Joel Paris is Emeritus Professor of Psychiatry at McGill University. He has published widely and on topics as diverse as chronic suicidality and a contextualization of psychotherapy in the neuroscientific age. Since the first edition, he published Overdiagnosis in Psychiatry (Paris, Reference Paris2015), which examined pathways to over-treatment, complex challenges in delineating diagnoses, consequences of ‘diagnosis epidemics’ and the dominance of biological reductionism in academia.
In the preface to this second edition, Paris highlighted ongoing theoretical and clinical challenges within psychiatry and reminded readers that evidence-based medicine (EBM) did not exist, as we know it, until the mid-twentieth century. As such, he argued for the continued importance of a critical eye. This edition aimed to examine this subject in more detail, contextualize the issues with reference to research, and offer a greater degree of critique. The title is itself a play on the classic Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science (Gardner, 1957). Fads are ‘…practices based on temporary bursts of enthusiasm’ that ‘…short circuit the slow advance of science’, and an excessive focus on one issue – with a failure to appreciate complexity – is highly characteristic. Fads are categorized under etiology, diagnosis, psychopharmacology, psychotherapy, and prevention. Fallacies encompass a range of cognitive errors, biases, and associated phenomena (e.g., correlation/causation conflation, reductionism, and groupthink).
Paris identified three main problematic themes in contemporary practice: the limitations of current diagnostic systems, managing expectations around neuroscience, and, finally, the marginalization of psychotherapy. He offered critiques on the most dominant classificatory systems and considered alternatives. He explored various driving forces behind overdiagnosis and orientated readers to the issues of concept creep, disorder spectrumification, and failures to consider psychosocial contexts. Paris outlined how these can funnel toward overdiagnosis and, in turn, overprescribing. He argued, for instance, that broadening the diagnostic criteria for depression has resulted in too low a threshold, thereby medicalizing ordinary life experiences, and addressed similar trends in other conditions (i.e., bipolar disorders, ADHD, autism spectrum disorders, and complex post-traumatic stress disorder). Indeed, he flagged the extension of ADHD into adult populations as one of the most striking modern fads.
The realm of treatment is reckoned as a fad heartland. Clinicians may find themselves more vulnerable to fads through therapeutic desperation, the allure of novelty, idealism, overconfidence, and even pride. Extremes of fanaticism or inertia may also be evident around a condition. Paris explained how these states could serve to perpetuate fads. Readers learn how despite ECT being an effective treatment, for example, it regrettably still suffers from the residual effects of its early faddish application. Paris charted the trajectory of psychoanalytic dominance in American psychiatry acknowledging its distinctive intellectual appeal, a key factor in its rise, and its unfalsifiability, which ushered in its demise.
The current under-reliance on psychotherapeutic interventions is contrasted with the over-reliance on prescribing and the ‘cult of medication adjustments’. Paris illustrated the perils of reductionism – citing, for example, ‘chemical imbalance’ theories – and how the more a theory claims to explain everything, the less likely it is to do so. He described the trend in over-prescription of antipsychotics as potentially the most harmful fad today given their side effects.
He urged doctors to remain mindful of the limitations inherent to the academic publishing industry. In tandem with this, the evolution of the relationship between doctors, the pharmaceutical industry, and the public was interrogated. He called for an evidence-based integration of differing psychotherapeutic modalities. Regarding prevention, he emphasized this as posing a fundamental challenge given our limited understanding of causation. Finally, Paris proposed various ‘antidotes’ stressing the importance of a healthy blend of critical thinking, curiosity, and skepticism. He encouraged readers to engage in clinical research and implored their practice to be evidence-based wherever possible.
In terms of strengths, Paris explored comprehensively – from individual to systemic level – the range of factors allowing fads and fallacies to pass into the mainstream. He drew on a breadth of clinical and academic experience to illustrate the topics. He advocated a more judicious approach to psychiatric practice, shepherded by EBM. His recommendations remain largely unchanged with the necessity of trainees becoming comfortable with uncertainty and complexity underscored. These represent resoundingly constructive messages to convey to the next generation.
While the author indicated EBM’s rise meant patients became more active in their engagement with services, coverage of technological advances and changes in practice and society was, admittedly, rather limited. Since the first edition, social media has undoubtedly become a potent vehicle for faddish behaviour given how it transformed public discourse. It has fuelled public interest in psychedelic ‘microdosing’, by way of merely one example. Indeed, there are many other similar examples falling under the broad umbrella of the ‘wellness industry’ some of which certainly overlap with the fringes of contemporary psychiatric practice. The pandemic heralded widespread introduction of telemedicine at pace, and, with it, a proliferation of online therapists of varying standards. Linked to this, the range of mental health apps and trackers has also grown steadily over the past decade. More broadly, mental health itself has steadily moved into the mainstream. Viral movements have shown themselves to be tremendously powerful and potentially capable of influencing public opinion to such a degree that policy, funding, or even the law may ultimately undergo transformation. Significantly, the release of this second edition largely coincided with the public launch of artificial intelligence (AI) tools, which was met with great exuberance. How such innovations will affect practice remains unclear; however, there is clearly scope for widespread applications across healthcare, and this has begun in earnest. Whether potential will be applied empirically is the hope rather than the likelihood. Perhaps, in that sense, this second edition suffered from misfortunate timing; there may be a lot more to write about in the near future.
This second edition offers a critical re-examination of psychiatry’s vulnerability to transient enthusiasm. By navigating a course through modern history, medical students, trainees, and clinicians are encouraged to engage critically with new trends. Overall, it instills an appreciation of the often non-linear nature of progress more generally.
Competing interests
OPO’S is a member of the RCPsych Books Committee. This review was not commissioned.
