This is a curious book, best read in a double register. The authors' explicit aim is to correct certain orthodoxies in Tawney scholarship that, in their words “distort” the true nature of Tawney's thought. These orthodoxies are repeated a number of times throughout the book and come down to the assumptions that (a) Tawney's political thought never changed substantially or developed over the course of his career, (b) that his thought was continually informed by and articulated a deep Christian sensitivity, and (c) that it is more or less of a piece and betrays a surprising degree of internal coherence.
The authors challenge each of these assumptions in turn, and the structure of the book revolves around their debunking of these “myths” of Tawney scholarship. This is the first register and it will be of interest mostly to the world of Tawney scholarship and perhaps to arguments within the English Left and Labour movement where the stature of Tawney is still grand. Mind you, though, the debunking of these myths will not, I believe, change much in the appreciation of Tawney's moral position nor in the exhilaration we still feel as we read Tawney's inspiring prose. At least, I hope it doesn't.
I first encountered Tawney's writing in public high school in Brooklyn in the 1960s and it made perfect sense in those times of social protest, activism, and visions of a better world. From the blank look of most of my students when Tawney's name comes up, I gather that it is no longer the practice to teach Tawney in high school and this is the second register in which this work should be read: as simply a wonderful introduction to Tawney's thought. One does not need to be a virtuoso of Tawney scholarship or as concerned as our authors are with making the case for an emergent secular strain in Tawney's writing in order to profit from this encounter with the world of Tawney's thinking, analysis, and moral vision. Any work that increases the public's familiarity with Tawney's writings and that may push people to read his own books (which are liberally quoted in this study) is to be welcomed.
The authors review the trajectory of Tawney's political vision, beginning with his Commonplace Book (1912–1914) through his more topical political writings: his sustained critiques of capitalism in The Acquisitive Society (1921), his historical analysis of capitalism, Religion and the Rise of Capitalism (1926), and his more explicitly political writings of the 1940s and 1950s. Throughout, their aim is to argue for the decreasing importance of any Christian moral vision or nexus to his writings, for an emergent secular or in their terms “humanist” understanding of rights and political equality not rooted in a Christian worldview. At times they seem to overstate their case and, in making their argument, seem to impose distinctions and divisions in the trajectory of Tawney's thought that feel foreign to the felt experience of reading Tawney's prose. At times such reading borders on the tendentious. Thus, Tawney's book The Attack (1953), which was published less than ten years before he died, did indeed contain earlier essays from the 1920s and is discussed in this context by our authors. They, however, totally disregard the strong religious or spiritual elements to be found in this work—most especially the importance of Christian fellowship as the basis of equality and ethical action. The authors are at some pains to argue for the changing nature—perhaps in their view, maturation—of Tawney's thought over the decades of his life with the religious aspects playing an ever decreasing role. Doubtless, most people's thought grows and changes over time and the circumstances of life, but equally, some threads and concerns remain constant, if with changing hues and emphases.
It is not clear why the authors do so much to protest Tawney's emergent secularism. One almost feels it reflects current political concerns and conflicts much more than those of the first half of the twentieth century. We are today caught in a world where the religious and secular roots of action, morality, and understanding are thought to be antithetical, as ultimate contradictions. This was not always so. It certainly was not so of the world inhabited by the likes of Tawney, Hugh Gaitskell (leader of the Labour party), and Archbishop Temple. I thus very much doubt that Tawney or many of his contemporary readers would have appreciated or even understood the importance of this distinction that our authors make so much of. I must admit that I do not.
There can be little doubt that over the course of his political life and engagement as well as his scholarly writings and topical interventions the driving force for Tawney was a concern with moral fellowship and the ethical obligations of collective life. It is this that lends such glory to his prose and this that continues to engage us today and that makes of him a moral force to be reckoned with. Whether this concern is to be understood in explicitly Christian terms, or in a broader, more humanist framework, almost seems beside the point. Whether Christianity is a “driving force” or just a “convenient framework” for Tawney's critique of capitalism (89) seems to miss the point—that of a sustained critique of those forces that undermine and destroy the fellowship of human community. It is for the moral force of this critique that we should continue to turn to Tawney's writings to gain an appreciation not of his stature, but of our obligations.
