This excellent book focuses on Afghanistan, a country that suddenly found itself on the world's center stage after 9/11 and the subsequent acts of U.S. retaliation. Although the media have by now shifted their attention to other hot spots, the problems that the Afghan people face have not diminished substantially. In this comprehensive work, Schetter analyzes the reasons behind the thoroughly complex situation in the region.
As a starting point for his convincing argument, he takes the phenomenon of ethnic attribution and emphasizes that ethnicity is a recent phenomenon connected with the establishment of modern nation-states and is constructed in stark contrast to the historical continuity it tries to convey. How could a nation-state emerge and be installed in such a culturally diverse region in the first place? How did the state of Afghanistan, once created, handle such a considerable potential for social conflict and attempt to develop a national ideology? Schetter argues that ethnic groups in Afghanistan primarily developed from the interaction between the state and groups and individuals and that the main cause of the ethnic focus of Afghan society was the implementation and putting into practice of a nation-state ideology.
The work is divided into two parts. The first group of chapters provides a detailed introduction to the theory of ethnicity, and the second group presents the case study of Afghanistan. After introducing the most common sociological and ethnological approaches in the discussion on ethnicity, Schetter adds a spatial dimension by arguing that the belief in a common origin shared by members of an ethnic group is not only attached to a certain point in time but is also attached to one in space. It was only through the formation and worldwide expansion of nation-states, which need to have their own territories to justify their existence, that ethnic groups came into being and ethnically based demands began to be made. Therefore, the author roundly rejects the quite common theory that ethnicity guided political as well as military actions even before the establishment of the Afghan nation-state at the end of the 19th century.
The case study in the second part of the book begins with a historical overview of the various and quite conscious efforts to define ethnic groups in Afghanistan. Schetter neatly demonstrates how Western and Afghan scientists have displayed an untiring perseverance in dividing the Afghan population into ethnic categories since the beginning of the 20th century, trying to resolve the state of hybridity among different ethnic categories, once they were established, by systematically constructing new ones. Examining the constitutions of 1928, 1932, and 1964 against that background, the author traces out the genesis of the Afghan nation-state until the end of the 1970s, his main objective being to assess the importance of ethnicity for the period before the beginning of the Afghan War in 1978. For him, the key question is whether belonging to a certain ethnic group had a decisive effect on one's access to socioeconomic resources and institutions of power.
The analysis of the long period of war (1978–99) is the most comprehensive chapter of the study. Until the end of the 1970s this ethnic “framework of orientation” was reflected as a crucial element of social structuring even in the usual actions of everyday life. However, Cold War zeitgeist and the Afghans' focusing on their own social and spatial microcosms prevented an ethnic mobilization on a supraregional basis. This situation remained unchanged until the beginning of the war and the end of the East–West conflict in the late 1980s and the early 1990s. From then on, all warring factions unscrupulously exploited the element of ethnicity for their own political ends. Although the political demands for collective goods (like regional autonomy) were based on arguments of ethnicity, the ethnic dimension of the conflict was obscured by Islamic rhetoric, creating the specific situation we find in Afghanistan.
The manuscript of the book was completed in 2000. Before it could be published, however, events came thick and fast in Afghanistan, and in September 2002 Schetter consequently added an important postscript to his original text. Although ethnicity suggested itself as a universal explanation for the Afghanistan conflict after 9/11, the author points to the dangers of reducing the war to its ethnic dimension because this totally disregards the instrumentalization of the ethnic element by political actors, defining monolithic ethnic blocks that never existed in reality.
The media frequently reduce ethnic confrontations to the self-actualization of ethnic collectives, concluding that such confrontations are diametrically opposed to enlightened modern society, which is based on individual self-actualization. This view, which has now become quite common, suggests that the actors display an uncivilized and backward medieval behavior. Schetter argues that the ethnic solutions recommended by the United Nations merely uphold the ethnic propaganda used in the political arena and the planned system of ethnic quotas just cements the importance of ethnicity. In his view, a solution to the conflict in Afghanistan should not only consider the ethnic dimension but should also place far greater emphasis on the modern-day fault lines, particularly the differences between rural and urban regions, conflicts of ideology, and the clientele systems.
On the whole, Conrad Schetter has produced a brilliant study on the important subject of ethnicity in Afghanistan. The structure is clear, the central points are cogently elaborated, and the methodological reflections are at the highest level. This study is set to become an indispensable work for everyone who wants to deal with the more recent and contemporary history of Afghanistan.
