The subtitle of MacLeod's magnificent volume is a clue that this huge book of roughly a quarter of a million words and weighing over two kilogrammes is more than a biography of a little-known Anglo-Australian chemist and mineralogist, but a major study of the emergence of Australian science under the imperial watch of Great Britain from the 1850s to the 1930s.
Biographies are notoriously difficult to get published unless the protagonist is from the first eleven that includes Galileo, Newton, Darwin and Einstein. And yet it is from the lives of the reserves who did not show extraordinary originality that historians of science can learn most. Liversidge's career dramatically underlines this point. Born in London in 1846, the son of an up-and-coming carriage-maker, Liversidge was able to benefit from the recent creation of educational facilities that enabled bright working- and lower-middle-class students to enter upon scientific and technical careers. In Liversidge's case, attendance at evening classes at the City of London College in 1864 brought him a scholarship to the Royal School of Mines (RSM) in 1867, where his teachers included Edward Frankland (in the incorporated Royal College of Chemistry), Andrew Ramsay, Warrington Smyth, T.H. Huxley, John Tyndall and John Percy. The school's teachers and curriculum made an enormous impression upon him and propelled his interests towards mineralogy and mining.
By 1870, when Liversidge graduated from the RSM, the University of Cambridge was at the cusp of reforms related to the natural sciences that included the provision of open scholarships. Liversidge was awarded one of these at Christ's College and embarked upon the Natural Science Tripos. Given the practical skills and knowledge he had already acquired at the RSM, and that he had already begun to publish articles on the phenomenon of supersaturated solutions, he was picked out for special attention by the chemist George Liveing (from whom he learned how to run a laboratory) and the physiologist Michael Foster (who showed him how to be a ‘statesman’ of science). Liversidge never took his degree because, after only six terms, he was recruited to teach geology, mineralogy and chemistry at the University of Sydney in the Australian colony of New South Wales (NSW). In this way, in 1872, he became a ‘moving metropolis’ (a metaphor that MacLeod first coined in 1982), transposing, transmitting and adapting the ideals and practices of British scientific institutions and educational facilities (and particularly those of the RSM and Cambridge) to the conditions of a remote British colony.
The bulk of MacLeod's impressive study is concerned with Liversidge's successes and frustrations in transforming the underendowed University of Sydney (founded 1852) into a scientific and technical institution. It also provides a detailed analytical account of his many contributions to the public science of Sydney and of NSW as a whole. His successes, doggedly achieved, and influenced by British models, were impressive: the transformation of the ailing Royal Society of NSW (founded 1850) into a thriving learned society, and an influential report on British and European technical education in 1880 that led (after much agitation from Liversidge) to the rehabilitation of the Mechanics' Institution into a Technical College (now the University of NSW) and the opening in 1893 of the Technological, Industrial and Sanitary Museum (now the iconic Powerhouse Museum). In 1892, after frustrating struggles with the Senate and his professorial colleagues over the appropriate amount of science teaching in the BA curriculum, he founded a Science Faculty (whose dean he became), and with it a School of Mines. His efforts to federalize scientists in Australia, New Zealand and Great Britain were untiring. Liversidge was the founding father of the Australian Association for the Advancement of Science in 1888 and the creator of a NSW section of the Society of Chemical Industry in 1902. It is small wonder that this unselfish and shy practical idealist was described by a colleague as ‘the greatest organiser of science that Australia has seen’ (p. 433). Given all these public activities that were so important in making Sydney a science city, Liversidge's own researches, chiefly in the mineralogy of gold, suffered by comparison. Promoted to a chair of chemistry and mineralogy in 1882, by 1905 he was clearly exhausted; his youthful stammer returned and students (as they will) began to torment him in lectures. It was time to leave the country he had given devoted service to in the interests of a greater Britain.
A lifelong bachelor, in 1907 Liversidge returned to London, where he engaged in independent research at the Davy-Faraday laboratories; joined innumerable committees of the Chemical Society, Institute of Chemistry and the British Science Guild; and worked on magnesium alloys as part of the war effort. He died in 1927 a rich man, leaving many bequests in both the United Kingdom and Australia. The annual Liversidge Lectureship of the Royal Society of Chemistry is one of the ways his name has been kept alive, though it is doubtful whether the lecturers appointed could identify any of Liversidge's scientific contributions. MacLeod, however, sees him as a pioneer of geochemistry and plausibly identifies this obscurity as due to the fact that mineralogical chemistry became lost to chemists and was taken over by geologists at the end of the nineteenth century.
MacLeod himself has been a ‘moving metropolis’. As the two-page citation of his own publications in the book's bibliography demonstrates, the biography draws deeply on the influential research he has conducted on three continents during the past forty years. It enables him to illuminate every aspect of Liversidge's education and career with impressive authority in limpid prose packed with memorable metaphors and literary allusions. An abundance of interesting illustrations is elegantly housed within the text and nearly a third of the book is devoted to appendices, references, bibliographies and the index. Liversidge deserves to be studied not only as an outstanding biography of a man who devoted his life to public science, but also for its powerful demonstration of how Australia came of age and independence.
