Federal policy toward American Indians is at the heart of American political history but is largely absent in the political science literature on American political development, as Stephen J. Rockwell demonstrates in his impressive book. Rockwell presents a compelling case for revisiting our ideas about the nineteenth-century bureaucratic state and about the political foundations of the American West. As he illustrates effectively, the bureaucracy in charge of Indian affairs in the early nineteenth century exercised extraordinary power, decades earlier than conventional wisdom would have it about the rise of bureaucracy in the United States. This bureaucracy endured across the nineteenth century's changing politics, economics, and demographics. The settlement of the West—starting with the Northwest Territories—hinged on extensive and successful federal intervention to create “open” lands stripped of American Indian nations. The author carefully reviews the voluminous historical scholarship, providing a powerful new lens.
Rockwell also makes a significant contribution to the study of American racial politics. Indian Affairs and the Administrative State in the Nineteenth Century pairs well with C. Vann Woodward's The Strange Career of Jim Crow (1955) and other works on the great exertions to build the American racial order. The implication of Rockwell's work is that American bureaucracy was born in the campaigns for white privilege. Felix Cohen, in his landmark Handbook of Federal Indian Law (1942, 174–75), termed it “perhaps the greatest concentration of administrative absolutism in our governmental structure.”
Rockwell describes a modern yearning to see agents of federal Indian policy as corrupt and incompetent, not as talented professionals. Contemporary critics of those agents were eager to make such charges, even if they lacked evidence, and he argues that scholars have accepted those charges without critically evaluating them.
The author identifies the three eras of federal Indian policy in the nineteenth century: pacification, removal, and containment (p. 6). Administrators of federal Indian policy saw their tasks shift dramatically—along with changes in the particular name and organization of the “Indian Office”—yet they maintained high performance. In the early nineteenth century, federal officials pacified Indian nations by negotiating treaty concessions and controlling all trade with them. As white demands for Indian lands intensified in the Southeast and the Northwest Territories, federal policy shifted to the removal of Indian nations to lands west of the Mississippi River. The Cherokee Trail of Tears—the brutal, forced march of the Cherokee from Georgia into present-day Oklahoma—may be the best-known case of removal, but the policy was forced upon many Indian peoples. Finally, as more whites pushed west of the Mississippi, containment policy took hold. Federal agents isolated Indians on reservations and also expropriated reservation lands for white settlement. Alongside political control, economic control, and physical confinement, federal agents administered a slate of social interventions for “civilizing” Indian peoples.
Each of these three eras—pacification, removal, and containment—was a distinct yet massive bureaucratic endeavor. Rockwell demonstrates that all three policies involved complex on-the-ground logistics, as well as delicate negotiations with multiple and competing interests. Officials oversaw the minutiae of life in Indian nations that varied greatly in their culture, economy, military prowess, and sociopolitical organization. Field agents balanced demands from an array of white stakeholders: local farmers, merchants, fur traders, missionaries, military commanders, and East Coast humanitarians. The author illustrates how administrators in the Indian Office met these challenges with great skill.
Two elements in the Indian Office's success were its large budget and broad mandate. Even Andrew Jackson, a supposed advocate of limited government, worked assiduously to expand the power and scope of federal Indian administration (pp. 132–58). The agency's internal operations mattered as well. Due to the accomplishments of local bureaucrats, a “culture of discretion” emerged in the Indian Office (pp. 104–18). Also, appointments were not decided solely by patronage. Rockwell identifies appointees with extensive experience either in Indian affairs or in management (pp. 246–56).
The author argues that contemporary allegations of corrupt and incompetent Indian field agents reflected political tactics rather than actual practices. First, such charges could play on the public's humanitarian sympathies, even if they were not supported by evidence (pp. 122–23). Second, as field agents were constantly bargaining among multiple and competing interests, the parties nearly always felt slighted (pp. 211–16). Third, federal officials often turned a blind eye to Indian mistreatment in order to placate their local opponents (pp. 183–87). Federal officials were concerned primarily with political and economic control (pp. 272–74). When they sacrificed programs for Indian welfare, they often did so to serve the agency's primary objectives.
Rockwell acknowledges some limitations in the Indian Office. Highly decentralized authority meant that policies in a particular place could change radically if a new agent took control (pp. 113–14). Such inconsistency could reflect the short-term focus of local officials. Most decisions were made on the ground, but the Indian Office's central administration decided funding, time lines, record keeping, and reporting (pp. 194–200). The policy architecture was designed by central offices that sometimes lacked a proper understanding of local needs.
There are parts of this analysis that Rockwell could have developed further or that other scholars should develop subsequently. First, there is the counterfactual: How exactly would we know a failed Indian Office if we saw it? The author argues that contemporary critiques of the agency were not an objective measure of the agency's performance. To what, then, should we turn as precise indicators? To this end, it would be helpful to examine variation in individual agents' successes. A related puzzle is whether Rockwell's findings portray the median administrator or the cream of the crop.
In addition, the author contends that the Indian Office effectively co-opted arguments about humanitarian concerns—by arguing that Indians benefited from federal control—but the Indian Office performed inconsistently in humanitarian practices because they were a secondary priority (pp. 161–63; 296–301). He also notes that charges of incompetence and corruption were powerful attacks (pp. 205–11). If the agency legitimized a humanitarian ideal and failed to deliver on that objective, it would seem to be a serious failure on its part. We cannot ignore the historical legacy of this failure. Social control could not be separated from political and economic control. Stephen Cornell's The Return of the Native: American Indian Political Resurgence (1988) and Frederick Hoxie's Parading through History: The Making of the Crow Nation in America, 1805–1935 (1995) demonstrated that the federal government's elaborate, oppressive social policy ultimately did not destroy Indian social identity, leaving intact the social structures that provided the foundation for American Indian political resurgence.
All that said, we should not understate Rockwell's remarkable contribution. He helps readers revisit the American history that they thought they knew and he marshals surprising new findings about the might of the federal bureaucracy in Indian affairs. He shows the power of a strong and effective federal bureaucratic apparatus that began in the early nineteenth century, decades earlier than standard understandings of bureaucratic development. He illustrates how western settlement was a product of big government, not simply rugged individualism. The West was never “open”; it was cleared of its indigenous residents by powerful, talented, federal bureaucrats. You should never be able to think about bureaucratic capacity—or your favorite “pristine” and “untouched” landscapes—in the same way again.
