Counting among his nemeses the likes of Henri Bergson, immortalized as the radical Max Gottlieb in Sinclair Lewis's novel Arrowsmith (1925), and equipped, more recently, with Philip Pauly's catchy label ‘engineering ideal’, Jacques Loeb – of tropism and artificial parthogenesis fame – had little time for qualitative, vitalist mysticism; like no other twentieth-century scientist, Loeb came to represent the quintessential ‘mechanistic’ biologist, vigorously endorsing his programme of a ‘technical biology’, as he himself would call it: a programme gradually taking shape in the course of Loeb's formidable career as a champion of experimental biology which began in the 1880s, as a meandering student of physiology between Berlin, Strasbourg and Naples, and ended in 1924 in America – Loeb's Heimat of choice – at the Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research.
Jewish descent, and increasingly estranged from his native Germany and her ways, there is no lack of a tragic element in Loeb's rather well-charted biography nevertheless. Indeed, if one is to follow the received narratives by Pauly, Robert Kohler, Gerald Geison and others, the speciality most closely tied to Loeb's celebrated name, ‘general physiology’, was a curious ‘undiscipline’ at best, if not a ‘disciplinary failure’, surpassed and outcrowded by the successes of biochemistry and the needs of medical schools – Loeb's quantitative zeal notwithstanding. But few historians, in fact, have (then or since) felt tempted to pursue the fate of the physiological sciences much beyond 1900, ‘general’ and otherwise. And few have ventured much beyond a small number of academic laboratories in doing so. Heiner Fangerau's Spinning the Scientific Web is, or could have been, a welcome recent exception to the pattern, pursuing the physiological trajectory of Loeb and his ‘scientific web’ – a variation on Ludwik Fleck's Denkkollektive (thought collectives) – against the prevailing historiographic preoccupation with the origins of biochemistry and molecular biology in the early twentieth century.
It is, at any rate, not tragedy but a certain quantitative zeal which pervades Fangerau's biographical investigations (a predilection which Fangerau quite evidently shares with his object of study). Indeed, the most striking feature of Fangerau's book is the ample use it makes of quantitative methods and routines of data visualization diverted, mostly, from sociology: from the (historiographically) more familiar techniques of citation analysis to the less familiar, and more recent, tools of network analysis. Throughout they supplement Fangerau's ‘qualitative’, or what he terms ‘classical hermeneutic’, operations (p. 161), which centre, somewhat schematically at times, on themes such as Loeb's deployment of laboratory animals, his views on German and American science (or national ‘style’), or the continuities and ruptures within Loeb's Denkkollektiv. Such techniques are at home with market analysts and employees of Interpol rather than with historians of science, but the latter may usefully profit from Fangerau's detailed and technical discussion of the methods involved; they may, at the very least, find some inspiration, especially if they face having to deal with huge amounts of textual data, as many a historian of twentieth-century science would, or if they share a suspicion of the sometimes rather intuitionist methods of cultural history. They may, however, be less impressed with the results at hand.
The bulk of Fangerau's book is devoted to the thesis that Loeb's vision of a ‘technical biology’ was instrumental, or stilbildend, as regards the emergence of twentieth-century ‘biomedicine’ (p. 15 and passim) – biomedicine being understood as the gradual reformatting of the medical sciences in the course of the last century through ‘basic’, physico-chemical experimental research. The significance of Loeb's ‘scientific web’ in this process Fangerau establishes with evidence drawn from citation analysis, publication patterns and the like, but the plausibility of Fangerau's narrative clearly suffers from the lack of any in-depth engagement with the historiography of medicine (such as, most obviously perhaps, the laboratory-versus-clinic historiography, and its many twists and complications); nor does it seem to sit very easily with the ‘undiscipline’ stories of general physiology mentioned above. Fangerau's study, while less focused on the American context than Pauly's more readable Controlling Life (1987), thus ultimately adds little to Loeb's historical persona; nor does it put to historiographic effect the wealth of – quantified – material Fangerau has meticulously gathered. Indeed, a great deal of the conclusions Fangerau derives from his non-hermeneutic methods, such as that ‘informal’ thought collectives (correspondence networks) are less volatile than ‘formal’ thought collectives (‘citation networks’) (p. 161), would seem to be applicable to almost any scientist's biography: theory, shored up with numbers, tends to trump history. And more generally, Fangerau's depiction of Loeb's thought collective remains, on the whole, lifeless and somewhat ahistorical. This is rather unfortunate, for underneath Fangerau's data and graphs there do seem to lurk much revisionist potential and other, less familiar stories – at least as far as narratives of ‘general physiology’ are concerned. Thus, alongside such familiar names as philosopher–physicist Ernst Mach, embryologist Hans Driesch or Rockefeller trustee Simon Flexner, it is figures such as William Bate Hardy, Wolfgang Ostwald, Henry Proctor, Frederic Donnan or Leonor Michaelis who make a conspicuously prominent appearance in Fangerau's data: figures best remembered, or derided, as representatives of a ‘dark age of biocolloidity’ (Marcel Florkin) but whose oeuvre would have encompassed, as it were, a truly technical, if rather impure, biology, since their work ranged from the study of frozen meat and lubricants to the viscosity of bread to leather tanning and sewage. Fangerau, however, does not make much of this rather curious, physiological thought collective; nor, regrettably, do we learn much of all this, or of what else breathed life into Loeb's ‘scientific web’. Yet perhaps unravelling this web would have revealed a different story of early twentieth-century, ‘technical’ biology – one that is neither one of basic biomedicine, nor indeed one of the undisciplined failures of general physiology.
