These two volumes are published in the Greenwood series of introductory texts addressing issues of science and religion. The series, edited by Richard Olson, is strongly historical in orientation and is intended to provide the student with a historical overview of each topic. Rather surprisingly, the titles of both volumes seem inappropriate, and in ways that mirror one another. As Efron states explicitly in his introduction, his book ‘is not properly a history of Judaism at all [but] … an account of Jews, in different times and places, and how they made sense of nature’ (p. 9; original emphases). Although there might be some justification for talking about Judaism in earlier periods, Efron's caveat is particularly relevant to his penultimate chapter, which addresses the roles and activities of Jewish scientists in twentieth-century America and Israel.
By contrast, Iqbal claims that he has not written a ‘history of Islamic scientific tradition but [a history of] the relationship between Islam and science’ (p. 40), whereas the volume's title is Science and Islam. More specifically, he is concerned to establish the existence of what he calls ‘Islamic science’ against those who have claimed that Islam is opposed to science. The emphasis throughout is on Islam as a religious world view and how science can and should be fitted into that outlook. His narrative is coloured by this strong commitment and he is highly critical of those who conceive the relationship differently. For example, he is very dismissive of the academic and journalist Ziauddin Sardar, who has tried to understand the Muslim engagement with modern science from a social and political standpoint and who does not see Islam as unchanging and standing outside history but as adapting to different sociohistorical contexts.
Both the strengths and the weaknesses of Iqbal's book stem from his central thesis. A substantial part of the book is devoted to the period spanning the eighth to sixteenth centuries with informative discussions especially on the Islamic astronomical tradition, the different philosophical responses to Aristotelian natural philosophy, and the role of observatories. I would have welcomed more on these and related issues, and especially a more detailed analysis of how the underlying principles of Islam influenced the scientific practices of the period. Unfortunately for the reader wanting to grasp the main issues in the development of science by Islamic thinkers, there are a number of extensive digressions where Iqbal challenges those historians who, he claims, have misunderstood the nature of Islamic science. I was particularly disappointed by the combative tone of his disagreements with Ignac Goldziher who, writing a century ago, did more than any other contemporary Western scholar to try to understand the complexities of Islamic thought.
A chapter is also devoted to the decline of Islamic science. Here Iqbal disagrees with those who see the decline as dating from earlier centuries and pushes the date to the seventeenth century, but offers little supporting evidence. While some of the problems with the various contending theses for this decline are identified, Iqbal offers no thesis of his own, instead pointing out that a great deal of historical work has yet to be done. This is not very illuminating for the student reader who may have little interest in the historiographical debates but would have appreciated a few substantial pointers.
The book generates an interesting discussion between Sayyid Ahmad Khan, the late nineteenth-century champion of Western science, and Jamal al-Din al-Afghani, who was highly critical of the importation by the colonial powers of science and its attendant materialism into Islamic societies. During the second half of the twentieth century and the wane of colonialism, the problems of science and technology have become, as Iqbal rightly sees, increasingly pressing in the Muslim world. While some champion Western science, he locates himself firmly among the ranks of those scholars (including René Guénon and Seyyed Hossein Nasr) who are critical of this alien import and instead are seeking to revive the earlier tradition of Islamic science so that they can selectively engage Western science while remaining firmly wedded to an unchanging Islam. This message will excite some readers but not others.
By comparison with Iqbal's frequent admonitions, Efron criticizes very few commentators. Nevertheless, he cautions against the claim that Jews possess an integral ability to do science as a result of imbibing the traditional method of Talmudic dialectic. Instead he insists that Jewish participation in science should be understood in terms of local historical context, and that (outside the case of modern Israel) this context includes the relationship between Jews and the wider non-Jewish community. Thus he sees no justification for constructing an ahistorical notion of ‘Jewish science’ but rather analyses in historical-contextual terms the opportunities open to Jews to enter science and their attraction to particular sciences.
This is a student-friendly volume which begins with a discussion of how the Torah and the early rabbinical commentators portrayed the Creation and how nature can be studied. Efron argues that no one view of nature emerged from this process; rather, the Talmud contains a plurality of views. For Efron the significance of this plurality for their long-term development of science is that these foundational texts do not require Jews to accept any specific view of nature, but leave them free to explore alternative understandings. This is an interesting and important claim but one that should not be overstated; the example of medieval Jewish philosophy discussed in a later chapter shows a diversity of responses to Aristotelian natural philosophy but within the scope of contemporary readings of Torah.
Efron discusses the flowering of science and medicine among Jews in specific contexts, including the creative interchanges with Muslims and Christians in medieval Spain. Likewise early seventeenth-century Prague and Padua provide insightful case studies, as does the Haskalah (Enlightenment) of the eighteenth century. I would have welcomed a longer chapter on the nineteenth century. By contrast, the twentieth century is discussed at greater length, with informative sections on the importance of science and technology in the modern state of Israel and the prominence of Jews in American science: ‘Save Vaudeville and then Hollywood, American Jews were nowhere more prominent than in science’ (p. 178). As noted above, in these later chapters Efron moves further away from Judaism per se and concentrates on the place of Jews in science and medicine and its relation to modern Jewish social history. This is perhaps inevitable, especially as many of the scientists he discusses abandoned the religious Orthodoxy of their parents. Yet it would also have been helpful to mention such present-day organizations as the Association of Orthodox Jewish Scientists and the Torah Science Foundation, where the relationship between science and Orthodoxy is still under intense discussion.
Both volumes follow the editorial convention of concluding with the texts of several important primary sources. Apart from this similarity, the authors interpret their assignments very differently. While these differences tell us a lot about the two authors, it is difficult for the reader to draw any historical comparisons and contrasts between these two important religious traditions.
