No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2005
During the early 1990s, Argentina's Peronist Party accomplished a political magic trick: under the leadership of President Carlos Menem, Peronism turned away from its traditional commitment to social justice and an activist state, embraced the free market and neoliberal reform, and yet maintained the electoral support of the majority of the poor. For many Argentine intellectuals, this trick was easy enough to explain. According to the conventional wisdom, poor people remained loyal to Peronism, despite their rapidly declining standard of living, either because they remained under the hypnotic spell of Juan and Evita or because they were bought off by clientelist politicians offering handouts. Javier Auyero's ethnography of Peronist politics in an impoverished shantytown on the outskirts of Buenos Aires challenges these simplistic explanations. This timely and important book reconceptualizes political clientelism, a crucial phenomenon within scholarship on Latin America and beyond, while making visible and intelligible a population that has been relegated to marginality both by socioeconomic realities and by academic discourse.
During the early 1990s, Argentina's Peronist Party accomplished a political magic trick: under the leadership of President Carlos Menem, Peronism turned away from its traditional commitment to social justice and an activist state, embraced the free market and neoliberal reform, and yet maintained the electoral support of the majority of the poor. For many Argentine intellectuals, this trick was easy enough to explain. According to the conventional wisdom, poor people remained loyal to Peronism, despite their rapidly declining standard of living, either because they remained under the hypnotic spell of Juan and Evita or because they were bought off by clientelist politicians offering handouts. Javier Auyero's ethnography of Peronist politics in an impoverished shantytown on the outskirts of Buenos Aires challenges these simplistic explanations. This timely and important book reconceptualizes political clientelism, a crucial phenomenon within scholarship on Latin America and beyond, while making visible and intelligible a population that has been relegated to marginality both by socioeconomic realities and by academic discourse.
Auyero's central criticism of the voluminous literature on clientelism is that by describing the phenomenon as a simple exchange of favors for votes, it neglects the larger relationships and cultural meanings within which these transactions occur. As Auyero puts it, “[t]his point of view assumes—wrongly—that ( . . . ) votes and support come because of goods, services, and particular favors” (23). Instead of assuming any particular causal mechanism, his account explores the way the residents of Villa Paraíso (not its real name) experience and understand clientelist practices. These practices, he argues, ought to be thought of as “personalized political mediation,” a technique through which many shantytown residents solve their everyday survival needs. The most valuable contribution of Poor People's Politics is its detailed description of these practices. Quoting extensively from interviews with brokers, clients and other residents, Auyero provides a fine-grained account of the day-to-day experience of politics in the shantytown.
The book's first two chapters contextualize Auyero's ethnography by recounting Argentina's recent economic history and by providing a brief history of the particular shantytown under study. Beginning in the 1970s but particularly during the neoliberal heyday of the 1990s, Argentina experienced a rapid process of deindustrialization, accompanied by sharply increasing levels of unemployment, poverty and inequality. These trends have had a catastrophic impact on places like Villa Paraíso. Built in the 1930s as a temporary home for migrant workers seeking jobs in Buenos Aires's expanding manufacturing sector, the neighborhood has a long history of collective action and political mobilization. But the brutality of the military dictatorship of 1976–83, the steady erosion of employment during the 1980s and 1990s, and the implementation of draconian neoliberalism has resulted in deproletarianization and the dismantling of neighborhood organizations. Residents who once participated in collective movements to improve their community now struggle merely to survive.
In this context, many residents of Villa Paraíso solve their everyday problems through one of the only effective means available to them: the local Peronist patronage networks. Auyero provides a careful structural analysis of these networks, through which goods and favors circulate from the Governor of Buenos Aries Province and the Mayor of the municipality down through Peronist brokers to groups of residents in Villa Paraíso. Thanks to their privileged access to the state, brokers control resources, such as medicine or construction materials, and information, such as the date and time of the municipality's monthly distribution of free food. In exchange for these favors, “clients” are expected to attend Peronist rallies. The number of people a broker can mobilize for such events determines the extent of his or her access to resources. Each broker has an “inner circle” of followers who participate actively in the broker's day-to-day operations and who have received or hope to receive a public sector job in return for their loyalty. Interestingly, Auyero reveals that several of the most powerful Peronist brokers are women, whose success derives in large part from their ability to “perform Evita.” From their bleached blonde hair to their pose as the mothers of the poor, they deliberately evoke memories of the beloved Eva Perón. In so doing, these brokers personalize the goods they distribute and legitimize their own role in the process, even as they reinforce a gendered politics, in which policy-making remains a male domain, while administering assistance to the poor is essentially feminine.
Auyero pays close attention to the discourses mobilized by Peronist brokers as well as to the reception of those discourses by residents. The brokers depict their own actions as motivated not by self interest but by a passion to help the needy, and they strive both rhetorically and in practice to erase the social distance between them and the poor. Perhaps unsurprisingly, Auyero finds that the brokers' inner circles accept these representations, while those who benefit less from the Peronist networks are more critical. A broker's loyal followers typically consider her to be individually responsible for every good that has come to their family or to the shantytown as a whole. Moreover, their memory of Peronism's golden age emphasizes the “distributional” account favored by the brokers, rather than what Auyero, following historian Daniel James, describes as the “heretical” meaning of Peronism. In other words, brokers and their most privileged clients locate the central meaning of Peronism in the distribution of goods to the poor, not in the commitment to social justice and the assault on the oligarchy. Their memories of the Peronist past are thus shaped by their experience of Peronism in the present.
Auyero's arguments, while always provocative, are occasionally less than satisfying. One problem is that he focuses a great deal of his analysis on the small “inner circles,” at the expense of the bulk of the shantytown population. He convincingly dissects the complex relationship and shared cultural perspective that tie these loyal clients to their individual brokers. Yet he argues that the electoral effectiveness of clientelism is exaggerated, since the large majority of the population remains outside the hegemonic grasp of Peronist brokers. But what about this majority? One wonders if some residents are able to engage with clientelism opportunistically, without swallowing its political messages. Auyero emphasizes the way the present shapes people's memories of the past, but he tends to downplay the influence of the past on the present. If people who benefit from Peronist patronage remember Peronism as “distributional,” might it not also be the case that a more “heretical” memory of Peronism enables others to see through the manipulations of Peronist brokers? Auyero's story is, in a sense, about the declining significance of class as a marker of identity for the urban poor. While that story is no doubt shaped by deproletarianization and the neoliberal assault on unions, it must also be the product of a longer history. By deemphasizing that historical process, Auyero presents the death of “heretical” Peronism and the unmaking of the Argentine working class as more definitive than they might actually be.
Despite these shortcomings, Auyero's book represents a major contribution to the study of clientelism and politics among the poor in Latin America as well as a much-needed guide to contemporary Peronism. The severe economic and political crisis that has beset Argentina since the publication of Poor People's Politics makes its subject even more urgent. Both the meaning of Peronism and the future of democracy itself are very much up for grabs right now, and yet most observers have described the crisis as primarily a middle-class affair. This book should awaken scholars to the political relevance of the shantytowns.