In one of the essays in his new collection The Shipwrecked Mind: On Political Reaction, Mark Lilla tells of the remarkable coincidence that Michel Houellebecq's Submission, a novel about the Islamization of France, “appeared the very day of the Charlie Hebdo massacre.” Although Lilla does not manage quite that sort of simultaneity, something of the same sort of coincidence exists here, for his book appeared very near in time to the surprising political triumph of Donald Trump in the American elections of 2016. In this essay and others in the volume, Lilla attempts to deal with that form of political reaction that he sometimes calls “the politics of nostalgia,” one manifestation of which would be the now famous Make America Great Again slogan. Lilla does not speak of Trump or mention that slogan or focus particularly on the United States. Instead he develops his theme of a politics of nostalgia as a much larger phenomenon, if not worldwide then certainly widespread throughout the West. And beyond that, he presents an analysis of political Islam itself: “it is in the Muslim world that belief in a lost Golden Age is most potent and consequential today,” he tells us (140).
His brief analysis of Islamism as a particularly virulent form of the politics of nostalgia comes as an afterword, in part because most of the rest of the book dates from much before our current immersion in Trumpism. Like his earlier The Reckless Mind (New York Review of Books, 2001), the essays in The Shipwrecked Mind derive from articles—book reviews really—that he has published over the years in the New York Review of Books. Some of the essays/reviews hail from as far back as 2002, with only two written after 2012.
His two NYRB-derived books, as their titles suggest, are meant to be paired with the earlier Reckless Mind, taking up writers such as Martin Heidegger, Alexandre Kojève, and Michel Foucault, who either engaged in or encouraged a kind of philosophical revolutionary politics that, Lilla maintains, were irresponsible or reckless. In that book, he explored the political temptation of “tyrannophilia” which great minds sometimes (foolishly) succumb to. The authors he considers in the present volume, the “shipwrecked minds,” are disposed in quite the other direction: they are not looking forward to unheard-of new (dangerous) possibilities, but are disaffected from the way things are headed and instead look back to some better age from which we have somewhere declined. Thus his notion of a “politics of nostalgia.”
One cannot press the thesis too hard, however; for, like the earlier book, this one is a collection of only modestly revised previously published reviews. The books under discussion only retrospectively appear to fall into the category of “shipwrecked mind.” That is to say, not all parts contribute equally well to the ostensible theme of the book. Three of the essays, the oldest three, focus on individual thinkers—Franz Rosenzweig, Eric Voegelin, and Leo Strauss. These fit least well with the overall thesis. Perhaps the one that fits best is the essay on Brad Gregory's The Unintended Reformation: How a Religious Revolution Secularized Society (Belknap, 2012). Gregory, a Notre Dame historian, has assembled a huge (in bulk) critique of the decline of society from a kind of peak in the high Middle Ages to our much decayed modernity. Lilla captures the idea of the book nicely in the title for his essay: “From Luther to Walmart.” There is an essay on Alain Badiou's Saint Paul: The Foundation of Universalism (Stanford University Press, 2003), a book that looks back to Paul, but otherwise does not fit well Lilla's notion of a politics of nostalgia, for, as he describes Badiou's book, it calls “on the left to rediscover the radical universalism of Saint Paul and apply it to revolutionary politics” (82). Badiou actually fits better into the basket of the reckless. The last essay adapted from NYRB is the aforementioned review of Michel Houellebecq's Submission, together with some reflections on the Charlie Hebdo affair and on Islam in Europe today. The adapted essays are bookended by an introduction and an afterword, in which Lilla attempts more systematic explanation of his thesis.
Lilla has many virtues as a reviewer. His writing is lucid and engaging; he has a talent for setting the books under review into larger contexts that bring out the significance of the works. He is fair and usually sympathetic to his authors, but renders judgments about the meaning and quality of the works. (A partial exception is his review of Brad Gregory's book, where Lilla's pen is dipped more than usual in hot pepper sauce. Lilla is not particularly friendly to the kind of religion-inspired narrative Gregory has produced.) Lilla's virtues as a reviewer are manifest in this volume; a revealing instance is his review of Eric Voegelin, probably the least well-known of the authors Lilla engages here. As he usually does, Lilla gives a brief biographical sketch to set the works in the context of the life, in this case Voegelin's anti-Nazi writings and his subsequent appearance on Austrian Nazi enemies lists after the Anschluss of 1938. Fleeing to America, Voegelin began a multivolume series, Order and History, of which Lilla gives us a quick thumbnail but revealing sketch. Voegelin was widely known for his use of a heavily neologistic style, in which he stated his central thesis: modernity is the “immanentization of the eschaton.” Lilla renders this and other of Voegelin's obscurely expressed ideas in perfectly clear and normal English. One does not come away from his brief essay an expert on Voegelin, but one does come away with a good general idea of what he was about.
Voegelin was but one of Lilla's “shipwrecked minds.” The shipwrecked are, as Lilla paints them, reactionaries, “militants of nostalgia” (xiii). They are thinkers who no longer possess, if they ever did, an overarching narrative of history, as progress, regress, or cycle. Thinkers who do possess such a narrative posit some mechanism to explain the course of history and can, for better or worse, anticipate the future as possessing basic continuity, in terms of the mechanism of history, with the past. But the shipwrecked see history as nothing so smooth or predictable; instead they see it as having been punctuated by a cataclysm of some sort, unpredicted, unpredictable—and bad. “In response an apocalyptic view of history develops that sees a rip in time that widens with each passing year, distancing us from an age that was golden or heroic or simply normal. In this vision there is only one event in history, the kairos separating the world we were meant for from the world we must live in. That is all we can know, and must know, about the past” (136).
Lilla concedes that his account in this book “makes a very modest start… rather than a systematic treatise on the concept of reaction” (xiii–xiv). Even on a generous reading, one would have to agree with Lilla's self-assessment. Even the authors Lilla speaks of only questionably belong in his category of “the shipwrecked.” Neither Rosenzweig nor Strauss, to take two examples, drips with nostalgia for a lost golden age; neither despairs of a way forward. These are not thinkers waiting for the salvage ship to tow them off the reef on which they foundered. Of course, the elements that make up the book were not originally conceived as part of an exposition of reactionism and the new introduction and afterword do not go very far in developing an analysis of the phenomena of reaction and the politics of nostalgia. Nonetheless, The Shipwrecked Mind makes for a quick and provocative read, and offers suggestive interpretations of the thinkers and events Lilla discusses in it.
