While the cover of this nicely designed book highlights “protest” in bold letters, in truth Ho-fung Hung brings new meanings to the phrase “with Chinese characteristics” in his wide-ranging study of collective action and resistance in Qing China. A comparison between traditional modes of protest in early modern China and modern protest repertoires in Europe provides the foundation for the key questions of this work. Ultimately, Hung presents the Chinese case not only as an alternative to the supposedly universal Western European model but also as an instructive example of how one might periodize histories of modern protest more generally. In addition, he makes a strong argument for appreciating early modern forms of Chinese protest as the font of a “cultural reservoir” (p. 199) from which subsequent generations of revolutionaries, student demonstrators, and local protestors have drawn inspiration.
Hung isolates three factors to serve as comparative measures in his evaluation of early modern Chinese protest versus its modern European counterpart: state capacity, commercial prosperity, and the moral legitimacy of the state. Whereas modern Europe experienced “unidirectional” growth in the first two categories, China's development with respect to state capacity and commercial prosperity during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries is better characterized as “cyclical” (p. 16). Furthermore, the privileged status of Confucian ideology in political discourse contributed to the formation of a distinctive repertoire of protest that reflected popular appraisals of the state in moral terms. A sustained comparison of different periods of protest between 1740 and 1839 shows “that while the general political-economic contexts determined whether the protestors were more likely to engage or resist the state, the perceived moral legitimacy of the state delimited how exactly the protesters would engage or resist the state” (p. 19, italics in the original).
The heart of this work is a longitudinal analysis of episodes of protest in the eighteen inner provinces of Qing China, spanning the reigns of the Qianlong, Jiaqing, and Daoguang emperors. As defined here, “protest” encompasses a broad range of activities, including submissions of petitions, market strikes, and violent resistance to state interventions; but excludes large-scale social movements, rebellions, and inter-lineage feuding. In compiling the documented instances of protest as recorded in the Veritable Records of the Qing (Qing shilu), Hung identifies three waves of protest that correspond to distinctive historical periods. The first wave, extending from 1740 to 1759, is characterized by “filial-loyal demonstrations.” In this time period, the state center was strong, commerce was thriving, and the perceived moral legitimacy of the state was high. Protestors during this period participated in what Hung labels “state-engaging” patterns of resistance that gave credence to the paternalist pretensions of the court and its offices. The second wave of protest, taking place between 1776 and 1795, was more violent in its expression and corresponded to a decline in both state capacity and moral legitimacy. During this period, the majority of protests were “state-resisting” and reflected the growth of illegitimate local power-holders such as bandit gangs and salt smugglers, particularly in the more remote areas of the inner provinces. The third wave, from 1820 to 1839, continued in the vein of violent and state-resisting protest but with a twist: protesters incorporated direct appeals to the court into their repertoire, responding to the “regeneration of the empire's moral legitimacy under the reformist rhetoric of the Jiaqing and Daoguang emperors” with a marked increase in appeals to the capital (pp. 137, 157–58). At a time when state capacity was significantly diminished, protestors directed their ire against increasingly impotent local authorities while simultaneously pleading with the court to support their claims.
Hung makes the case that we can relate these macropatterns of protest to shifts in the political economy of the Qing state. He is most persuasive in demonstrating that protestors' choice of action was conditioned by their perceptions of state capacity. The inclusion of a broad range of case studies representing the three waves of protest helps to illustrate these claims. The question of what motivated different instances of protest is somewhat thornier. Because Hung focuses primarily on the relationship between the state and its subjects—a relationship based on Confucian orthodoxy—his model does not fully accommodate contributing factors such as alternative worldviews held by the protestors themselves or the role of non-state authorities in constraining or facilitating protest events. Nevertheless, Hung's clear articulation of protest cycles in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century China demands the attention of scholars interested in specific episodes of rebellion and resistance in this period as well as scholars of Qing political economy.
