Each of Albert Einstein's three ground-breaking papers of 1905 is nowadays considered to have merited the Nobel Prize for physics. He was nominated from 1910 onwards by increasing numbers of leading physicists. The award could have been for his contribution on Brownian motion, revealing the molecular structure of matter and forming the basis for statistical physics. Or it could have been for contributing to quantum physics, the overarching physical theory of the subsequent century. Or it could have been for the special and general theories of relativity. But when the prize was finally awarded in 1922 (deferred from 1921) it was for an achievement much more specific: an experimental ‘law’ relating the frequency of ultraviolet light to the energies of the electrons it ejects from metals. The novelty lay in light interacting with solids on the atomic scale and in Planck's quantum constant h featuring in the law.
How did this happen? Aant Elzinga's book, based on research in the Nobel archives, illuminates the tortuous path taken, from a narrow interpretation of Alfred Nobel's terms to antagonism on the four-man physics committee and a fudged compromise when the international credibility of the prize was at stake. Elzinga makes clear that the Nobel committee would not reward creative science, but only ‘discovery or invention’. It definitely did not reward ‘metaphysics and speculation’ – a stance relaxed in recent decades. Although Einstein's novel concept of duality (spelled out in 1909) went unmentioned in the citation, his prize is frequently attributed to his role in developing quantum theory. His best-known biographer, Abraham Pais (Subtle Is the Lord: The Science and Life of Albert Einstein, Oxford 1982), stated that, despite most nominators arguing for relativity, the award was rightly given for quantum physics. Pais lauded the ‘judgement of a highly responsible rather conservative body of great prestige … [the] story has neither heroes nor culprits’ (p. 503).
Elzinga's judgement is different and his analysis pulls no punches, showing a verdict cobbled together amidst personal biases and for a narrow experimental law. Chance had intervened with the unexpected death of the committee chairman. The hero was a new committee member, C. W. Oseen, who, finding that the others were set against relativity, argued for the ‘law’ being fundamental and underpinning Bohr's atom model. He successfully proposed a package using the deferred 1921 prize – one to Einstein and the second to Niels Bohr. But such was the animus against relativity theory that at the Swedish Academy's plenary meeting an astonishing reservation was added to Einstein's certificate (p. 1), declaring the value of the recognized work ‘independent of the value that (after eventual confirmation) may be credited to the relativity and gravitation theory’. By 1914–15 experimental tests confirming so fundamental a ‘law’ as the special theory of relativity would normally have satisfied the physics committee. But from 1914 they shifted the grounds of argument to the new general relativity theory (not published in full until 1916). Through 1917–19 they said the bending of light rays by the Sun was controversial and emphasized that no gravitational red shift had been detected in the Sun's light. These were seen to outweigh the success of the third test (advance of the perihelion of the planet Mercury).
The Nobel committee needed by 1921 to find a way out over Einstein, because of his high public profile as well as international scientific prestige. But a second reason for their change in view was a wish to play conciliator over the post-1918 ‘cold war in science’. The Swedish chemist Svante Arrhenius, Oseen and others in neutral Sweden valued scientific internationalism and wanted to bring together scientists from the former warring countries. Elzinga says the prize committees sought to use the awards as a political instrument, as the Peace Prize is used today. They made awards to several German scientists – Planck, Stark, Haber (despite involvement in gas warfare) and von Laue – and arranged a special celebration for the wartime nobellists in June 1920. Only Charles Barkla attended from the English-speaking world, and praised the ‘truly international’ award. Despite controversy (over Haber), its long-term prestige did apparently benefit. The 1921–2 awards to Einstein and Bohr were needed to restore credibility. Einstein's 1923 acceptance lecture was on relativity, then seen to be his major work. He spoke on that topic at the instigation of Arrhenius, who had thus reversed his opposition in committee.
Elzinga fails to say directly that Abraham Pais was mistaken, despite their quite different assessments of the Nobel committee's decision-making. How Pais's short chapter based on the same Nobel archive could get so much so wrong is not something Elzinga probes. Yet the issue is important, because Pais's biography – reissued in 2005 with plaudits from prominent physicists – carries authority and prestige for its exposition of Einstein's science. His mishandling of the Nobel episode arises from a more general partisanship on Pais's part on behalf of quantum physics in its heyday in the 1970s and early 1980s. It was Pais's biography that established the myth that Einstein lost the great Bohr–Einstein debate of the 1930s. Citation statistics show the famous EPR paper of 1935, arguing that quantum mechanics was incomplete, to be a ‘revived classic’ with few citations until around 1990 and a large upsurge since then. It is the only paper by Einstein in Physical Review that has this classic status (S. Redner, ‘Citation statistics from 110 years of Physical Review’, Physics Today (2005), 58, 49–54).
Biographies are naturally written within a social and cultural context. Not to bring out further how and why Pais's authoritative biography went wrong is an unfortunate deficiency in Elzinga's otherwise absorbing account. In tandem with the revival of quantum scepticism in physics, his book helps us recover Einstein's story from the tendentious interpretation of it that has gone unchallenged for too long.
