The Middlesex County Pauper Lunatic Asylum at Hanwell was the first to be built for the county under the provisions of the County Asylums Act of 1808. The site was near the village of Hanwell, 8 miles to the west of London.
The asylum was designed by the Quaker architect William Alderson, work began in 1829 and the asylum opened in 1831. The design was based on the panopticon principle proposed by the philosopher Jeremy Bentham. The Glasgow asylum built by William Stark on this model had a radial plan and a central observation tower; at Wakefield, Watson and Pritchett, used an H-shaped layout with two observation towers. At Hanwell, there was a double ‘dog-leg’ plan with three observation towers (Fig. 1). There were gallery wards as at at the Moorfields Bethlem Hospital of 1676, designed by Robert Hooke. Airing courts, farm buildings, offices and accommodation for staff were provided, and the asylum had an impressive gateway. Extensions to the asylum, completed by 1838, used the same system of observation, but the new wards had a central corridor with rooms on each side.
Surveyor’s drawing: ‘General Plan of the Pauper Lunatic Asylum for Middlesex’, from: Ellis WC [1838], A Treatise on the Nature, Symptoms, Causes, and Treatment of Insanity, with Practical Observations on Lunatic Asylums and a Description of the Pauper Lunatic Asylum for the County of Middlesex, at Hanwell. London, Samuel Holdsworth, used courtesy of the Wellcome Collection [public domain mark].

Sir William Ellis was the first medical superintendent, taking up his duties in 1831 when the hospital opened. In 1818, he had become the first medical superintendent of the West Riding of Yorkshire Pauper Lunatic Asylum at Wakefield, with his wife as matron. Care of patients at Wakefield was influenced by practice at the Retreat at York. He believed in the therapeutic value of occupation for patients, and this was incorporated into the regimen of care at both Wakefield and Hanwell.
Ellis was succeeded at Hanwell in 1839 by John Conolly, who had graduated from the University of Edinburgh in 1821. He was influenced by the work of Robert Gardner Hill at the Lincoln Asylum, who in 1838 had shown that it was possible to care for patients without physical restraint. Conolly developed methods of care without physical restraint at Hanwell and promoted their use elsewhere.
Both Ellis and Conolly wrote in some detail about the construction, governance and staffing of asylums. They describe the layout of the hospitals in which they worked and how the buildings were used in the care of patients. Nowhere in these writings do they describe the system of observation provided by the panopticon design of their hospitals, how it might be used in practice or their own experience of its use. This suggests that the panopticon system of observation was not being used as had been intended when it was incorporated in the design of the asylums. Indeed, Conolly strongly recommends the design of for the new Derbyshire County Pauper Lunatic Asylum at Mickleover designed by Paterson and Duesbury and opened in 1844 (later the Pastures Hospital), which was not based on the panopticon principle. An important feature of the design of the Derbyshire asylum was the provision of corridors that allowed access to any ward without passing through another. This was a distinct departure from the plan of Hanwell Asylum. Views on the requirements of mental hospital design were changing.
Hanwell asylum under its early medical superintendents provided models of liberal care that were widely followed.The asylum also marked a turning point in asylum design. The asylum (later Saint Bernard’s Hospital) underwent major changes over the following years. It holds an important place in the evolution of the design of hospitals for the mentally ill and of their care.


eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.