the last two lines. Unsurprisingly, this passage has proved problematic for many present-day directors and is often cut, as is the assurance given a little later by Lohengrin to Henry when explaining that he will not be able to join him in the campaign against the Hungarians: ‘Great king, let me predict to you that you will win a great victory, and that from now until the end of days the hordes of the East will never prevail!’Footnote 32 Wagner, of course, was not thinking of the Hungarians of the tenth century but of the Russians of the nineteenth, whose tsar, Nicholas I, had the well-deserved reputation of being the most tyrannical of all European sovereigns. It was also well known that he kept the German princes (he was married to a sister of King Frederick William IV of Prussia) on the straight and narrow path of reaction. Wagner made the connection explicit in a crucial passage in his autobiography:
Now that I had finally completed Lohengrin, I had for the first time the leisure necessary to look about and study the course of events, and thus I could no longer remain personally indifferent to the lively ferment in which the idea of Germany and the hopes for its realisation had plunged everybody. . .Instead of speeches, I wanted deeds, specifically deeds from our princes whereby they would break irrevocably with their old ways, so injurious to wider German interests. To this end I got excited enough to write a popular appeal in verse, calling upon the German princes and their peoples to launch a great military undertaking against Russia, the apparent source of the pressure in favour of those policies of the German princes that had so fatefully alienated them from their subjects. One stanza ran:
His own freedom in Germany came to an abrupt end with the failure of the rising in Dresden in May 1849, almost the last episode in the abortive German revolutions of 1848–9. Sparked off by the king of Saxony's refusal to accept the new (and equally abortive) German constitution, it was quickly put down with Prussian help.Footnote 34 Wagner had been deeply involved. Indeed, the Saxon prosecutor's indictment accused him of being one of the leaders and, more specifically, of holding meetings at his home to plan the insurrection; of ordering the manufacture of hand-grenades; of manning an observation-post on the tower of the Church of the Cross (Kreuzkirche); and of raising support in the countryside around Dresden.Footnote 35 On 9 May, just as the Prussians were regaining complete control of the city, he succeeded in escaping, in the company of the Russian anarchist Mikhail Bakunin. Pursued by a warrant for his arrest, he made his way, first to Weimar, where he was helped by the ever-generous Franz Liszt, and then to Switzerland, which he reached by the end of the month.
When dictating his autobiography to Cosima for the benefit of the autocratic King Ludwig II in the mid-1860s, Wagner was at pains to play down his revolutionary activism, claiming that he had just decided ‘to let the tide of events carry me wherever it might. . .to surrender myself to the stream of events’.Footnote 36 This exculpation was contradicted both by his actions during 1848–9 and by his continuing commitment to violent revolution after he had fled. Indicative of his radicalism was – among many other inflammatory tirades – a newspaper article published in April 1849 in which a personification of ‘Revolution’ proclaims:
I will utterly annihilate the established order in which you live, for it springs from sin, its flower is misery and its fruit is crime; but the seed has ripened and I am the reaper. I will destroy every wrong which has power over men. I will destroy the domination of one over the other, of the dead over the living, of the material over the spiritual, I will shatter the power of the mighty, of the law and of property. Man's master shall be his own will, his own desire his only law, his own strength his only property, for only the free man is holy and there is nought higher than he. Let there be an end to the wrong that gives one man power over millions, which subjects millions to the will of one individual, to the evil which teaches that one has the power to give happiness to all others. Equals may not rule equals, equals have no higher power than equals, and since all are equal I shall destroy all dominion of one over the other.Footnote 37
There is much more in the same vein. His correspondence of the period was equally extreme, for example: ‘I have no money but an enormous desire to commit acts of artistic terrorism’ (to Franz Liszt); ‘My business is to bring about revolution wherever I go’ (to Theodor Uhlig); and ‘I long passionately for the revolution, and the only thing that gives me the will to live is the hope of surviving long enough to see it and to take part in it’ (to Ernst Benedikt Kietz).Footnote 38
Although Germany was to be the first port of call for his ‘sublime Goddess of Revolution’, Wagner was looking for nothing less than a world revolution that would emancipate all humanity, for she promises, among other things: ‘I shall destroy the existing order of things which divides mankind into hostile nations.’Footnote 39 In October 1848, the actor Edward Devrient recorded in his diary: ‘Wagner brought me a sketch for an opera; he still has these great socialist ideas in his head. Now it is not enough for him to have a united Germany, now it has to be a united Europe, a united humanity indeed.’Footnote 40 Expelled from Germany and, as it turned out, not able to return for eleven years, his horizons widened. Neither his numerous ‘Zürich reform writings’ nor the tetralogy The Ring of the Nibelung are informed by a nationalist perspective. Even the most notorious of the former – Judaism in Music – ends with the injunction: ‘take part in this work of redemption through self-denial, for then we are one and indivisible’.Footnote 41 This universalism was then given a powerful impetus by his acquaintance with the philosophy of Arthur Schopenhauer, made in 1854, which had a profound, if sometimes over-stated, influence on his subsequent works.Footnote 42 Characteristically, Wagner claimed that he had been a Schopenhauerian intuitively even before reading his magnum opus The World as Will and Idea.Footnote 43
