Historian Deborah Valenze opines, “Recent economic theory employing semiotics suggests that money indeed creates its own universe of knowledge” (p. 58). She appears to dismiss all economic reasoning about the role of money since the nineteenth century as fundamentally mistaken, on the basis of a 1998 article by Geoffrey Ingham in Acta Sociologica, the Journal of the Nordic Sociological Association. To give a flavor about how Ingham establishes that conclusion we have the following quote from him, “If money is essentially an abstract measuring system, then all ‘money’ (as opposed to simple media of exchange) is ‘virtual’, including not just ‘modern’ or even ‘postmodern’ money.” (p. 23).
The thrust of the book is about how the increasing monetization of the English economy in the period 1640–1770 created an increased “commodification” of women, children, servants, the poor, and criminals. It blurred the boundaries between people and things. But the process of dehumanization of people by money was somehow, mysteriously, reversed at the end of the eighteenth century by money becoming identified with a new notion of self.
The analysis of the book is predicated on a number of stark, unargued, and incorrect assumptions. The first is that a market exchange mediated by money is somehow of a fundamentally different category than an exchange by barter. Selling a cow for £5 mysteriously radically redefines selling a cow, compared to exchanging it for 10 bushels of wheat. The book nowhere demonstrates any difference between these types of transaction. When my father was a boy in Glasgow in the 1930s he would attend Saturday movie shows for children where the price of admission was two glass jam jars. He reports that the monetization of this barter exchange in the late 1930s did not seem to have affected the quality of the movie-going experience.
A second confusion is that exchanges that take place in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century England, with money as the medium, take place only because the exchange has been monetized. Women, children, servants, the poor, criminals were all “commodified” because of money. This is illustrated by the discussion of the bizarre practice of “wife sales.” (pp. 246–52). Such fictive sales are known to have existed from medieval times to the nineteenth century, but were most prevalent in 1785–1845. Lower class husbands who wished to divorce their wife would lead them by a halter into a market place, and auction them to the highest bidder. That highest bidder was pre-arranged. The fraction of marriages ending this way would be small, but it is nevertheless an odd mechanism, and certainly one designed to emphasize the chattel dependence of the wife. Valenze wants to interpret this practice as arising from the existence of a money economy, which commodified women. But you could as well sell your wife for a sack of wheat, or a gallon of ale, as for shillings. Moreover, you could have sold your wife for money as easily in 1300 as in 1800, even though the practice was so much more common later. The Pirahã, an Amazonian group completely innocent of money (they have no counting system in their language), who barter for commodities with Brazilian traders, prostitute their wives for cheap whiskey. God knows what will happen when money ends their innocence. This forced and implausible linkage between a type of divorce and money is just one of a catalogue of such unlikely liaisons that the author proposes: between money and slavery, money and the treatment of the poor, money and criminal justice.
Even Valenze's claim of the increasing commodification of the economy in 1640–1770 is suspect. Back in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries we find an economy already where money was in wide use. Manorial day laborers were paid in money. The Poll Tax of 12d a head on every male of 1381, equal to three days wages, was collected in cash. Most land rents were in cash. It was also an economy where the commodification that Valenze decries was widespread, perhaps even more so than later. Lords were still collecting cash fines in manorial courts for the right to marry your daughter outside the manor, for the right to leave the manor, or for women's sexual incontinence (leyrwite). Parents drew up formal maintenance agreements with their children that specified all the goods and services they were to receive when they retired and handed over their holdings to their children. What was so special about money or commodification in 1640–1770? The book in this respect is curiously a-historical, looking only at the author's chosen period without regard to developments before 1640 and after 1770 that would contradict the thesis.
Unfortunately this book reveals more about the decline of history as a discipline under the assault of a variety of ill formulated jargon imported from literary studies, than it does about money and English society in 1640–1770.
