No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
This is a genuinely interesting and useful analysis of the failed antecedents (approximately to 1938) of contemporary Kurdish nationalism as it largely played out in what became modern Turkey. Indeed, “Failed Antecedents of Contemporary Kurdish Nationalism” might have been a better title for the book.
More precisely, Martin Strohmeier is more concerned with the attempts to create Kurdish nationalism in this earlier period than with analyzing why these efforts seemingly failed. Thus, his treatise offers to English-only readers a wealth of material previously available only in scattered pieces.
Using short, pithy chapters, Strohmeier divides his work into three sections. Part 1 analyzes the attempts before World War I of aspiring Kurdish nationalists to awaken their would-be compatriots to their cause through newspapers. Part 2 deals with the Bedir Khan brothers' (Tureyya, Kamuran, and Celadet) development in the 1920s of a Kurdish movement in exile (mainly in Syria), the failure of their transnational Kurdish party Khoybun, and the negation of Kurdish nationalism by Sukru Mehmed Sekban. The third and final part analyzes a little-known novel (Der Adler [Eagle] von Kurdistan) co-written in the 1930s by Kamuran Bedir Khan, which failed to become a Kurdish national epic but does give valuable insights into what he saw as the characteristics of the imagined Kurdish nation. Throughout this book, there is much useful data about which a short review such as this can only suggest.
These early would-be Kurdish nationalists grappled with many problems, including the nature of the Kurdish relationship with the Turks and the primitive state of affairs in Kurdistan. “All Kurds were deeply if variously enmeshed in social, ideological, economic and personal relations with the Turks…. These bonds hampered the development of a self-assertive, robust and distinct Kurdish identity” (p. 54). In addition, the Kurdish “language was a shambles, not fit for education or literature; their culture was backward, and their history was a mystery” (p. 45). Furthermore, “a language-factor potentially more divisive than dialects was the problem presented by Turkish speakers among the Kurds” (p. 61).
Then, following World War I and the subsequent rush to create nation-states in the Middle East, the Kurds had no one to counter the appeal to Muslim loyalty of Mustafa Kemal (Ataturk). “Kurdish leaders such as Serif Pasha appeared to be traitors willing to sign away the fatherland to the Armenian enemies” (p. 70). “The making of their (Turkish) nation was to depend on the unmaking of any plans the Kurds had had for their own nation” (p. 84). In addition, by helping the Turks rid “the area of Armenians, the Kurds had unwittingly forfeited their historical status and value to the Turks as counterweights to the Armenians” (p. 87).
By contrast, Mem u Zin—the Kurdish national epic dating from the 17th century—“constitutes the backbone of the argument that Kurds are a nation capable of attaining a high level of civilization, and possessing a language which can yield great literature…. The epic lends itself astonishingly well to the exigencies of national identity building because of its many-faceted appeal to diverse groups in Kurdish society … and has become almost a ‘Declaration of Independence’ in Kurdish history” (p. 27).
Following the failure of the Shaykh Said and Ararat rebellions in the 1920s, the Bedir Khan brothers broke completely with their residual Turkish loyalties and sought to develop, with French support in Syria, a full-blown Kurdish nationalism. In Les Massacres Kurdes en Turquie and The Case of Kurdistan Against Turkey, “the Turks are portrayed as having pursued throughout the whole of their co-existence with the Kurds and other races the aims of extermination and assimilation…. The Turks, descendants of Attila and Jingiz Khan, are an unchanging entity, barbaric and evil by nature” (p. 104). Although “propagandistic in its simplistic, misleading, and distorted interpretations of Kurdish and Turkish history” (p. 111), “Tureyya's [Bedir Khan's] publications had a tremendous influence on later writings on the Kurds…. The statistics on deportations and losses contained in his booklets as well as his equally propagandist versions of historical events were integrated into many subsequent accounts of the Kurdish national struggle” (p. 114). However, Strohmeier concludes that, for “the progress of Kurdish identity-building as manifested in nationalist writing, we must regard Tureyya's publications as being of seminal importance” (pp. 100–101).
Part 3 deals with Der Adler von Kurdistan, a formalistic and forgotten attempt by Kamuran Bedir Khan to write a novel to project the Kurdish cause on the magnitude of Franz Werfel's classic The Forty Days of Musa Dagh for the Armenians. Strohmeier demonstrates how a close reading of this short book “reveals a unique and fascinating attempt to fashion an image of Kurdishness incorporating the entire panoply of the imagined Kurdish nation and depicting their brave and just struggle for freedom … : their heroism, patriotism, reverence for their land, identification with their mountains; their pride in their language and heritage; the beauty of their folk tales and songs, the rich variety of their material culture; their strong and patriotic women; the solidarity among Kurds from all backgrounds” (p. 203).
Strohmeier's book also contains a bibliography, an index, and an appendix containing excerpts from Kurdish nationalist writings, as well as some photographs of the Bedir Khan brothers and their intellectual adversary, Sukru Mehmed Sekban. The scholarship is sound, accurate, and well balanced, and it relies on appropriate sources. Thus, this analysis of a failed nationalism ironically will become a useful contribution to understanding the background of what subsequently has become a powerful Kurdish nationalist challenge that has already helped to alter the very nature of the Kemalist Turkish state.