Islamic Art in Oman is a collection of essays of considerable interest, some of which address entirely new ground. The volume reflects the interest in cultural heritage which has been a feature of all of the states of Arabia in recent years and which has been particularly marked in the Sultanate of Oman.
The work presented in Islamic Art in Oman underlines the distinctiveness of the Sultanate's culture, with its contrast between the self-contained mountainous interior and the outward facing coastal areas.
One of the least known aspects of Oman's Islamic arts of the past is addressed by Salimi and Faysal al-Hafiyan in their account of “Omani Quranic Manuscripts” (pp. 106–117) which enters onto a virtually unstudied field. The authors frankly admit the difficulty that they have had in compiling their research for the lack of textual reference that they have at their disposal—academic or otherwise. They recount how the Ministry of Heritage and Culture has gathered about 156 MSS so far and they regard the present publication as an opportunity to appeal for gathering together many more of the scattered MSS of the Holy Quran of Omani origin. An established major collection is the library of Seyyid Mohammad bin Ahmad Al Busaidi.
As the authors demonstrate, the material collected so far is new to scholarship, being an entirely unconsidered area in past Quranic studies and deserving much future research. They emphasise that there was no tradition of professional scribes in the country although this may need further explanation and refinement in order to assess the lineage of such distinctive Omani Quran illumination as they record.
Given the distinctiveness of the extant Omani Qurans from the twelfth/eighteenth century onwards it does not seem a very fruitful line of enquiry to consider them in the context of the familiar great traditions of ‘Iraq, Iran, Egypt or the Ottomans. The distance in time and in style of the Omani Qurans is so great from these familiar classic Islamic traditions of Quran design that we are better advised initially to address Omani Qurans in their own terms. It is also more fruitful to see these Qurans in the context of Oman's known range of contacts within Arabia and the shores of the Indian Ocean and with other Ibadhi communities beyond Oman.
Salimi and Faysal al-Hafiyan demonstrate the importance of an indigenous Qur'an tradition associated with known figures including Salama b. Muslim al-Awtabi al-Suhari and Abu Muhammad Abdallah b. Muhammad al-Azdi al-Suhari.
The mode of composition of these Qurans, as a group, is very distinctive; the use of black ink prevails but red is also used for the script. Red also prevails as the colour used extensively in block filling and decoration. This is unusual in Islamic religious art. Gold is used but generally to only a limited degree.
The preferred script is a conservative, solid Naskhi which the authors note sometimes has affinities with Indian Arabic scripts. The preference for Naskhi is to persist as a “chancery” script in the Arabian Gulf area in later times: see, for example a letter addressed to the Shaykh of Abu Dhabi, Zayed I b. Salih b. ‘Ali, dated to 12 Safar, 1313/4th August 1895Footnote 1 although the Omani Qurans are far more controlled as befits religious works written in piety.
The authors refer to an early Quran written by Muhammad b. Khalaf b. Salih al-Simawi who worked for Imam Sayf b. Malik al-Ya'rubi and which was completed on 26th Shaban, 1127/1715 at Mombasa. In its squared format, the Mombasa Quran is very disturbing. All the other Omani Qurans recorded by Salimi and Faysal al-Hafiyan have a vertical format which is generally preferred after the early Islamic period. By contrast, the squared format is extremely ancient, preserved only in Islamic Spain but one hesitates to draw any conclusion from this at this stage of research with respect to the Mombasa Quran.
We know little about the east African Quran writing tradition other than it was diverse, as is shown by a possibly nineteenth-century Quran from Western Sudan in the Khalili CollectionFootnote 2 and its differences compared to the Mombasa Quran.
Ruba Kanaan's chapter on the carved plaster mihrabs of Oman is based on her field survey of 2001. In a well argued discussion, she breaks out of the standard framework of perception of Omani mihrabs that associates them with the Samarra’ tradition of plaster carving and the well-recorded early mihrab tradition of Iran. The proximity of Iran and its sequence of impressive carved plaster mihrabs from the late tenth century onwards is a tempting source for the Oman tradition but as Ruba Kanaan argues, the matter is more complex.
