Beginning with Fritz Saxl's 1934 study of the horoscope ceiling which Baldassare Peruzzi painted for Agostino Chigi in the Villa Farnesina (1511), art historians have been fascinated by the monumental astrological vaults of Renaissance architecture. These lavish productions are often interpreted as rhetorical tools for naturalizing the legitimacy of the ruler among the ruled by associating the former's position with astrological fate. According to Mary Quinlan-McGrath, this was not at all how the patrons of such vaults interpreted their significance and use. Instead, she claims, these vaults were built as instruments for purifying and protecting the bodies, spirits, and minds of these patrons and their kin.
There is very little evidence for actors’ understandings of these starry vaults. One precious exception, which is central to Quinlan-McGrath's argument, occurs in Chapter III.19 of Marsilio Ficino's influential De vita, where Ficino concludes an extensive discussion of astrological images with the advice for a man to construct, ‘in the very depth of his house … a chamber, vaulted and marked with these figures and colors, and he should spend most of his waking hours there and also sleep’ (p. 161). The distinguishing feat of Quinlan-McGrath's book is to carefully explore how such advice could have made perfect sense for the elites of Renaissance Italy, embedded as it was in widely shared intellectual presuppositions reaching back as far as Plato's Timaeus.
The planning and ambit of this exploration, carried out in eight chapters, are simply breathtaking. In terms of planning, the author privileges a select number of presuppositions (‘gazing’ as the default relation between patrons and their vaults; vision as a (meta)physical mediator between things, rather than as a transmission of visual content; the self and architectural art as equally embedded in a divinely given, astrologically shaped nature and fate; artificial figures as privileged sites for capturing such celestial powers), and carefully shows how each of these was connected with another. This yields an elegant, Russian doll-like structure ‘from the larger concepts to the more particular’ (p. x).
In terms of ambit, it is clear that the author has waded through an enormous literature on premodern metaphysics, epistemology, astrology, mathematics, natural philosophy, psychology and art history, in supplying the reader with ‘the tools’ by which to ‘judge the case’ (p. 198). No less impressive is her judicious selection of what to include in the main body of the text (two hundred pages), and what to relegate to the particularly insightful endnotes (fifty pages).
So how is the case to be judged after reading this book? At the very least, Quinlan-McGrath's thesis is far less anachronistic than anything else which is on offer concerning this topic. This is not to say, of course, that her precise interpretation of the Renaissance equivalent of the oxygen tent is definitive. Consider her interpretation of Book III of Ficino's De vita. As early as Chapter III.8, Ficino introduces doubt and uncertainty about amulets as suitable recipients of portable celestial power; his subsequent discussion of figurae never really abandons these suspicions. Ficino, who articulates this in terms of ‘medicine’ versus ‘magic’, does grant the possibility of demonic agency in the effectiveness of figurae, and repeatedly takes the position that the heat released when inscribing a figure, not the inscription as such, is the source of its effectiveness. This makes the distance between him and a theologian like Aquinas less large than Quinlan-McGrath tends to suggest. Likewise, it remains unclear whether Ficino's talk of harmonies obtaining between images speaks the language of ‘sympathy’ or ‘copy’, of ressemblance or ‘representation’. Further research may also highlight Ficino's tendency to advance a strong distinction between the sub- and superlunary realms, as well as his apparent investment in an anagogy of the spirit towards the celestial and supra-celestial realm, rather than in sublunary empowerment per se. Finally, it remains to be seen what we should make of Ficino's frequent adoption of metaphors of preparation and accommodation in describing the relation between spirits and ‘celestial gifts’. Is the Ficinian self really an embodied being which also has spirits, or rather a ‘spirit in the material world’?
The simple fact remains, however, that Quinlan-McGrath's fresh look at these astrological canopies opens up entire new vistas of Renaissance intellectual life. This alone makes it required reading for anyone interested in Renaissance visual culture, architecture, and history of natural philosophy. But it can also serve as a model of scholarship. Over the past few decades, it has become far less uncommon for art historians to sink their teeth into premodern intellectual history and history of science. Influences crowns them all in tenaciousness and thoughtfulness.
