Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T23:50:35.274Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Reynolds number scaling in cryogenic turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection in a cylindrical aspect ratio one cell

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 October 2017

Věra Musilová*
Affiliation:
The Czech Academy of Sciences, Institute of Scientific Instruments, Královopolská 147, Brno, Czech Republic
Tomáš Králík
Affiliation:
The Czech Academy of Sciences, Institute of Scientific Instruments, Královopolská 147, Brno, Czech Republic
Marco La Mantia
Affiliation:
Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Charles University, Ke Karlovu 3, 121 16 Prague, Czech Republic
Michal Macek
Affiliation:
The Czech Academy of Sciences, Institute of Scientific Instruments, Královopolská 147, Brno, Czech Republic
Pavel Urban
Affiliation:
The Czech Academy of Sciences, Institute of Scientific Instruments, Královopolská 147, Brno, Czech Republic
Ladislav Skrbek
Affiliation:
Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Charles University, Ke Karlovu 3, 121 16 Prague, Czech Republic
*
†Email address for correspondence: vera@isibrno.cz

Abstract

We perform an experimental study of turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection up to very high Rayleigh number, $10^{8}<Ra<10^{14}$ , in a cylindrical aspect ratio one cell, 30 cm in height, filled with cryogenic helium gas. We monitor temperature fluctuations in the convective flow with four small (0.2 mm) sensors positioned in pairs 1.5 cm from the sidewalls and 2.5 cm vertically apart and symmetrically around the mid-height of the cell. Based on one-point and two-point correlations of the temperature fluctuations, we determine different types of Reynolds numbers, $\mathit{Re}$ , associated with the large-scale circulation (LSC). We observe a transition between two types of $\mathit{Re}(\mathit{Ra})$ scaling around $\mathit{Ra}=10^{10}{-}10^{11}$ , which is accompanied by a scaling change of the skewness of the probability distribution functions (PDFs) of the temperature fluctuations. The $\mathit{Re}(\mathit{Ra})$ dependencies measured near the sidewall at Prandtl number $\mathit{Pr}\sim 1$ are consistent with the $\mathit{Ra}^{4/9}\mathit{Pr}^{-2/3}$ scaling above the transition, while for $\mathit{Ra}<10^{10}$ , the $\mathit{Re}(\mathit{Ra})$ dependencies are steeper. It seems likely that this change in $\mathit{Re}(\mathit{Ra})$ scaling is linked to the previously reported change in the Nusselt number $\mathit{Nu}(\mathit{Ra})$ scaling. This behaviour is in agreement with independent cryogenic laboratory experiments with $\mathit{Pr}\sim 1$ , but markedly different from the $\mathit{Re}$  scaling obtained in water experiments ( $\mathit{Pr}\sim 3.3{-}5.6$ ). We discuss the results in comparison with different versions of the Grossmann–Lohse theory.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2017 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Scheme of the apparatus. (a) Inner part of helium cryostat (Urban et al.2010) containing the cylindrical aspect ratio one RBC cell. Four small Ge temperature sensors (named T1–T4) measure temperature fluctuations in the fluid at opposite sides in the cell interior. Temperatures of the top ($T_{t}$) and bottom ($T_{b}$) plates are measured by four additional temperature sensors embedded in the centre and near the edge of both plates. The top plate temperature is stabilized. Temperature of the vent lines near the cell is controlled with electrical heaters to suppress potential effect of convection inside the lines. (b) Scheme of the azimuthal positions of vent lines, filling tube and sensors in the cell with respect to the cardinal points as seen from top. Small red and blue circles show the prevailing flow direction (warm and cold stream, respectively) observed with the sensors.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Temperature fluctuations (in arbitrary units) recorded using sensor T3 (a). Panel (b) zooms into a detail of the time record. We can see here a typical short-time reversal of the temperature spikes, i.e. sign changes of the large fluctuation bunches with respect to the mean signal $R_{m}$, from prevalent (for T3) positive deviations to negative deviations (see time period between $t=3600$ and 3670). These were detected at all investigated $\mathit{Ra}$, with an overall occurrence of approximately 10 % of time.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Probability density functions (PDFs) of temperature fluctuations $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FF}T$ as measured by all sensors. The sensor positions are shown in (b) together with the prevailing LSC direction. PDFs obtained with the sensors at opposite side of the RBC cell display opposite skewness (T1, T2 versus T3, T4), so we reversed the temperature scale in the PDF plots for T3 and T4 to highlight the symmetry. $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70E}_{T}$ stands for the standard temperature deviation. Slight difference between PDFs of the leading sensors (T1 and T3), facing the LSC flow on one hand, and the trailing sensors (T2 and T4) on the other hand can be seen, while members of each pair show mutually almost identical PDFs.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Skewness ($M_{3}$) and flatness ($M_{4}$) of temperature fluctuation PDFs. Sensors T1 and T3 are the ‘leading sensors’ facing the mean LSC flow, while T2 and T4 are ‘hidden’ behind them, and are thus called ‘trailing sensors’. The values at high end of $\mathit{Ra}>10^{12}$ are influenced by lower signal to noise ratio of temperature signals in the experimental run ‘c’.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Temperature fluctuation PDFs recorded for various $\mathit{Ra}$ compared between leading (a) and trailing sensors (b). Data from T1 and T2 are shown. Notice the relatively lower skewness of the trailing sensor PDF at the lowest value of $\mathit{Ra}$, clearly distinct from the same sensor PDF at high $\mathit{Ra}$ and all the leading sensor PDFs, which depend on $\mathit{Ra}$ only weakly, in particular their skewness is practically constant (cf. figure 4).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Standard deviation of temperature fluctuations $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70E}_{T}/\unicode[STIX]{x0394}T$, normalized by the temperature difference between the bottom and top plate, and compensated by $\mathit{Ra}^{-1/7}$. Our data, measured near the sidewall, are compared with the results of Castaing et al. (1989), measured midway between the sidewall and the centre and Niemela et al. (2000), measured at the cell centre, and the data point by He et al. (2014a) near the wall in an $SF_{6}$ experiment.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) The auto-correlation functions (AC) together with the cross-correlation function (CC) of temperature fluctuation signals recorded by sensors at opposite sides of the RBC cell. The time $T_{0}$ derived from the positions of first side maxima corresponds to the main peak frequency $f_{0}=1/T_{0}$ in the power spectra. (b,c) Power spectra of temperature fluctuations at mid-plane near the sidewall in $2^{\circ }$ tilted water sample obtained by Xi et al. (2009) at azimuthal position $0^{\circ }$ (LSC plane) together with $45^{\circ }$ and $90^{\circ }$ from LSC plane ($\mathit{Pr}=5.3$, $Ra=5\times 10^{9}$) (b) and by Niemela et al. (2001) ($\mathit{Pr}=0.8$, $Ra=1.5\times 10^{11}$), Qiu & Tong (2002) ($\mathit{Pr}=5.5$, $Ra=1.4\times 10^{9}$) and measured by us (marked as ‘Brno’) for $\mathit{Pr}\sim 1$ and $\mathit{Ra}$ as indicated (c). Dependencies compensated with respect to the background power spectra $S_{bg}$ are shown.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Auto-correlation function (red solid) of temperature fluctuations and cross-correlation function (black dashed) of time records at nearby sensors, distant by $d=2.5~\text{cm}$. Time delays $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{p}$ and $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{0}$ define velocities $U_{p}$, $U$, $V$ and $U_{eff}$ used in various definitions of Reynolds number (3.2)–(3.5). Time delay $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{p}$ between signals at positions distant by $d$ relates to the Taylor hypothesis-based mean flow velocity $U_{p}=d/\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{p}$. The figure is a zoom into the AC and CC functions shown in figure 7(a).

