Salt brings flavour to our lives. It also serves to feed cattle. In nineteenth-century Colombia, it was additionally one of the three most important sources of fiscal revenue. Joshua Rosenthal has therefore identified a significant subject that had hitherto remained largely ignored by the literature, and for this reason alone his book is a major contribution to modern Colombian historiography.
There are other reasons as well. Rosenthal's book focuses on a single source of salt production, La Salina de Chita, a small town located in the eastern province of Boyacá. This is an entry point to the wider subject of the formation and development of the Colombian state, since the production of salt was officially kept under the control of the central government through a variety of arrangements. Through the history of salt, Rosenthal is thus able to shed light on both the nature of the state and on the relationship between national, regional and local politics.
The continuity of the state monopoly of salt through the nineteenth century in Colombia is striking. As Rosenthal observes, other Spanish American countries abandoned this colonial tax in the early republican years. In Colombia, it survived the free trade impetus of the 1850s. It also continued under the administration of the central government even during the Olimpo Radical (1863–85), a period of extreme federalism. Poverty may be the likely explanation for this survival. The salt monopoly endured because it ‘generated desperately needed revenue for the national government … From the 1820s until 1900 profits from ministry saltworks managed under the monopoly accounted for about 10 per cent of Colombia's total federal revenue’ (p. 5).
Whatever wealth it produced, the salt monopoly does not seem to have generated much development in La Salina. Some employees of the finance ministry often said that it was an ‘empty town’, filled with migrants and dealers in contraband. Rosenthal, however, offers some population figures that challenge those views: 900 people lived there in 1816, 1150 in 1851 and 1250 in 1905. Thus it hardly grew over the years, in spite of the expansion of salt production, a fact that perhaps leads Rosenthal to note, a trifle oddly, that La Salina's population was ‘not stagnant but rather stable in a kind of dynamic equilibrium’ (pp. 30–1). Some indicators, like the number of taxed residents, would suggest that there was some relative wealth in La Salina during the 1820s and 1830s, but any such signs disappeared during the second half of the nineteenth century when La Salina became one of the poorest towns in Boyacá.
There was little farming or cattle raising in La Salina. The town depended solely on salt, and the forest in the surrounding lands provided the timber needed for its production. Together with the salt monopoly came the state, whose presence was notable in the very buildings of the factories, the personnel working for the various administrators whom the ministry contracted in various ways, and the guards employed to protect the premises: their numbers varied, but after the 1860s there were never fewer than 20. The state also became involved in purchasing the surrounding forest, so that by the end of the century it had ‘emerged as the town's major landowner’ (p. 61).
The political economy of La Salina was far from simple. If during the early republic, in the 1820s, its administrator was a local landowner and one of its wealthiest residents, the saltworks were later often managed by outsiders, mostly from Tunja or Bogotá. There were also a couple of foreigners, including José Dovieski, a Polish national who, after being arrested for his involvement in the Melista rebellion of 1854, appeared as a contractor of La Salina leading a rebellion against the national government in an extraordinary episode, only to disappear from the historical records. Lack of local knowledge was a source of friction with the community. It is not easy to follow the political loyalties of the local population, but after the 1860s the monopoly was in the hands of prominent liberal politicians, and it remained so during the Regeneración – a remarkable and interesting continuity that Rosenthal manages to identify. He also does a good job at examining the recurrent involvement of La Salina in some of the civil wars that the country suffered during the nineteenth century.
The merits of the book by far outnumber its shortcomings. Readers might have welcomed a good description of how salt was produced at the very beginning of the story, but this is not done until chapter 3. ‘A community of sorts endured’ in La Salina, Rosenthal notes, but it is difficult to tell what sort of community this town was – somewhat inevitably, given the paucity of sources. Some of the protagonists needed to be introduced better. Following a commonplace of the historiography, the author ties the politics of salt to civil wars, neglecting the connections between the salt monopoly and elections, perhaps more crucial and revealing given the intensity and regularity of the electoral calendar. When the author refers to the 1833 constitution, he surely means that of 1832; and the 1863 Constitution was not that of the Granadine confederation. Above all, this reader remains unpersuaded by the argument that La Salina was in the end a ‘modest success’, success here being measured by the mere fact that salt production grew over the years. Given the miserable living conditions of the town after a century of state control over the industry, a proper critical assessment of the salt monopoly is missing.
La Salina de Chita was one of several sources of salt production in the country, and Rosenthal often makes relevant references to other mines elsewhere, like Zipaquirá and Galerazamba. There is a need for a national history of salt in Colombia; as this book amply demonstrates, it is an excellent way to learn about state formation, politics and development during the nineteenth century.