There is indeed evidence of ceramics and other factors used in early mihrabs and mosques in Oman, seemingly derived from ‘Iraqi and Iranian influence, but she sees an imaginative and indigenous development in mihrab design taking place in the late fifteenth to sixteenth centuries.
She categorises the main types of plaster carved mihrabs in Oman in the late fifteenth to sixteenth centuries on the basis of form. The mihrabs which are flat and with a central recess set in the thickness of the wall she associates with the Ibadhi hinterland of the Jabal al-Akhdar. This grouping she applies to decorated and undecorated mihrabs alike. She notes that she has located no observation in Ibadhi fiqh on the issue of mihrab design, but it may well be that architecture in all Islamic traditions is preserved by customary practice, rather than by legally defined prescription.
The mihrab type which projects on the exterior of the qibla wall she associates with the Sunni areas on the Omani coast. This distinction makes sense, for in the Sunni communities of the Gulf coast to the north in Ra's al-Khayma and Abu Dhabi, a projecting mihrab is a standard feature of mosques. This can be seen in mosques as widely distributed as those at Bukha in Musandam in northern Oman, in Ra's al-Khayma and on Dalma island in Abu Dhabi, in the United Arab Emirates.Footnote 3 Inland, in Saudi Arabia, projecting mihrabs are standard from the ca eighth century, with the earliest example at al-Rabadha on the Darb Zubayda pilgrim route, east of al-Madina al-Munuwarra.Footnote 4
Ruba Kanaan identifies several key named figures working in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries on the monumental carved plaster mihrabs of the Ibadhi interior. She argues convincingly that these craftsmen were a part of an internal development within the realms of Omani craftsmanship rather than stemming from any outside influence. The craftsmen were sufficiently respected to be named in the mihrab inscriptions. Outstanding among these, she cites a well-known local master plaster, ‘Abdullah b. Qasim b. Muhammad al-Humaymi of the early sixteenth century and subsequently, she notes the work of another master, Mashmal and of his family, the latter responsible collectively for at least nine mihrabs extending from 923/1517 to 1068/1658 (pp. 247–249).
Rather than the past emphasis on Iran she rightly notes the westward connections of the mihrabs of Oman with those to the west in Yemen, of the Sulayhid and the Ayyubid and Rasulid period.
This point is also picked up in an essay in Islamic Art in Oman by Lorenz Korn who argues that certain aspects of the Omani mosque tradition should be seen as extending along the south Arabian coast to Yemen.
Heinz Gaube's chapter contributes to the superb tradition of Omani woodworking, which was the finest in the Gulf, unsurpassed elsewhere. As with so much else in Omani art and architecture, it should be considered with its cousin traditions in east Africa.
Birget Mershen discusses jewellery and weapons production and its embellishment, a skill at its finest, of course, in the khanajir, the most emblematic weapons of Oman. Her research on jewellery, especially silver, reflects the degree to which Oman has continued to be a producer of such work until very recent times. Fortunately, fine examples were collected by the Museum of the Ministry Heritage and Culture before these skills started to fade away with modernity.
Some of the jewellery published is magical, a strongly established aspect of Oman's culture. This is clearly the case with a piece with a shackled female demon while other jewellery was designed to hold talismanic scripts.
Seth Priestman summarises the regional ceramics of Oman, a complex subject. Distinguishing glazed Bahla ware from Oman, for example, from Khunj ware from the Iranian side of the Gulf is a particularly difficult task. As to the Omani production of unglazed wares, they have great regional variation. As in so much else in the crafts of Oman, some ceramic traditions persisted until recent times, especially in the more remote areas. Thus, ceramic manufacture flourished still at Lima in Musandam in 2003 as this reviewer saw, one of the last survivals into the present century of the Omani indigenous ceramic tradition.Footnote 5
As to the production of this sumptuously illustrated volume, the only point of criticism is the lack of numbered plates. This makes it difficult for the reader to correlate text and illustration, an important issue in a book whose force depends so much on illustrations. However, this is a minor point of criticism for an important book that summarises well the current state of knowledge of the Sultanate of Oman's rich cultural heritage.
