Daphna Ephrat's Spiritual Wayfarers, Leaders in Piety: Sufis and the Dissemination of Islam in Medieval Palestine is one of the more recent additions to a growing body of literature on the nexus of Sufism and society. Ephrat's study shares with the rest of this literature the twofold purpose of examining a specific moment and place where Sufism thrived and using these examinations to address wider issues in the history of Sufism. As general conclusions about the existence and definitions of developmental stages in Sufism change over time, these studies face a challenging task. Ephrat's ambitious book is no exception.
Ephrat's work focuses on Sufism in medieval Palestine, which in the author's definition extends from the mid-7th to the late 15th centuries and encompasses a number of significant cities, including Jerusalem, Hebron, Ascalon, Tyre, and Ramla. These places, as she points out, witnessed dramatic and frequent changes in political rule and, in some cases, were home to pious tombs and other religious structures. The book has two specific aims: to present a comprehensive picture of Sufism in Palestine and to trace its evolution from a group of marginalized spiritual wayfarers to the “prominent religiously based and led associations” (p. 191) found in the public spheres of the Islamic world between 1000 and 1500. This topic is especially fascinating because it brings together such important issues as the response to the Crusader conquests, the process of Islamization, and the special role of Palestine as a center of pious sites. The author's main choice of source material, Sufi and non-Sufi biographical and hagiographical works, provides rich information on the ascetics, mystics, and holy figures collectively labeled as Sufis. Ephrat raises many interesting questions about these texts and demonstrates her formidable knowledge of their content. In addition, her past work on 11th-century Baghdad provides an important background to the changing role of religious elites in medieval Palestine. Drawing on building inscriptions and Mujir al-Din's history of Jerusalem and Hebron (1521), Ephrat also includes important information on pious buildings in medieval Palestine.
Ephrat divides her book into three chapters that correspond to crucial stages of development in the formation of Sufism in Palestine. Beginning with a discussion of the changing role of the spiritual wayfarer and ascetic ideas from the Arab-Muslim conquests to the late 10th century, the author paints a picture of some of the changes in the terms associated with asceticism and piety throughout the period. As in every section of her text, she buttresses her argument with selected works about Sufism from other places and time periods. Having demonstrated the incorporation of ascetic ideals into society, Ephrat goes on in the second chapter to describe the integration of Sufis into the scholarly world of the ʿulamaʾ in the earlier Islamic period (the late 10th to mid-13th centuries). Her final chapter, covering the period from the mid-13th to the late 15th centuries, looks at the expansion of “a Sufi-inspired community” (p. 6) or people of the path.
Chapter 1 describes a first stage in the development of an “ethical mystical movement known as Sufism” (p. 35). Through a discussion of the pious figures who were attracted to Palestine because of its religious sites and its relation to other important pilgrimage centers, Ephrat describes their evolution from role models and wayfaring elites to the beginning of their formation of a Sufi circle. She supports this conclusion by citing changes in the terminology used in biographical entries. Some of the figures she examines, such as Ibn al-Jallaʾ, became more prominent in the periods following their deaths and were described differently in varying sources. Because Ephrat's choice of sources encompass a large time span, this variance is not surprising. However, a brief discussion of how Ephrat approached the disjunction between some of her sources would have been helpful.
In Chapter 2, having established the genesis of Sufism as a movement, Ephrat explores how this movement gained strength and prominence. Her main argument begins with the premise that there was a chasm between legists and mystics. During the course of this second period of integration, bridges were built across this chasm through the growing orthodoxy of mystic figures. As these mystics became more orthodox, the legalists became more influenced by mystical thought. As in the previous chapter, Ephrat touches on many important issues surrounding legal schools and the authors of biographical dictionaries, including rich information on the role of mystics as hadith transmitters. Much of her discussion of these issues links her material to larger trends in Sufi studies.
The final of the three chapters, aptly named “Expansion,” continues to chart how Sufism was disseminated in the greater society. It draws on the work of Meri and Taylor to argue that charismatic figures were incorporated into the community. In addition, Ephrat describes and analyzes the large-scale building activity of the period. The sheer number of religious structures built in Jerusalem alone is impressive and makes one wish that Ephrat had spent less time bringing in tangential and problematic arguments about terminology and more time on the buildings’ individual characters, especially after her series of very useful charts delineating building activity.
This highly ambitious book provides valuable information on a fascinating place and time. The author's use and knowledge of biographical works and her analysis of the role of mystics in hadith transmission make her book an important addition to studies of Sufi leaders. In addition, she has presented information on various Sufi establishments in a clear and accessible manner. Although Ephrat points out that her book was meant to incorporate two analytical frames, one that deals with Sufism in Palestine and another that addresses broader Sufi developments, she rarely used her material to question some of the more general conclusions on how Sufism developed. If she had drawn comparisons between her material and sources on mystics in other parts of the Arab world (especially in Mamluk and Ayyubid Egypt) instead, her book could have told us considerably more about whether there were such distinct stages in Sufism and how they related to political and social developments.
