Today, John D. Rockefeller's Standard Oil Company registers as both a relic of the robber baron past and a precursor to our current economic order. On the one hand, Standard Oil was an exceptional corporation, so powerful in its monopolistic practices that the Supreme Court forced the trust to break apart in 1911. On the other hand, Standard Oil can be viewed as the model for and precursor of contemporary multinational corporations, for whom integration and its contemporary correlatives like “synergy” remain values. Even after the Supreme Court's 1911 ruling against Standard Oil, the Rockefellers remained one of the wealthiest families in the United States. As Mary Brown Bullock notes, John D. Rockefeller “continued to hold a significant percentage of Standard Oil equities; by 1913, his net worth was $900 million, an all-time high. The U.S. national budget that year was less – only $715 million” (15).
In The Oil Prince's Legacy, Mary Brown Bullock documents how the Rockefeller family used some of their family fortune to establish a number of philanthropic institutions focussed on China. Detailing the activities of the Asia Society, the Asian Cultural Council, the China Medical Board, the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, and the Rockefeller Foundation, Bullock persuasively argues that the Rockefeller family's interest in China emerges from nineteenth-century missionary work but morphs into internationalist exchange. A member of both the China Medical Board and the Asia Society, Bullock has grounded her book in archival research and interviews with faculty and graduates of the Rockefeller-funded Peking Union Medical College. The book's documentation of Rockefeller philanthropy in China from 1863 to the present benefits greatly from her access to the Rockefeller archives as well as to people who were directly involved in their philanthropic projects.
The Oil Prince's Legacy is organized chronologically, beginning with John D. Rockefeller's first sale of kerosene to China in 1863, when he would make also his first donation to missionary work in China. In the next decades, Rockefeller would focus his philanthropy on education: “Through funding such institutions as Spelman College and the University of Chicago, he exemplified his lifelong conviction that educational institutions should be problem-solving institutions, enabling individuals of all ranks and ethnicities to work and spread American values” (13). Initially inspired to give by the YMCA, Rockefeller increasingly supported scientific medicine in his later life. This interest in medicine was further pursued by John D. Rockefeller Jr., who oversaw the founding of the Peking Union Medical College, designed to be “a Johns Hopkins for China” (28). The book's central chapters detail the establishment of this elite medical college, along with the Rockefeller's support of “scores of different institutions in China, a multiple-campus American university without walls” (72). World War II and the founding of the People's Republic of China complicated and eventually severed control over these projects, but by the late 1960s Rockefeller institutions were beginning to seek inroads back into China. The book concludes with an account of how the philanthropic projects of Rockefeller institutions have changed, now that China is no longer viewed through the missionary lens as a nation in need of both religious salvation and exposure to modern science, but instead approached as a “global partner in addressing health, environmental, and poverty issues” (200).
Shifting away from an analysis of Rockefeller philanthropy as cultural imperialism or a mere adjunct to Standard Oil's economic interests, Bullock adopts Akira Iriye's concept of “cultural internationalism” to describe Rockefeller philanthropy in China. She argues that this framework allows her to view Rockefeller institutions through “a more neutral lens,” one that “centers on non-state actors that influence the character of foreign relations as much as or sometimes more than traditional state relations” (3). Acknowledging the ways in which Rockefeller philanthropy nonetheless participated in cultural imperialism, especially in its earliest support of missionary projects, Bullock uses the lens of cultural internationalism to frame the Rockefellers' support of medical science, and especially the founding of Peking Union Medical College, in terms of the value and promise of universal, scientific knowledge.
By viewing all of Rockefeller philanthropy as a form of cultural internationalism, Bullock is able to account for the ways in which Rockefeller institutions' involvement in China functioned outside practical, economic interests or US foreign policy. However, by including nineteenth-century missionary work, the founding of an elite medical school, and controversial, contemporary projects focussed on agriculture and population control under the banner of “cultural internationalism,” the term begins to lose any clear historical, social, or political meaning. The Oil Prince's Legacy makes a convincing argument for the centrality of the Rockefeller family and their philanthropic institutions to US–China relations, medical science, and higher education in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries.
