These two books belong to an expanding body of scholarship, which over the last decade or so has started to alter dramatically the way we understand Early Rome. Thanks to new excavations and recent archival research, there is a significantly greater quantity of evidence than ever before for the period's reconstruction. What is more, these books suggest a shift that is not only quantitative but potentially qualitative, as the density of data starts to open up paths beyond the intense polemics concerned with the reliability of Rome's foundation legends. Indeed, these books largely avoid explicitly engaging with ancient sources and seek to describe Rome's early development starting from the material evidence. The first, La Roma dei Re, is a catalogue made to accompany a show held in autumn 2018 at the Musei Capitolini, organised by Claudio Parisi Pressice and Isabella Damiani. In the best tradition of Italian museum catalogues, the work contains substantial scholarly merit, while it is also substantial simply as a physical object. The hefty, large-format book reaches 509 pages with colour images of hundreds of objects, often from multiple angles, along with texts by 36 contributors. The volume is also pleasantly faithful to its title: every bit a ‘collection of the archaeology’, it is intent on gathering together and displaying old and new data for the reconstruction of Early Rome, focusing on material from the tenth to the sixth centuries b.c.e., and occasionally running beyond those boundaries in both directions. Parisi Presicce and Damiani's introduction relates the exhibition to previous shows on Early Rome: Enea nel Lazio (1981), La grande Roma dei Tarquini (1990) or Roma. Romolo, Remo e la fondazione della città (2001). While these were framed around one or another legendary protagonist, the present authors offer a more material-based account of the city's development through the same periods. Further introductions to the early city's topography (Parisi Presicce) and its exchange networks (Damiani) are accompanied by a brief but excellent essay by Carmine Ampolo emphasising how the great obscurity of Early Rome, already noted in antiquity, is often too little acknowledged by modern scholars, and that proper reconstructions of the period must restore the early city not only from archaeological overburden but from dense accretions of modern speculation.
The catalogue's eight sections follow different themes. The first and longest focuses on ritual, starting with detailed review of Rome's earliest votive deposits, then moving to the Archaic sanctuary at Sant’ Omobono with excellent illustrations and discussion of its architectural terracottas. Patrizia Fortini treats us to a glimpse of her unpublished work on the area of the comitium. Then we turn to the Sapienza University of Rome's excavations on the north-east slopes of the Palatine. Directed by Clementina Panella, the project has proved one of the most fruitful excavations in the city centre in several decades, if not since the work of Giacomo Boni. Recent years have seen the project reach the lowermost and earliest stratigraphy, which continues to yield fascinating finds, such as a human skull possibly displayed as a trophy in the sanctuary of the curiae veteres. The section closes with votive deposits from the Viminal and Capitoline and a glance at the Archaic city's drainage systems and wells. The short second section examines funerary ritual, pairing old excavations with newer discoveries from the Capitoline and north-east Palatine. Section three, on settlement evidence, includes the first detailed publication of a series of Early Iron Age huts found by Panella's team on the north-east Palatine. These sensational discoveries extend knowledge of the Early Iron Age Palatine from the long-known settlement on the hill's south-west edge to its opposite corner. We should be cautious in assuming continuous inhabitation in between, however, as Ampolo's introduction justly invokes the idea of the ‘leopard spot’ city (a macchia di leopardo) employed by Medieval archaeologists to describe the patchwork inhabitation of post-Imperial Rome.
The fourth section is a lengthy treatment of exchange and commerce. Three sherds of Italo-Mycenaean pottery from the Capitoline are confirmed petrochemically to be of local, perhaps even Roman, manufacture. Moving forward in time, we find comprehensive presentation of imported Greek and Greek-styled material from Sant’ Omobono and the Esquiline necropolis. Rome appears to have received such material starting from around the time of the establishment of the first Greek colony at Pithecusae, a link reinforced through side-by-side presentation of material from Pithecusae and from the Orientalising-period Esquiline Burial Group 125, using Giovanni Pinza's designation ‘group’ rather than tomb in reference to material archaeologically related but not necessarily from the same burial. Two graffiti from Group 125, one a Greek name Kleikou on a Protocorinthian olpe, the other possibly an Etruscan name ]uvis, further confirm a situation of elite mobility. Sections five and six look at how Iron Age grave goods indicated gender and social rank. Interesting material includes the first publication of a Bronze Age sword-blade found in the Tiber. The latest burial discussed, an early fifth-century tomb from Largo Magnanapoli on the Quirinal, includes a fragment of a cranium with traces of gold leaf, perhaps from a diadem, and an alabastron, items that seem to echo rituals regulated by the XII Tables a generation or two later. Section seven displays some valiant attempts to sort through the sparsely documented nineteenth-century excavation of the Esquiline necropolis; the final section discusses the original display of such material in the Palazzo dei Conservatori.
If the volume's mass makes it appear comprehensive, attentive readers will note the absence of reference to Andrea Carandini's excavations on the slopes of the Palatine. Of great relevance to the archaeology of Early Rome, the results of that work rapidly became the subject of fierce debate over their relationship to mythological stories of Romulus or the Tarquins. Their absence here reflects the book's desire to avoid such topics, and discussion often breaks off right at the point of interpretative engagement. When Damiani notes the rise of the Esquiline necropolis in Latial Period IIB, just as activity in the Forum burial grounds ceases, she states that this shift speaks to changes in the scale and nature of the Roman settlement, but gives no opinion on the more precise nature of such changes (244), and similar cautiousness appears throughout.