Figure 8

Figure 9.Prandtl (a) and Reynolds numbers (b–d) in cryogenic helium and pressurized $SF_{6}$ experiments: our results (Brno) are compared with data obtained in the aspect ratio one cell of Castaing et al. (1989), Niemela et al. (2001), He et al. (2015) and aspect ratio $1/2$ of Chavanne et al. (2001). The Reynolds numbers $\mathit{Re}_{f0}$ (3.1), $\mathit{Re}_{p}$ (3.2) and the elliptic method based $\mathit{Re}_{U},\mathit{Re}_{V}$ and $\mathit{Re}_{eff}$ (3.3)–(3.5) are all compensated by the ${\sim}\mathit{Ra}^{4/9}\mathit{Pr}^{-2/3}$ dependence. The vertical lines indicate the values of $Ra_{c}$ (dashed) and the corresponding transition intervals (dotted) for $Re_{f0}$, $Re_{p}$ and $Re_{eff}$ (see text and table 1).

Figure 9

Figure 10.Comparison of our experimental values of $\mathit{Re}_{eff}$ with the Grossmann–Lohse theory in the original (Grossmann & Lohse 2001, 2002) and the updated (Stevens et al.2013) fits. The zoom-in, shown in (b) traces in detail the change of scaling associated with the $IV_{l}$–$IV_{u}$ transition predicted for helium data by the original fit, while no transition is seen in the updated fit, as it places the helium data fully into the $IV_{u}$ region in this $\mathit{Ra}$ range, cf. Stevens et al. (2013). The vertical lines in (b) relate to the Grossmann & Lohse (2002) curve, and their meaning is as in figure 9.

Figure 10

Table 1.Transitional values of $Ra_{c}$ for different types of Reynolds numbers with the scaling exponents $\unicode[STIX]{x1D701}=\unicode[STIX]{x1D701}_{L}$ corresponding to $Ra and $\unicode[STIX]{x1D701}=\unicode[STIX]{x1D701}_{R}$ corresponding to $Ra>Ra_{c}$. The Prandtl number dependence is assumed to be $Re\propto Pr^{-2/3}$ (see text).

Figure 11

Figure 11.Frequency Reynolds number versus $\mathit{Ra}$ measured in cryogenic helium (Brno – our data, Niemela et al.2001) and water experiments at $3.3<\mathit{Pr}<5.7$ (Qiu & Tong 2001a; Sun et al.2005; Brown et al.2007) compensated by $\mathit{Ra}^{4/9}\mathit{Pr}^{-2/3}$, as in figures 9 and 10.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Comparison of $(Nu-1)Ra/Pr^{2}$ between our data and other experiments, plotted against the frequency Reynolds number $\mathit{Re}_{f0}$. Solid blue squares correspond to the cryogenic helium data of Niemela et al. (2001) and Niemela & Sreenivasan (2003a). Crosses are data from water experiment by Brown et al. (2007). The dashed line represents the GL model fit by Stevens et al. (2013) for helium.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Values of reduced mean energy dissipation rate, $(Nu-1)Ra/Pr^{2}$, in dependence on frequency-based Reynolds number $\mathit{Re}_{f0}$ (a) and the ‘elliptic’ number $\mathit{Re}_{eff}$ (b). The solid line represents the original fit of the Grossmann–Lohse model (Grossmann & Lohse 2001, 2002), while the dashed line is the updated fit by Stevens et al. (2013).