“Dark matter” is the name that physicists give to material that is irregularly distributed around the visible universe but is itself undetectable. We are fairly sure it is there, despite our inability to observe it, because several observable phenomena are best understood as gravitational effects of its mass: we deduce the existence of what we can't see from the behavior of what we can. Andrew Sofer's ingenious and somewhat playful book adopts this concept as a metaphor for theatre.
It is a good idea: the theatrical significance of the invisible is often overlooked, but a moment's thought confirms how central it is. Traditional symbols such as the mask and the curtain tacitly acknowledge that theatre is as much about concealment as it is about display; and familiar dramatic tropes, from the messengers of Attic tragedy to the just-out-of-sight sex of Restoration comedy, repeatedly link the stage to a determining unstaged universe. For an artistic medium whose obvious distinction is physical presence, drama depends surprisingly often on the absent and the unseen. Yet Sofer is unusual in having been surprised enough to make this dependence his central theme. It affords a broad territory to explore.
His mode of exploration is the case study: the chapters take the form of essays on plays that range chronologically from Christopher Marlowe's Doctor Faustus to Caryl Churchill's Far Away (2000). In some ways, this text-based procedure is rewarding, because it means that the deconstructive moves that Sofer wants to make can be carried through some finely angled particular reading. For example, the carnival-time plot of Aphra Behn's The Rover prompts an investigation of the sexual politics of masks, and the complicated relationship between the male look, the hidden woman, and the woman on display. The strongest chapter concerns Arthur Miller's The Archbishop's Ceiling (1977), a play set in Eastern Europe whose central conceit is that the eponymous ceiling, hanging over the stage throughout, conceals a listening device. Sofer shows subtly how the diffused sense of being overheard undermines the integrity of the idea of character. Realist drama, such as Miller's own earlier work, had assumed that each actor speaks as a unitary subject of ethical choice, but under the archbishop's ceiling that self unravels into disparate strands of performance and presence; it is a crisis of representation not only for the playwright's fictional people but also for his artistic form. The eavesdropping state is dark matter indeed, nowhere visible but everywhere felt through its gravitational drag on the trajectories we watch. Its darkness, moreover, is essential, not adventitious: the bug is unknowable. It is possible that it is nonexistent, or that nobody in the security services is bothering to listen; but it still works to distort the onstage relationships, because you can never be sure. Here Sofer's basic critical metaphor is shrewdly and even movingly apt.
However, just this felicity indicates a problem of method. The chapter describes the importance of invisibility to this one play—to its structure, its political referentiality, the story it tells. So it has the character of a text-specific “reading,” whose conclusions cannot necessarily be generalized. However, when Sofer's master concept is introduced at the outset of the book, it is presented as more than a way of interpreting certain texts. “Dark matter is woven into the fabric of theatrical representation” (4). This assertion, which recurs in various wordings through the book, is not a move within the exposition of this or that play; rather, it forms part of a theory of theatre as such. Ironically, the idea's special appositeness to the selected play obstructs its larger theoretical application. The same invisible determinant, whatever it may be—the masked face, the hidden microphone, the offstage atrocity—has to do double duty: it appears as a noteworthy particular invention but also as a general condition of theatrical meaning. It is required to be exceptional and representative in the same breath. In short, a discourse that is really literary criticism is trying to do the work of poetics, and the functional gap is hard to bridge.
The difficulty is felt especially when the play is historically remote. The Doctor Faustus chapter, for instance, revolves around the anecdote about a sixteenth-century performance the actors abandoned when they realized that there was one devil too many on the stage. Sofer deduces an open border between the stage and the world: early modern theatrical utterances could be effectual performatives. This confounds the exceptional with the representative, however. The apparition in the story is memorable because it is exactly what is not expected to happen in a playhouse. To treat it as paradigmatic is rather like concluding from the Aurora shooting that violent death is a normal element of Hollywood premieres. It's an interesting story, but it doesn't demonstrate a general instability in “the distinction between performance and performativity” (37).
Besides, the question about performativity is of tenuous relevance. In the story, as in Marlowe's play, devils are not dark matter but are literally visible: the relations of seen and unseen are certainly problematic, but it is not the same problem. This is one instance of the extreme inclusiveness of the basic category. Theatrical invisibility embraces things that could be staged but aren't, that can't be staged for reasons of decorum, that can be staged only suggestively, that are inherently invisible, that have been made invisible by repression, and so on. I said earlier that Sofer had identified a broad field for exploration, but at this point the breadth is disabling. One could discuss virtually any play in these terms. The effect, despite the totalizing promise of the scientific terminology, is of a sequence of loosely connected readings of plays that have caught the author's interest. It is perhaps a sign of the academic times that this modest and intelligent project has to claim to be so much more.