While the catalogue thus follows more empirical than analytical goals, Gabriele Cifani's study of The Origins of the Roman Economy aims instead at synthesis, drawing together some of the same material (and much else besides) to produce an impressively rich account of Early Rome's economic development from the Early Bronze Age to the Middle Republic. Cifani starts by following modern thought on the subject back to the Renaissance Humanists and Enlightenment thinkers who, he suggests, painted an influential picture of the early settlement's economy as subsistence-based and primitive. He seeks to overturn this position by showing Rome's early role in Mediterranean exchange networks. He also advances the argument that Rome was from an early point the dominant city-state in its region: already by Latial Period IIB, the settlement of Rome was ‘certainly the most important of Latium and … already one of the largest in all of central Italy’ (51). The major urbanisation process evident at Rome in the Archaic period in Cifani's view largely capitalises on existing exchange networks and opportunities for wealth that had by that point long supported the settlement's elite. This maximalist vision underpins a detailed description of material relevant to economic production, consumption and exchange over the course of eighteen chapters. Most of the chapters follow a chronological organisation, while some pursue single themes. These thematic chapters deserve a wide audience for their application of critical historical questions to this early material. Cifani treats the ecological situation of the early settlement; the demography and carrying capacity of Latium; and institutional topics such as standards of value, the economic organisation of space or the fiscal status of the early Roman community. Excellent discussion traces epigraphic evidence for Latins across the wider Archaic Mediterranean. Another fascinating chapter teases out a history of Roman production from the early calendar.
As with the other book under review here, Cifani's monograph showcases copious archaeological evidence now at our disposal for the period. The book ends with nineteen appendices listing for almost a hundred pages evidence from ceramic types to epigraphic and archaeobotanical data. These lists leave little doubt about the author's command of the evidence, but I do take issue with some of its interpretation. Engagement with economic theory is often somewhat eclectic and, despite the laudable decision to publish this book in English, there is less attention than one might like to the considerable output of English-language scholarship on the ancient economy following the landmark Cambridge Economic History of the Greek and Roman World (2007), itself cited mostly in passing. To be sure, Cifani proves beyond any doubt that Early Rome's economy was neither subsistence-based nor primitive; however, the point tends to push through an open door when viewed within current discourse on ancient Mediterranean connectivity. Moreover, if economic exchange can now be seen as a commonplace in antiquity, Rome's participation in a connected world need not necessarily imply its priority, while the book's maximalist view seems at times to proceed by assertion more than argument. It is possible that Rome was from an early date not only a consumer, but a producer of Central Mediterranean trade goods, but there is little evidence of what exactly was being exported; thus, Cifani must speculate about Rome's distribution of perishable, archaeologically invisible goods. Then, the confident assertion that Early Iron Age Rome was a strong state dominating its surrounding territory mostly comes down to the fact that the settlement's occupiable—but not necessarily occupied, as Ampolo's leopard spot city implies—space was larger than that of ‘minor’ centres like Crustumerium or Fidenae. (This Canadian reviewer wonders what the same analysis would say about Ottawa and Toronto.) By the sixth century, corroborating evidence appears in the form of truly monumental architecture at Rome, but for the earlier period questions about how settlements in the Lower Tiber Valley interacted are harder to answer from evidence at hand. And we might also ask whether communities even found it worthwhile to expend the great effort needed to pursue and maintain territorial domination, an assumption which current anthropological and historical research vigorously questions; cf. e.g. James C. Scott, Against the Grain: A Deep History of the Earliest States (2017). In Cifani's view, the Early Roman state rises to power almost automatically, but it is not hard to think of alternatives.
It seems almost inevitable that, as we accumulate evidence, the situation will begin to appear more messy and complex, while these books obviously show diverging desires to draw grand conclusions about Early Roman society from the available data. Whereas Marco Bettelli's essay in La Roma dei Re emphasises how the Italo-Mycenaean sherds from the Capitoline insert Rome into Bronze Age exchange networks encompassing Latium and south Etruria, Cifani goes further, identifying such material as ‘clear evidence of stable contacts with Aegean traders’ (33). The contrast should not detract from either work, both superbly up to date and for that reason especially valuable. The books also converge in an important way in their centring of the history of Early Rome around themes of connectivity and exchange. As becomes abundantly clear, Early Roman society was strongly shaped by its connections with the outside world and indeed repays being understood from a Mediterranean perspective. The influx of goods and people helped define the early settlement, as, even if it remains hard to say when such mobility started to single Rome out, we can see clearly that exchange presented evolving opportunities for Early Rome's inhabitants to (re)define their community. Of course, this is a very different history than the personalities and stories found in ancient writers. But after more than a century of intense, often polemical debates over how to reconcile sources and archaeology in the study of Early Rome, there is something refreshing about these ventures down pathways opened up by the material itself.