The Ring of the Nibelung (whose text he did not alter but reinterpreted to fit his new Weltanschauung), Tristan and Isolde, The Mastersingers of Nuremberg and Parsifal deal with great universal themes such as the incompatibility of love and power, domination-free discourse, sexual and social revolution and the renunciation of desire. Yet Wagner's old hatred of the decadent world of the German nobility was never far away. In Twilight of the Gods, it appears as the court of the Gibichungs, where the degenerate Gunther and his pathetic sister Gutrune are unable even to find mates by their own efforts. They have to rely on the trickery of their half-brother, the evil Hagen, and so are drawn into a web of deceit, treachery and murder. Hagen's father is the capitalist plutocrat Alberich, who half-seduced and half-raped Queen Grimhilde, a mésalliance epitomising the unholy marriage of new money and old blood in nineteenth-century Europe. Hagen is thus the polar opposite of Siegfried, the product of the loving union between the twins Siegmund and Sieglinde, a hero without fear, malice or ambition and so doomed to succumb to the wiles of his enemy.
The theme of the charismatic hero coming from outside to redeem the tired world of the old regime was one of Wagner's favourites – Rienzi, Tannhäuser, Lohengrin, Siegfried, Walther von Stolzing, perhaps Tristan, certainly Parsifal, all qualify.Footnote 44 The most explicit criticism of the nobility is to be found in The Mastersingers, specifically in the final peroration of Hans Sachs. Having won the singing competition and thus the hand of the beautiful (and rich) Eva Pogner, Walther at first refuses to enter the guild of mastersingers, not unreasonably perhaps, given his earlier treatment by them. Hans Sachs then steps forward to save the day by giving Walther a sharp reminder that he had won not because of the length of his noble pedigree but by his merit as an artist. It was the mastersingers, he goes on, who had kept the flame of true German art burning in the dark days, which, alas, were about to return:
This passage has been denounced for being ‘chauvinistic’Footnote 46 or even ‘a summons to a racial war on the Latins’Footnote 47 but was not directed against foreigners at all, as the context (and a careful reading of the text) reveals. The work is set in the newly Protestant city of Nuremberg in the mid-sixteenth century (the historical Hans Sachs's dates were 1494–1576). Sachs is looking forward with anxiety (and Wagner is looking back in anger) to a period of civil strife driven by religious hatreds, culminating in the Thirty Years War of 1618–48. Sachs is of course right to be alarmed. The Holy Roman Empire will indeed fragment as Spanish, Danish, Dutch, Swedish and French armies rampage across German-speaking Europe, aided and abetted by the German princes. Even after military conflict has come to an end, foreign domination will persist in the form of the French and, to a lesser extent, Italian culture imitated by the deluded princes, slaves to alien fashions. Only the authentic, if unsophisticated, culture of the mastersingers will keep the native flame burning. In other words, Sachs is not targeting foreigners, nor is he asserting German superiority; his anger is reserved for the German princes. Although Wagner certainly had a low opinion of contemporary French culture, he blamed its materialism and superficiality not on the French nation but on the oppression of Napoleon III's Empire.Footnote 48 If ‘chauvinism’ is defined as ‘exaggerated patriotism of a bellicose sort, blind enthusiasm for national glory or military ascendancy’ (as it is by the Oxford English Dictionary), there is nothing chauvinistic about this speech.
Hans Sachs would have been even more upset had he been able to look into the future and see what happened when German native culture did find its feet again in the course of the eighteenth century. The great cultural revival was accompanied by a new political catastrophe after 1792 when the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic wars turned Germany into a French colony to be exploited at will. In 1813, Wagner believed, the German people rose in revolt in a great war of liberation and threw off the foreign yoke, only to find that the German princes had not changed one jot. The traitors were still inside the gates and still wedded to ‘foreign delusions and baubles’. In November 1878, Cosima recorded in her diary: ‘R. says that the 1813 uprising, so misinterpreted by the ruling princes and thus crushed, was as much a disaster for Germany as the Thirty Years War.’Footnote 49 That few historians would accept the Wagner version of modern German history does not matter. It enjoyed wide popularity at the time, not least because it was popularised by Friedrich Schiller. Wagner himself cited Schiller's poem ‘The German Muse’, in which a sense of grievance about the lack of princely patronage was outweighed by the pride the German people could take in the knowledge that they had created their culture by their own unaided efforts. In an unpublished draft of a poem, written partly in prose and partly in verse, of the same period (1801) which was later given the title ‘German Greatness’, Schiller returned to the theme:
At a time when two arrogant nations [France and Great Britain] have their feet on his neck, can the German hold up his head. . .and take his place with pride among the peoples of the world? Yes he can! He may suffer misfortune in war, but he has not lost what constituted his real value. The German Empire and the German nation are two quite different things. The majesty of the German never rested on the heads of his princes. The German has founded his own true value away from politics and even if the Empire were to go under, German dignity would remain inviolate. For it is a moral form of greatness and resides in culture and the character of the nation, which is quite independent from its political fate
. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .
