The complex known as the “Great Temple” is one of Petra's key monuments, rising above the southern side of the colonnaded street (Via Sacra) and overlooking the city center. Over the course of the last 20 years, it has also become one of the best-known monuments of Petra, a true showpiece of Nabataean art and architecture. This rise to prominence is entirely thanks to the efforts of M. Joukowsky (J.) and her team. The Brown University excavation of the “Great Temple” of 1993–2008 has been one of Petra's most expansive and successful archaeological projects, and exemplary in both its execution and its publications.
The present volume is the third and final publication (volume 1 appeared in 1998, volume 2 in 2007). Alongside these, the team has published scores of articles and conference papers, as well as an open-access database meticulously covering all relevant aspects, from the nitty-gritty of the material evidence to in-depth synthetic studies with a wider focus.Footnote 1 This third volume is a keystone in terms of chronology as well as substance. With the bulk of architecture and material evidence published in previous volumes, this book complements and rounds off prior research with analyses of the material, and often fresh insights along the way. It should be noted, however, that there is a considerable time lag here: the manuscripts for this book were completed in 2010 but publication was delayed for reasons beyond the editor's control (explained on 7). The book is divided into two parts, “Architecture” and “Material Culture,” with 9 and 17 chapters respectively, written by 22 contributors. Five appendices offer useful statistics, detailed measurements, a database analysis, and typologies of the pottery and architectural decoration.
The “Great Temple” is a highly symmetrical complex measuring about 113 by 70 m and spread out over three levels, respectively the propylon, lower peristyle court (called “lower temenos” by the excavators), and upper court with large hall (“cella”) featuring interior colonnades. It is flanked to the west by a Roman-Byzantine bath complex, to the south by a richly decorated residential area, and to the east by a garden complex with an ornamental pool and pavilion. All these structures were excavated by the team, though the garden complex was published separately and is not included in this volume.
In her introduction (11–30), J. sets out the 15 site phases, of which phases II–V are the main construction periods, roughly between the mid-1st c. BCE and the end of the 1st c. CE. Phase IV, the “grand design” phase, which saw the construction of almost all the key features, is dated to ca. 1st c. BCE–1st c. CE. More precision would have been desirable here and especially for phase V, as it entails major restructuring near the watershed moment of 106 CE, when the Nabataean kingdom was turned into the Roman province of Arabia; but the evidence, as J. acknowledges, “does not permit more than a rather broad dating” (16).
In Chapter 3, “Construction techniques” (41–70), S. Rababeh deals expertly with building materials, foundations, floors, vaults, walls, columns, etc. The most fascinating questions concern the “cella.” It lies in the center of the upper “temenos,” 25 m above Petra's colonnaded street. For phase IV it was reconstructed as a rectangular Corinthian tetrastyle in antis (28 × 42.5 m) with wide intercolumniation, 5 m on the sides and 7 m in the center. Curiously, it has a massive colonnade on the inside, running along three sides of the room. The question of the roofing of the “cella,” and whether certain parts were roofed at all, cannot be conclusively determined (60–64). At different stages, it might have had a pitched roof, or it could have been an open-air courtyard surrounded by covered walkways.
J. J. Basile covers the “Sculpted relief panels from the Great Temple” (106–22). They were recovered from the lower “temenos,” a large peristyle court (70 × 65 m) with a well-preserved pavement of hexagonal slabs, flanked to each side by a double portico, terminating in the south in semicircular exedras. The monumental relief panels (each about 90 cm wide), reused in secondary structures, were carved in low relief and depict a series of busts of male and female deities (Ares?, Tyche, Aphrodite, Athena). The fleshy Hellenistic style corresponds to the relief panels with deities and marine imagery found at the nearby temenos gate of the Qasr al-Bint (the “1967 group”), all dated to the late 1st c. BCE. The “Great Temple” panels may have originally decorated the antae walls of the “cella.” Also from the lower peristyle court come the famous and unique elephant-headed capitals discussed by J. (134–47). These elephants are probably the most iconic images from the “Great Temple.”
R. Frederiksen deals with the “Theater-in-temple” in Chapter 8 (149–96). In phase V, the “cella” saw a remarkable turnaround. It was inscribed with a cavea, i.e., semicircular ranks in the manner of a theater which offered space to some 600 people. But why was a theater built inside a temple? Generally speaking, theater-like structures of this kind were often multifunctional; they could cater to dramatic or musical performances, or assemblies of various kinds. In my view, one of its key functions may well have been as a bouleuterion (Frederiksen is skeptical, 183). In terms of size and design it is comparable to the Hellenistic and Roman examples of Miletos, Priene, Iasos, and Pompeii, or to the bouleuterion in Jerash. In addition to structural similarities, the bouleuteria of both Petra and Jerash also had the stage buildings added subsequently and executed with much less care.
