Mark Swanson's Coptic Papacy is the second volume of a trilogy due to be completed in late 2011. The title of the book and the series may be somewhat puzzling to Western readers. Both draw upon the fact that Heracles of Alexandria (d. 247 a.d.) was the first bishop to be addressed as pappas, a designation that has been retained for the Alexandrian prelate ever since. (Roman bishops did not routinely employ the title until the 6th century.) The present volume, analyzing Coptic patriarchal biographies from the dawn of Arab rule through the Mamluk era, will be of great interest to anyone researching the history of Egypt, intercommunal relations under Islamic rule, or Christian Arabic Studies. It is a nuanced, thoughtful volume that fills an important gap within scholarly literature.
In large measure, the leanness of the monograph (which chronologically covers nearly as much as the other two volumes in the series combined but is in fact shorter than both) is due to Swanson's admirable ability to focus squarely on his topic. Coptic Papacy is not a history of the Coptic Church or community per se nor a discussion of Coptic–Muslim relations as such, though both topics figure prominently in the work. Rather, this is an analysis of the history and historiography of Coptic Patriarchs. (Although the title “Pope” is attested throughout the period surveyed, it comes in at a distant second to “Patriarch” in Coptic Arabic literature and in this book.) Swanson, a specialist in Arab Christian Studies, pens a masterful account, drawing upon a wide array of sources, including the writings of Arab Muslim historians (particularly al-Maqrizi and Ibn Taghribirdi), hagiographic literature, liturgical texts, Coptic Arabic nomocanons, and unpublished manuscripts. His prose is lucid, engaging, and certainly not short on wit. Although Swanson positions Coptic Popes at the center of the narrative, he is careful to touch on the status of the community and its leadership as well as the tenor of intercommunal relations in each chapter. Additionally, interspersed throughout the volume are concise discussions of important saints and authors, Coptic Arabic texts (where several pseudonymous attributions are amended), and the contentious issues of conversion and Arabization.
The first two thirds of the monograph (Chapters 1–6) are, by necessity, heavily dependent upon the History of the Patriarchs (HP). Inaugurated in the 5th century A.D., the lengthy HP—2,300 pages in the current Arabic-English editions—provides official biographies of Coptic patriarchs. It remains the single most important text for the premodern history of the Coptic Orthodox Church and is of great significance for the study of Egyptian history, particularly from the rise of Islam through the period of Ayyubid rule. Rather than pursuing the typical route of simply summarizing the HP, however, Swanson renders these chapters into a sophisticated thematic and historical study, equally concerned with literary themes and tropes as with forwarding a history of the Coptic hierarchy. Coptic Papacy may thus be perceived as a parallel volume to Johannes den Heijer's Mawhub ibn Mansur (Louvain: E. Peeters, 1989). Whereas Den Heijer's focus is largely textual, however, Swanson is much more concerned with exploring the style, content, and historical setting of patriarchal biographies. Additionally, Coptic Papacy structurally conforms to Den Heijer's textual dissection of the HP; hence, the book's nine chapters correspond to nine HP quires (a series of biographies composed or edited by a single author), the first six of which (covering 623–1250 a.d.) are rich in historical details—religious, secular, and political—and may be firmly attributed to specific authors or compilers. In each of these chapters, Swanson traces the careers of the various patriarchs against a background of intracommunal developments, regional politics, and societal change. He also effectively demonstrates each author's stylistic moorings and the intertextuality that punctuates the work. Beyond the originality of the historical narrative, Swanson's literary analysis of what traditionally has been read from a purely historical angle is refreshing and charts new paths for historical inquiry. It is difficult to overestimate the methodological significance of those six chapters, which dispel the monolithic perception of the HP while providing a trustworthy guide to its strengths, weaknesses, and pitfalls.
The final third of the volume (Chapters 7–9) investigating Coptic patriarchs under Mamluk rule is an achievement in itself and was undoubtedly the most demanding to write. Whereas the HP is essential for Egyptian and Coptic history through the Ayyubid era, the text borders on useless when it comes to the Mamluk period. Aside from the substantial biography of Patriarch Matthew I (1378–1408 a.d.), the Lives spanning the 14th and 15th centuries are seldom longer than a page. Many consist of a single paragraph reminiscent of an obituary rather than a vita. Here, Swanson draws upon decades of his own research reading difficult-to-access manuscripts in order to stitch together an impressive narrative anchored by several contemporaneous but, hitherto, unpublished hagiographic Lives. These chapters tend to focus more on the community and the patriarchs’ better-documented contemporaries than the popes themselves—an unavoidable deviation from the earlier pattern given the dearth of relevant sources. The 15th century in particular constituted a rather bleak period in Egyptian history, even more so for the beleaguered Coptic community, which attended to serious internal conflicts while staving off a host of external challenges and threats. Throughout this final third of the book, Swanson judiciously parses the trials faced by all Egyptians from those that were unique to the Copts.
The book is well documented, though at junctures the endnotes are limited to the HP and other primary sources, a likely editorial (American University in Cairo Press) decision that is mitigated somewhat by the book's ample bibliography. Finally, an uncrossed “t”: in summarizing the dynamics that culminated in the official transfer of the patriarchate to Cairo and the designation of Fustat-Cairo as a patriarchal diocese (pp. 65–66), Swanson takes for granted the end of that episode. Both Michael IV (1092–1102) and Macarius II (1102–28) failed to appropriate the diocese due to pressure from lay and clerical elites who demanded to have their own bishop. The decisive step was taken by Gabriel ibn Turayk (1131–45), who purposefully refused to appoint a bishop for Fustat-Cairo to succeed Yuʾannis ibn Sanhut (d. 1134), which led to the acquisition of the diocese by the Pope and the end of a long, highly contentious debate.
Swanson's Coptic Papacy is a significant contribution that will be deeply appreciated by students and scholars. It presents an original, engaging survey of nearly 900 years of Coptic history under Islamic rule while forwarding a structured discussion and interpretation of the lengthy HP and, to a lesser extent, several other Arabic Coptic sources. All will welcome Swanson's methodological approach, nuanced reading of the sources, and ability to place Coptic history within its Islamic cultural and political milieu.