Hans Sachs’a final speech in The Mastersingers, in other words, sounds almost like Schiller set to music. Although Wagner cited ‘The German Muse’, he cannot have known the longer version, which was not published until 1871 in volume xi of Schiller's complete works published in 1871. Although this was in Wagner's library at Wahnfried, he had finished his libretto nine years earlier.Footnote 51 In any event, the uncanny resemblance between the two texts reveals how close were their conceptions of modern German history.
Of all the traitorous German princes, the most toxic were the Prussians. As a Saxon, Wagner had special reason to hate them. The end of the Napoleonic wars brought victory for the Germans but defeat for the Saxons. As their king, Frederick Augustus I, stayed loyal to Napoleon until the end, Saxony had been punished with the loss to Prussia of more than 40 per cent of its population and more than half of its territory. That gave a special piquancy to Lohengrin, for in the tenth century, when Saxony was the dominant force in Germany and the German king was a Saxon, Brandenburg did not even exist. It was only for a brief period during and after the Franco-Prussian War of 1870–1 that Wagner felt anything positive about Prussia and even then – like most non-Prussian Germans – it was for the negative reason that Prussia was putting the French to the sword. On 22 January 1871, Cosima recorded:
Regarding the outcry in the press against the bombardment of Paris, R. says: ‘Now at last I understand the Prussians and their stiff, buttoned-up character; it used to annoy me to see the King of Prussia in that uniform buttoned right up to the neck, even in his workroom. But now I can understand it; if it had been otherwise, we should be lost.’Footnote 52
This enthusiasm did not last long. In 1871, he proclaimed: ‘Wonderful progress is being made in establishing the new Reich. . .Anyone who does not understand figures such as Bismarck, Roon & Moltke around this King Wilhelm – is very much to be pitied’ but five years later he was complaining: ‘The world, and more especially “Germania”, is becoming increasingly repugnant to me!’Footnote 53 As for Bismarck, when he met him in 1871, Wagner was ‘utterly enchanted with the genuine charm of his character’.Footnote 54 By 1878, he was commenting ‘no good star is watching over Bismarck's creation’ and later the same year was finding him guilty of ‘great superficiality!’.Footnote 55 By the end of the year, Bismarck was dismissed as ‘a bad man’, although with the characteristic proviso that ‘the princes are entirely to blame’.Footnote 56 In October 1880, Cosima recorded, ‘he expresses to me his utter antipathy to Bismarck’ and the following March he called him ‘a brutal barbarian’.Footnote 57 The bellicose Francophobia of 1870–1 was by now very much a thing of the past. On 6 September 1880, Cosima made the following revealing entry in her diary:
Yesterday a poem by E. Geibel in celebration of [the battle of] Sedan aroused utter disgust, and today a ‘Germania’ in the Illustrirte the same feeling; R. says ‘I have only to see a fellow in a winged helmet and I feel sick.’ – And the description of the battle itself produces from him an outburst of indignation: ‘The dead horses alone are enough! And it all shows the barbaric times in which we live.’ – The Emperor's latest speech to the army, which ends with the words that his final thoughts will always be for the army, evokes from R. the exclamation, ‘I should have thought for the ballet – a person like that is nothing more than a dim-witted soldier, and that's about all they know!’ He wonders how to save Fidi [their son Siegfried] from having to do military service – through naturalisation elsewhere? Continual thoughts of America, above all in order to gain independence for himself and particularly for Parsifal.Footnote 58
In conclusion, I must repeat my recognition that Wagner's attitudes to the German nation cannot be reduced to admiration of Friedrich Schiller and hostility to the German princes and nobility. From all the immense riches of his work, there is a great deal more to be mined on this subject, as so many analysts have demonstrated. I hesitate to say that this particular niche has been left unexplored because so much more has been written about Wagner than even the most diligent and uninterrupted scholar can hope to master or even be aware of.Footnote 59 However, in view of a persistent tendency to write about Wagner's politics as if an indictment for a war crimes tribunal were being prepared, it bears restating.
