Salsa Rising: New York Latin Music of the Sixties Generation is the final manuscript authored by Juan Flores (1943–2014). Published posthumously, this book is as much an important contribution to scholarship on Latin popular music of the United States as it is a portrait of the historical context during which the author transformed himself from a scholar of German literature to one of the founding scholars of Puerto Rican, Latin@, and Afro-Latin@ studies. I ask the reader to allow me the opportunity to present this review as a dedication to one of my beloved mentors. I met Professor Flores in the late 1990s while I was a graduate student in the ethnomusicology program at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York; he taught in the Department of Sociology at CUNY. Flores later went to New York University where he was a professor of social and cultural analysis. For those of us studying Cuban, Puerto Rican, and Latin@ popular music and culture in graduate school in the 1990s, the name Juan Flores was exciting! He was a Latino scholar whose work was must read, work that was deep in its cultural analysis, and most of all work that theorized Latin@ cultural expression as unique to the United States, neither watered-down versions of our parents’ home cultures nor assimilated manifestations of American culture. For me, two of his essays in particular took precedence among his many publications at the time. In “Cortijo's Revenge: New Mappings of Puerto Rican Culture” Flores critiques the racial and cultural hierarchies that determined nationalist discourse in Latin America, in this instance, black culture in Puerto Rico. Originally published in 1991 and later included in his edited volume, Divided Borders: Essays on Puerto Rican Identity, this essay anticipated the questions that scholars today such as Petra R. Rivera-Rideau continue to research and assess.Footnote 1 Then, there is his essay “‘Qué assimilated, brother, yo soy asimilao’: The Structuring of Puerto Rican Identity in the U.S.,” which gave scholarly voice to Latin@ experiences and sensibilities of the United States.Footnote 2 Latin@ history and culture would remain at the forefront of his teaching and scholarship to include in his crafting of his final manuscript Salsa Rising.
Juan Flores's presentation of the emergence of salsa music in New York in Salsa Rising is compelling for his uncanny synthesis of scholarly rigor with a personal intimacy of the subject matter. The central concern of the book is the unwieldy term “salsa” itself. He engages with this term by placing it in its historical context, 1960–75, and untangling its multiple cultural referents as these unfolded among the music's makers and audiences in the Latin neighborhoods of El Barrio and the Bronx and in the dancehalls of Manhattan. What makes his presentation of this history accessible and fresh is his understanding of salsa not merely as a musical style but rather as a “generation, the cultural voice and spirit of a historical span of time marked off by an initial collective inspiration and shared socio-historical experience…” (xvii). Though the scholarship on salsa is broad in its disciplinary and methodological scope, Salsa Rising is surprisingly the first manuscript by an academic that focuses on its emergence in New York. The book is much more than a historical account, however; it takes salsa's moments of shifts and transitions “from one stylistic temper to another” (xix) as its analytical entry points to study how and why this generation of Latin@s and their African American and Anglo American bandmates and dance partners forged a distinctive cultural voice and expressive modality that would eventually become a profitable market for the budding world music industry. Indeed, Flores's decision to focus on these shifts and transitions lends the book a biographical reading of sorts, unintentional though it may have been by the author. For it is precisely 1975, the culmination of Flores's study of the salsa generation, that also marked the culmination of his own radical politics and thus his move from Stanford University, where he taught German studies from 1970 to 1975, to Hunter College, where he would help develop its Latino studies curriculum.Footnote 3
Flores centers the book's narrative on the tensions exhibited among the music's key figures as they negotiated their careers as musicians, bandleaders, recording artists, and record label owners. At stake was the forging of a musical movement that would lend voice to the ethnic and racial pride, economic challenges, and political realities shaping the lives of Latin@s living in New York City and beyond in the 1960s and early 1970s. With economic disenfranchisement, civil rights, and Cold War politics in the forefront of their lives, young Latin@s in New York transformed their socially and culturally marginalized conditions into self-expressions of latinidad, drawing inspiration in varying degrees from the music cultures of their parents’ home islands, namely, Puerto Rico and Cuba, and of their African American neighbors and musician idols. For Flores, the musical motivations for these musicians’ maneuverings emerged largely from their respective statuses within and around Fania Records, the independent record label which had cornered the salsa recording industry by the early 1970s. Thus, Flores assesses the artistic, performance, and recording careers of Eddie Palmieri, Johnny Pacheco, Ray Barretto, the Alegre All-Stars, Barry Rogers, the Lebrón Brothers, Joe Bataan, Willie Colón, Fania All-Stars, and many others, taking as his primary task the delineation of those musicians who rehashed Cuban popular dance music of the previous generation from those who forged original musical expressions from within the liminality of what Flores conceives as the “Island-diaspora” continuum.
Flores supports his assessments of these musicians based on extensive interviews that he conducted with those who are still living, their bandmates, industry figures, and historians, often providing new insight into each musician's career trajectory. He also adroitly engages with the musical and lyrical content of much of their recorded output from this period, contextualizing his close readings of the music within the emergent Nuyorican reality of this sixties generation. Of Colón's significance in this regard, Flores concludes: “Willie Colón's eclectic but remarkably coherent body of early recorded work … did more than any equivalent output to set the tone for the ascendant ‘salsa’ sound” (146). Flores's treatment of Eddie Palmieri's artistic output, however, outweighs that of the book's other case studies, namely because of the resistance Palmieri explicitly expressed at the time in his musical and career choices toward Fania Records’ growing control over the market. Perhaps the book's most engaging moments are Flores's discussion of Palmieri's mentorship under intellectual and musician Bob Bianco. Under Bianco, for example, Palmieri studied the Schillinger system of musical composition, and we learn that he also attended classes in socioeconomic analysis at the Henry George School in Manhattan, where Bianco taught evening courses. Palmieri's political philosophy, Flores states, also “seemed to be in line with the politics of the Young Lords Party and other radical movements of the day, with which he felt an affinity and solidarity” (162). It is with this insight that Flores then unpacks the musical and political significances of Palmieri's most commercially and artistically successful albums which he recorded between 1968 and 1975. They include Justicia, Superimposition, Vamonos Pa'l Monte, Harlem River Drive, Live at Sing Sing, Sentido, and The Sun of Latin Music, none of which was recorded with Fania Records.
Soon after he joined the German Studies Department at Stanford University in 1970, Juan Flores published his book Poetry in East Germany: Adjustments, Visions, and Provocations, 1945–1970.Footnote 4 As the title suggests, Flores had already dedicated himself to the study of artistic expression and its political implications; even his first book's historical scope intersected with that of which would be his final book, Salsa Rising. In our many conversations, the last of which took place in Havana where we participated in Casa de las Américas's Coloquio Latinos en las Artes y las Letras in October 2013, Juan retold the story of his leaving Stanford to reinvent his career as a scholar and teacher of Puerto Rican studies in New York. But he more often spoke of his research on Eddie Palmieri and the music that he believed was the most potently resonant cultural artifact of this generation of Latin@s, that is, his generation. Flores's generation, indeed, reinvented themselves out of purpose and necessity without, however, eschewing the cultures of their parents or that of their fellow marginalized and oppressed friends and colleagues. Flores and the many other founders of Latin@/Afro-Latin@/Latinx studies helped forge paths for those of us to follow, paths that are more than ever under attack from all quarters of the academic political economy at the local, state, and federal levels. And there is no doubt that Salsa Rising and all of their work and professional risk taking will continue to point us in the right directions to secure and build on what they helped create. Gracias, Profe, for all that you gave us!
