William T. Coleman's Counsel for the Situation promises to be of interest to at least three scholarly communities: civil rights historians, legal historians, and scholars interested in federal transportation policy during the Ford administration. As a civil rights memoir, Coleman's work joins a relatively substantial canon, including Andrew Young's An Easy Burden, Jack Greenberg's Crusaders in the Courts, John Lewis's Walking with the Wind, and Constance Baker Motley's Equal Justice under Law. To this literature, Coleman provides intriguing details about some of the twentieth century's greatest civil rights cases, including, for example, personal doubts about Kenneth Clark's famous doll studies in Brown v. Board of Education (123) and a surprising endorsement of gradual desegregation in Brown II (158–59). At the same time, Coleman sheds light on lesser-known but still important suits that he presided over as LDF director, including McLaughlin v. Florida which decriminalized interracial cohabitation (200–2), and Sanders v. Russell, allowing out-of-state lawyers to represent black plaintiffs without having to appear at every judicial proceeding (203–4).
Just as Tomiko Brown-Nagin complicates prevailing civil rights narratives by focussing on black attorneys who did not always agree with Marshall and the LDF (see Courage to Dissent), so too does Coleman's memoir complicate the dominant literature by suggesting that civil rights attorneys were not all liberal Democrats. A lifelong Republican, Coleman recounts hostility from black Democrats like Andrew Young (257), even as he defends the civil rights records of Republican Presidents Dwight D. Eisenhower (357), Richard Nixon (360), and Gerald Ford (360). In fact, one of the most fascinating passages of the book critiques Franklin Delano Roosevelt for sponsoring “vertical urban ghettos” (357), Lyndon Johnson for encouraging “dependence on federal largesse” (360), and Jimmy Carter for remaining “surprisingly silent on issues of race” (361).
Not only do Coleman's Republican ties distinguish him from most activist authors, they transform his book into something besides simply a civil rights memoir. Tapped by President Ford to serve as secretary of transportation, Coleman provides intriguing personal insights into a broad array of significant policy questions, including, for example, the decline of American railroads (239), the deregulation of American airlines (240), and the challenges involved in developing a “National Transportation Policy” (246). Here, historians of policy and politics alike will find topics of interest, whether it be narrow subjects like the construction of the Washington, DC metro or broader questions of federal deregulation and transportation markets.
Finally, some mention of Coleman's reflections on the practice of law is warranted. In addition to working on civil rights cases, Coleman also worked extensively on issues of business, entertainment, and public law. Rather than being an expert in a limited field of law, Coleman aspired to become a generalist, a “counsel for the situation,” as he puts it (367). Borrowed from Louis Brandeis's “counsel to the situation” (366), Coleman's self-identifier both indicates frustration with current trends towards increased specialization in legal practice, and also underscores a more subtle theme woven throughout the book, namely Coleman's quiet struggle to prove himself as an attorney in and of “the mainstream” (76). Unwilling to join black bar associations (76) and politically averse to “black separatism” (166), Coleman fought persistently to prove his professional mettle among whites, showing again and again how he won cases and attracted clients by out-performing the competition. Many of his best stories come from this vein, including, for example, Coleman's initial struggles to find employment in white firms (97–98), his notoriety as one of the few “commuter[s] of color” to ride first class daily from Philadelphia to New York (99) and his path-breaking entry into elite white social clubs like “the Midday Club” and “the Union League” in Philadelphia (189). Again and again, Coleman shows how he confronted racial barriers but persevered, convinced that “[n]othing breaks down artificial barriers of discrimination more than human interaction” (93).
