The focus of this collection of essays is on how music was taught and learned in the Western European art tradition between the Middle Ages until approximately 1650. Five key questions are posed: ‘What were the pedagogical methods used by various teachers?’; ‘What did the student learn?’; ‘Who were the teachers, and who were the learners?’; ‘When and where was music learned?’; and ‘Why was music learned?’. In other words the basic concerns are method, repertory, identity, place and rationale. These concerns permeate the five parts of the book: Medieval Pedagogy, Renaissance Places of Learning, Renaissance Materials and Contexts, Music Education in the Convent, The Teacher. Each part comprises several chapters, and additionally there are three essays of a broader nature referred to as ‘perspectives’.
James Harr introduces the reader to Medieval Musical Pedagogy in the first of the ‘perspective’ chapters. He notes that training in instrumental performance (especially keyboards and the lute for aristocratic amateurs) was mostly an individual practice, often a father–son relationship. However, a much large number of children learned to sing, and generally this preceded learning to read. It is here that the Guidonian Hand, named after Guido d'Arezzo, makes its entrance. It was essentially a visual aid for learning the Gamut by associating a syllabic note name with each of the joints of the thumb and fingers. As Susan Forscher Weiss explains, ‘The inscribed palm . . . of the left hand was an aid in learning that emphasized sight, sound, and memory’ (p. 207).
The thinking of d'Arezzo is explored in a subsequent chapter by Dolores Pesce, who examines what Guido actually said about solmisation syllables in his writings.
But as Susan Boynton points out in ‘Medieval Musical Education as Seen through Sources Outside the Realm of Music Theory’, whilst treatises upon musical theory can tell us much about the character of musical learning, they do not provide much insight into the social and institutional setting of musical training. For this, the most important sources include monastic customaries. These provide detailed descriptions of teaching methods and show that the musical education of child oblates consisted of learning appropriate behaviour by imitating the older monks. The divine office, which occupied most of the day, afforded the opportunity not only to learn to sing and to read, but also how to hold themselves, as well as how to bow and to process. Performing the liturgy formed the core of monastic education.
In consideration of Renaissance Places of Learning, Gordon Munro's investigation of music education in Scotland is of particular interest. He traces the results of one of the first acts of Parliament in the reign of James VI in 1579, which initiated a process of reform to reverse the musical deterioration which was apparent as a consequence of the Scottish Reformation. By 1633 Munro estimates at least 25 song schools (or music schools) had been opened. Fascinating details are supplied about these schools. In Old Aberdeen, which may have been typical, the ‘three Rs’ (reading, writing and arithmetic) were taught in the downstairs room of the school; the upper room was reserved for those learning vocal and instrumental music. Generally the school day lasted eight or nine hours, and the metrical versions of psalms and spiritual songs formed an important part of the curriculum. Simple four-part psalm and canticle harmonisations were circulated, and in the larger song schools polyphonic music would have been taught. Teachers could charge their pupils quarterly fees (‘schollage’), in addition to receiving a teaching salary, and an intriguing table itemises the payments for such activities as ‘singing’, ‘discanting’ and ‘instrumental music’. By the middle of the seventeenth century, music school masters were evidently well-paid and highly regarded.
In contrast to the Scottish example is Kristine Forney's focus on the musical education of middle-class women in Antwerp. In addition to a religious education through music, the young women of merchant families were expected to have social skills in singing and playing instruments. Such women were apparently musically literate, capable of making arrangements, performing divisions and improvising.
Part three of the book introduces readers to the materials that are available for historians to work with, including commonplace books, conduct and courtesy books, treatises and the handwritten marginalia in early printed books. More specifically Pamela Starr identified 45 manuals of conduct and instruction of young men and women between 1500 and 1700, which commented on music and music teaching. She notes, ‘instead of an expected uniformity of view, I found a delightful farrago of opinion and rationale, both pro and con, which revealed a multivalent and inclusive reception of music in the lives of both children and adults’ (p.195). Nineteen extracts from the courtesy books are presented, which enable readers to enter the musical and educational world of the Early Modern era in England.
Some of the most significant contexts for musical instruction were convents. We find some detailed description of the musical and educational life of these institutions in Colleen Baade's chapter ‘Nun Musicians as Teachers and Students in Early Modern Spain’. We learn that basic instruction in chant formed part of the musical education of novices, and some underwent two half-hour singing lessons per day. A small number of new entrants were given what were called ‘dowry waivers’ on the basis of their musical ability, and in exchange for their services as musicians. The most prestigious monasteries demanded a high level of musical ability for such girls, who were often subjected to formal examinations on harp, violin and organ. In contrast to this general picture is Cynthia Cyrus's case study of a Salzburg Abbey in which she focuses upon the impact of post-Tridentine educational reforms on women's convents. These reforms prompted a shift from an aural environment to a literate one, and from an emphasis on traditional and localised plainchant to instrumental music and polyphony. Cyrus uncovers a story of resistance and a later adaptation of the reforms on the part of the nuns.
The book concludes with a consideration of The Teacher. As Russell Murray points out ‘The act of teaching is an ephemeral one . . . The challenge of recovering such an act from the past is thus a formidable one’ (p. 303). Insights can be gained through examining Renaissance dialogues and treatises which can tell us many things about musical learning, context and location. Murray looks in detail at the work of Ludovico Zacconi (1555–1627), and specifically on his manner of teaching counterpoint as outlined in the second part of his Prattica di musica. What Zacconi exemplifies is an active and pragmatic approach to teaching, keen to encourage his students to experiment. Murray concludes that ‘Through his writings, Zacconi creates a window through which we can infer some of the pedagogical practices of the masters of this era’ (p. 321). Two further chapters relating to teachers and teaching include Blake Wilson's study of pedagogy and literacy in Florence c. 1488, and Gary Towne's analysis of Pietro Cerone's El melopeo y maestro (The composer and the teacher), an influential text throughout Spanish dominions for nearly two centuries.
The editors of Music Education in the Middle Ages and the Renaissance regard their project as ‘the beginning of a discussion that we hope will inform investigations of the past for decades to come’ (p. xviii). They point out that although a number of musicologists have addressed issues of education in the context of larger studies of this period, there has been no comprehensive scholarly source on the subject of musical pedagogy, apart from, in the context of a much broader sweep, the work of Bernarr Rainbow in his Music in Educational Thought and Practice (Reference RAINBOW and Cox2006) and Four Centuries of Music Teaching Manuals, 1518–1932 (Reference RAINBOW2009). What is distinctive and welcome about this book is its musicological focus on pedagogy, music education, and the history of education which serves to expand the horizons of our field of study. As far as relating to the contemporary concerns of music educators, the book provides a salutary reminder that ‘Education had (and still has) a way of being old and new together’ (Orme, Reference ORME2007, p. 343).
