Modernizing Yazd is a valuable contribution to the literature of Iranian architectural studies. It is also valuable as a case study for architectural preservationists and scholars interested in urban transformations and the issues resulting from an ever-expanding modern population in a city with a complex past. At the start, Modarres reminds the reader that the planning and architecture of cities is an expression of cultural values, nationalism, power, and identity. These elements are examined as he methodically traces successive waves of construction, destruction, and transformation of built form in Yazd, the most dramatic of which happened in the 20th century. In doing so, Modarres raises questions about place, identity, and urban-planning practices in historical cities. His work is an example of how to decode cities transformed by waves of wholesale or selective destruction, modernization, and massive infill.
The principal thesis of Modernizing Yazd is that connections can be drawn between sociopolitical conditions and the preservation or transformation of space. Yazd demonstrates this well because of a history that includes minority communities that have been dissolving as a result of middle to late 20th-century transformations. Modarres discusses the loss of local identity through willful destruction. He also traces how deliberate transformations through the elimination of built form, new construction in strategic locations, and neglectful decay are among the strategies employed to construct a new “imagined” past, reinforce a particular identity, or construct a new identity.
The author identifies outside influences too. Much of the destruction and transformation, such as development directives with a nationalist agenda, came from Tehran and land-use planning practices from the West. He acknowledges that, in the recent past, some architecturally significant houses in the historic core have been adapted, reused, or restored, but the larger picture that this book paints is the loss of place, neighborhood, and memory.
The first chapter is a useful introduction for those unfamiliar with the history of Iran. It lays the foundation of the book's discussion of the relationships in Yazd between identity and political agendas and Iranian architecture, landscape, and urban design. Newcomers to the history of Iran would benefit from an organization of chapters that followed a more linear time line instead of this book's thematic organization that jumps back and forth in time, chapter by chapter.
The author uses a variety of sound secondary sources, from urban morphology to political histories of Iran, as well as census data, maps, and photographs to trace the transformations of Yazd. The compilation of data from these multiple sources clearly documents the shift of the population from the older sections of the city, and it shows that this shift was in part a result of government intervention, including the construction of both a hospital and city hall in the southern section of the city. Through such shifts, parts of the periphery became the center as urban institutions anchored these new centers.
Modarres has ample evidence to demonstrate that some of the loss of historic vernacular architecture of Yazd is due to both urban growth and the shift away from the center. Yazd today is more than five times larger than it was in the 1950s. This change was incredibly rapid, considering that prior to the 1950s the population of Yazd had hardly grown since the 1800s. With such sudden growth it is not surprising that parts of the historic city were lost, even without government policy helping things along. Although these recent transformations are the focus of much of this study, the value of this book is not merely in the documentation of these changes, but also in the context that Modarres presents, reminding the reader that transformations were coincident with population increases, a dramatic rise in literacy rates, and an improved economy.
Modarres's background in landscape architecture is evident throughout. His sensitivity to the importance of landscape and neighborhood helps to make a case for the preservation of the ordinary, the vernacular that creates a sense of place. His grounding in this discipline is evident in his focus on neighborhoods rather than monuments, on meaning rather than particular icons, and on culture and shared history as what should be prized. Although preservation efforts are sometimes focused on saving a particular building or monument, this study provides an argument that it is the whole delicate fabric of a neighborhood, district, or city that should be the concern of both residents and preservationists. The argument is strengthened through his documentation of the urban morphology of the early period of Yazd's history, overlaid with a description of newer neighborhoods.
For libraries that are interested in expanding their collections on preservation, landscape architecture, and the literature of urban morphology, this book is an accessible case study and a good model for other case-study research. It is also a good reference for people seeking to understand the struggles of historic cities in the modern world. As the worldview of a nation or a region changes, the agenda for preservation changes. The author clearly identifies various economic, cultural, and governmental milestones that lead to shifts in the preservation or modernization agenda. In this case, establishing connections with the Sassanid and Achaemenid empires became an important agenda for Iran after 1925, and the focus shifted once again with a shift in government and its agenda. Major transformations documented in this volume include industrialization after a factory opened in Yazd in 1931. As in many other historic cities, there was a huge impact on the old city with the introduction of large streets in the 1930s and 1940s.
Political milestones that are also physical ones include the introduction of the broad Pahlavi Street (now Imam Khomeini Street) that disrupted the delicate urban fabric developed over more than 1,000 years. This and other interventions of modern urbanization had the effect of removing sections of the bazaar and an 11th-century gate through the old city walls. This destruction was just one tear in the urban fabric that can make a city unrecognizable.
From the outset, Modarres discusses the importance of looking at provincial cities, such as Yazd, as a way to widen the focal lens of urban research beyond that of capitals. As government centers, capital cities have the closest contact to foreign influences. Yazd and other provincial cities are therefore examples of secondhand foreign influence, which has been channeled through the capital. Filtered influence is less studied, adding to the value of this work.
The book's main problem lies in its graphics. For someone who has not been to Yazd, the images in this book will not provide a clear sense of the architecture or the city. Demolished housing blocks and photos of the old city wall peeking through newer construction provide a sense of what was lost, but images of more notable architecture suffer from low-contrast photos that do not do the buildings justice. Although a few of the valuable and carefully drawn maps are annoyingly blurry, the many maps at different scales give the reader a good idea of boundary changes, including the location of city walls at different periods. Also, through maps, additions and expansions to the road system as well as neighborhood expansion beyond the early city boundaries can be clearly understood. The maps illustrate the location of the old city walls and the urban development beyond them, providing a snapshot of growth and change, particularly the construction to the south of the old city.
The emphasis in this book is on the destruction of the delicate texture and scale of neighborhoods with their respective distinct characters. Their alarming fragility is underscored by documentation of how quickly destruction can occur. Although the transformations are signs of economic success (whether only aspired to, imagined, or actually achieved), the study implies that other elements are also at work when such transformations erode the physical culture of a place.
