Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:51:31.922Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Structured input–output analysis of transitional wall-bounded flows

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 September 2021

Chang Liu*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
Dennice F. Gayme
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: changliu@jhu.edu

Abstract

Input–output analysis of transitional channel flows has proven to be a valuable analytical tool for identifying important flow structures and energetic motions. The traditional approach abstracts the nonlinear terms as forcing that is unstructured, in the sense that this forcing is not directly tied to the underlying nonlinearity in the dynamics. This paper instead employs a structured-singular-value-based approach that preserves certain input–output properties of the nonlinear forcing function in an effort to recover the larger range of key flow features identified through nonlinear analysis, experiments and direct numerical simulation (DNS) of transitional channel flows. Application of this method to transitional plane Couette and plane Poiseuille flows leads to not only the identification of the streamwise coherent structures predicted through traditional input–output approaches, but also the characterization of the oblique flow structures as those requiring the least energy to induce transition, in agreement with DNS studies, and nonlinear optimal perturbation analysis. The proposed approach also captures the recently observed oblique turbulent bands that have been linked to transition in experiments and DNS with very large channel size. The ability to identify the larger amplification of the streamwise varying structures predicted from DNS and nonlinear analysis in both flow regimes suggests that the structured approach allows one to maintain the nonlinear effects associated with weakening of the lift-up mechanism, which is known to dominate the linear operator. Capturing this key nonlinear effect enables the prediction of a wider range of known transitional flow structures within the analytical input–output modelling paradigm.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Block diagram representing the structured input–output feedback interconnection between the linearized dynamics and structured forcing modelling the nonlinearity (in the blue dashed region). In particular, each component of the forcing is modelled as an input–output mapping from the respective component of the velocity gradient $\boldsymbol {\nabla } u$, $\boldsymbol {\nabla } v$, $\boldsymbol {\nabla } w$ to the respective component forcings $f_{x,\xi }$, $f_{y,\xi }$, $f_{z,\xi }$ of the linearized dynamics with the gain $-\boldsymbol {u}_{\xi }$ defined in terms of the structured singular value of a linearized closed-loop system response.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Illustrations of flows between two parallel flat plates: (a) plane Couette flow with laminar base flow $\boldsymbol {U}(y)=y\boldsymbol {e}_x$ and (b) plane Poiseuille flow with laminar base flow $\boldsymbol {U}(y)=(1-y^2)\boldsymbol {e}_x$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Illustration of feedback interconnection associated with structured input–output analysis: (a) a componentwise description, where blocks inside of the blue dashed region represent the modelled forcing in (2.10) corresponding to the bottom block of figure 1; (b) a high-level description after discretization.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Contour plots of (a) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }(k_x,k_z)]$, (b) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$ and (c) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$ for plane Couette flow at $Re=358$. Here the blue star indicates streamwise vortices with $k_x\approx 0$, $k_z=2$; the red circle marks oblique waves with $k_x=k_z=1$ as studied by (Reddy et al.1998). The black triangle marks $\lambda _x=113$, $\lambda _z=69$ which are the observed wavelengths of the oblique turbulent band at $Re=358$ (Prigent et al.2003). The black solid line is $\lambda _z=\lambda _x\tan (32^\circ )$ representing a $32^\circ$ angle of the oblique turbulent band, and the blue dashed line represents $\lambda _z=\lambda _x\tan (20^\circ )$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Contour plots of (a) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }(k_x,k_z)]$, (b) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$ and (c) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\infty } (k_x,k_z)]$ for plane Poiseuille flow at $Re=690$. Here the blue star, $k_x\approx 0$, $k_z=2$, marks streamwise vortices; the black circle, $k_x=k_z=1$, marks oblique waves; the magenta square, $k_x=1$, $k_z\approx 0$, marks TS waves studied by Reddy et al. (1998). The black triangle, $\lambda _x=314$, $\lambda _z=248$, indicates the wavelengths of the oblique turbulent band at $Re=690$ observed in Kanazawa (2018).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Contour plots of (a) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{ux}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$, (b) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{vy}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$, (c) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{wz}\|_{\infty } (k_x,k_z)]$, (d) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } {ux}}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$, (e) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } {vy}}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$ and (f) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } {wz}}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$ for plane Couette flow at $Re=358$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Contour plots of (a) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{ux}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$, (b) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{vy}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$, (c) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{wz}\|_{\infty } (k_x,k_z)]$, (d) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } {ux}}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$, (e) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } {vy}}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$ and (f) $\text {log}_{10}[\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } {wz}}\|_{\infty }(k_x,k_z)]$ for plane Poiseuille flow at $Re=690$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.The Reynolds number dependence of $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }^M$ (black triangle); $\|\mathcal {H}\|_{\infty }^M$ (red circle); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\infty }^M$ (blue star); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }(1,1)$ (black square). (a) Plane Couette flow with red crosses marking $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }(0.19,0.58)$ and (b) plane Poiseuille flow with red crosses marking $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }(0.69,1.56)$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.The Reynolds number dependence of $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }^M$ (black triangle); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } ux}\|_{\infty }^M$ (blue star); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } vy}\|_{\infty }^M$ (magenta square); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } wz}\|_{\infty }^M$ (red circle). (a) Plane Couette flow and (b) plane Poiseuille flow.

Figure 9

Figure 10.The Reynolds number dependence of $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }^M$ (black triangle, solid line); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla }}\|_{\mu }^{sc}$ (balck triangle, dashed line); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } ux}\|_{\infty }^{sc}$ (blue star); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } vy}\|_{\infty }^{sc}$ (magenta square); $\|\mathcal {H}_{{\nabla } wz}\|_{\infty }^{sc}$ (red circle). (a) Plane Couette flow and (b) plane Poiseuille flow.