Bill Kissane's New Beginnings: Constitutionalism and Democracy in Modern Ireland provides a rich historical overview of Ireland's twentieth-century constitutional development. The book successfully employs the Irish case to analyze broader empirical, theoretical, and normative issues associated with establishing and preserving effective and stable democratic regimes. To this end, the book engages five “constitutional moments”: three deal with the successive stages of Ireland's fight for independence from Britain that culminated in de Valera's 1937 constitution; one explores political unrest in Northern Ireland and social changes in the Republic between 1969 and 1974; and the final one addresses the 1998 Belfast agreement which altered institutional arrangements in the North and consolidated peace in that part of Ireland. The detailed historical account of these constitutional moments provides a useful framing to examine critical junctures in Ireland's political development. Though the narrative is engaging, at times the chronological approach makes it difficult to appreciate the ways in which, and the degree to which, institutional, cultural, and agency-based explanations shape Kissane's overall argument. Rather than “new beginnings,” as the title suggests, Kissane tells a story of gradual development and embedded historical legacies.
Kissane's narrative reveals several reasons why Ireland is a useful case study. First, Kissane explores the question of how and why Ireland was able to establish and consolidate its democracy in the interwar period between 1918 and 1939 at a time when many European countries succumbed to various forms of authoritarian regimes. Ireland possessed one of the strongest executive branches in Europe and experienced growing centralization during the 1930s. Furthermore, institutional checks and balances in the 1922 constitution did not prevent strong party governments from dominating during this period. Kissane emphasizes historical legacies and cultural factors to explain why democracy prevailed in the Irish case.
A second reason Ireland serves as a telling case study is its complex relationship with the United Kingdom. This contentious relationship colors virtually every aspect of twentieth-century Irish politics and offers insights for other postcolonial and post-conflict states. Kissane also successfully demonstrates how the Irish-UK relationship touches upon salient themes in the budding field of constitutional studies. For example, he discusses the transition from “Treaty” to “Constitution” as it applies to both the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland. Whereas treaties are agreements between states seeking to ensure peaceful relations between them, constitutions codify political culture and public opinion about how politics should distribute power among government institutions and the rights of citizens within a country. This distinction is relevant for both parts of Ireland and helps explain why “new beginnings” or new constitutional moments are really the next steps in the evolution of Ireland on its path toward complete independence. Kissane continually underscores how partition institutionalized this sense of incomplete independence for both parts of Ireland and provided for ongoing constitutional controversies.
Kissane's analysis of the 1919, 1922, and 1937 constitutions thoroughly summarizes the debates over the type of institutions Ireland's democracy would implement at each stage. Kissane first explains how the balance of power between the UK and Ireland greatly influenced the character and set of institutions each constitution implemented. He goes beyond the conventional wisdom that the 1919 constitution was more a declaration of independence and propaganda document than a substantive governing framework by highlighting the various debates that dominated this founding period despite its not being formally enacted. Next, the 1922 constitution set forth clear lines of authority and a defined set of institutions for the newly created Irish Free State. This constitution was greatly constrained by the British government's veto over anything that violated the Anglo-Irish Treaty of 1921. Although this constitution perpetuated much of Britain's legal and bureaucratic structures within Ireland and the Westminster model of disciplined parties and a strong executive, Kissane highlights a marked shift toward incorporating fundamental law via the protection of individual rights, the use of referenda and plebiscites, and the existence of a written constitution. Ireland represents a hybrid case wherein parliamentary sovereignty associated with the Westminster model coexisted with institutions that promoted popular sovereignty. Kissane astutely argues that the first two constitutions represent an unusual blend of nationalism and constitutionalism coexisting, which was very different from other countries where these two sentiments were often in tension with one another.
For Kissane, the 1937 Constitution completed the path toward independence for the Republic of Ireland. Kissane rehearses common arguments about the blend of maintaining much of the previous institutional framework while at the same time imbuing this constitution with a conservative Catholic national identity that more accurately reflected state-society relations at the time. He highlights a renewed emphasis on the “state” that had been de-emphasized in 1922 because of the role of the British government. The fact that institutions that promoted popular sovereignty (PR-STV, referenda, and the presidency) assumed greater currency in 1937 reinforced the tension between these “new” elements and the legacies of parliamentary sovereignty inherited from the British. More clarity in terms of the explanatory factors that determined this particular trajectory would have strengthened this rich historical review.
Kissane's chapter on the Belfast Agreement of 1998 returns to the theme of the transition from “Treaty” to “Constitution” by illustrating how features of both exist in contemporary Northern Ireland. Although Kissane's treatment of what is new about the Belfast agreement is rather familiar, he helpfully places the three strands of the peace process (i.e., power relations within Northern Ireland, between North and South, and between the UK and Republic of Ireland governments) into his broader framework. He also incorporates the experience of the European Union and the fact that the Republic of Ireland has changed socially, economically, and politically in ways that allowed it to work as an equal with the British. Lessons from the Northern Irish peace process are valuable for other cases of conflict resolution where treaties and new constitutions are involved.
A third reason why Ireland is a useful case for exploring broader constitutional issues is that Ireland's Constitution has survived and maintained overall institutional stability during a time of dramatic social, economic, and political change. Increased pluralism due to modernizing family and women's roles, secularization, immigration, and globalization has so altered society that some question whether Ireland needs a new constitution. Kissane's analysis of the growing reliance on referenda and judicial review to address Ireland's changing social conditions underscores the balance between features of the constitution's rigidity and flexibility and explains why Ireland's constitution has survived a period of tumultuous change. Although this chapter does not fit as neatly into the book's overall focus on Ireland's constitutional issues as they relate to independence, it offers a welcome integration of the role of individuals, parties, and civil-society actors with institutional and cultural arguments.
Kissane's book should be required reading for anyone interested in twentieth-century Irish politics. His analysis of Ireland's constitutional development raises several themes of relevance for comparative scholars seeking to understand the complex state-society relationships that undergird the implementation of constitutions and the impact this has on the quality of democracy. Kissane successfully highlights how an overemphasis on bolstering effective governance among constitutional practitioners can ultimately contribute to undermining the overall democratic character of a constitution.