The uniqueness of this radical redesign cannot be overstated: “it is unique in Roman architecture. The installation of a theater into a pre-existing colonnade is a rare phenomenon, and no close parallels for the construction and plan of the Great Theater Temple exist” (186). But it was not just a colonnade: the theater was built into what the excavators identify as a temple cella. If true, this was an astonishing desecration and repurposing of a functioning temple, a measure so drastic that it defies explanation.
This raises the key questions about the “Great Temple” complex, or what J. calls “the Great Debate” (415): What was the “cella” for? What, ultimately, was the entire building complex for? Was it a sanctuary? An administrative building? A place for assemblies and public gatherings? On this question, most contributors to the volume withhold explicit judgment. They use designations such as “cella,” “temenos,” etc. throughout (without quotation marks), but are generally careful not to commit to a definitive answer about the building's function. This is a deliberate stance: “scholars do not universally agree that it represents a Nabataean sacred space … but nothing from our excavations has been left unsaid, so let the debate continue!” (415). This is a refreshingly open and welcoming attitude, and one that invites informed debate and reasoned arguments.
To my mind, the evidence stacks up against a sanctuary and in favor of a royal structure for assemblies and audiences. To start with, there is the improbable desecration of the “cella” when it was transformed into a theater-like structure. In addition, the “cella” design itself seems unparalleled for a temple and ill-suited as a divine abode. Cellas are normally enclosed spaces. Here, however, the “naos” is wide open to the “pronaos,” only separated by a pair of columns. The wall surrounding the interior space (with its peculiar three-sided colonnade on the inside) was pierced on all sides by numerous windows and entrances. With its wide openings and numerous accesses, this building stands out from ancient and in particular Nabataean sacred architecture. It also lacked cultic paraphernalia: no adyton or cult platform has been found in the “cella,” nor were there ex votos, altars, dedicatory inscriptions, or traces of a cult statue.
These architectural features are jarring when seen through the lens of religious architecture, but they make sense when seen from a palatial angle. This alternative interpretation was first explored by E. L. Schluntz, a member of the Brown team, in her PhD thesis from 1999, which is also regularly cited in this volume.Footnote 2 Royal palatial architecture, especially that of Herod the Great, opens up a number of promising architectural analogies. Like the “cella,” the large triclinium of Herod's third palace in Jericho was a rectangular hall with a wide entrance at the center of one short side and a triple interior portico close to the wall: both were oeci Corinthii in Vitruvian style, with basilica-like features. In both halls the first column on either side has an elongated diameter, and the two columns in the back corner are heart-shaped for aesthetic and static reasons.
Further links with Herodian architecture are found in other areas of the “Great Temple” complex. Intricate gilded and colored stucco decorations from the residential area to the southwest of the “cella” (not in this volume but discussed by J. in other publicationsFootnote 3) are stylistically very close to Herod's palaces at Masada, Jericho, and Herodium. Even the stucco employed in all these examples is of precisely the same kind, as a chemical analysis has shown. The luxurious pool and garden complex to the east of the “Great Temple” points in the same direction. The discovery of flowerpots, ollae perforatae, which show this to be a formal garden or small-scale paradeisos, has provided another Herodian link: the flowerpots are of the same type as those in Jericho. The pool (43 × 23 × 2.5 m) had at its center a monumental rectangular pavilion supported by four interior Corinthian columns on high pedestals. Schluntz noted clear parallels with Herod's pool complex and pavilion at Herodium with regard to the proportions of the complex and the position of the pavilion. All these architectural analogies strongly point toward palatial architecture. Of course, definite proof is more than one can hope for. The discussion around the “Great Temple” will no doubt carry on and continue to bear fruit.
The exploration and publication of the “Great Temple” complex open new avenues of research. They reveal aspects of Nabataean art and architecture and links to the outside world that one would not have suspected until just a few years ago. It is thanks to the efforts of J. and her team that we are in a position to appreciate the significance of this major Nabataean monument in the heart of Petra. This book will be welcomed by the scholarly community not only as a research summary and mise à jour, but also, thanks to its meticulous documentation, as a reference work, a compendium for all “Great Temple” research in future years. Let the debate continue!
