Commercialism first became a major problem for medicine in the decade of the 1970s, when huge quantities of new money began to flow into the healthcare system, as a result of Medicaid and Medicare, and the rapid expansion of private, employer-based insurance. Of course, physicians benefited, but most of this new money went to insurance plans and medical care delivery institutions, like hospitals, nursing homes, diagnostic services, and ambulatory care facilities of many kinds. Many of these were newly established for-profit businesses. A vast number of satellite enterprises sprang up to serve the growing needs of the new businesses by providing services like marketing and advertising, brokering, consulting, information technology, financial services, case and disease management, billing and collecting, and so forth.
Collectively, all of these businesses and their satellite services constituted a huge new healthcare “industry” (which I called “the new medical–industrial complex”), employing millions of workers and attracting armies of investors. The private non-investor-owned insurance plans and healthcare facilities (that called themselves “nonprofit,” and thereby claimed tax exemption) had to compete with the investor-owned businesses and with each other. Consequently, their behavior also became more entrepreneurial, as concerns about economic survival and the “bottom line” began to dominate the entire private healthcare system.
These developments inevitably influenced practicing physicians, many of whom were attracted to the profitable business opportunities for clinicians in the new investor-owned enterprises. Physicians became associated with them as investors, owners, partners, or employees, thus creating financial conflicts of interest that were unprecedented in number and variety. Even when they deliberately avoided such associations and confined their sources of income to the care of patients, physicians increasingly thought of themselves as private business people, competing with their colleagues for a share of the patient market. With the growth of medical technology and the ever-increasing specialization and subspecialization of medical and surgical practice, the financial rewards of entrepreneurial behavior continued to grow.
All this has greatly undermined the traditional ethical philosophy of medical practice. Medicine never in its history totally rejected the seductions of financial gain, but until fairly recently most young physicians entered their profession with the primary intention to be of service to their patients. It was, of course, assumed that personal financial gain was not incompatible with that goal, and that most physicians would be at least modestly well rewarded for competent and dedicated clinical service. But financial ambition did not trump professional ethics, as it increasingly seems to do now.
The trouble, I believe, is twofold. We have a dysfunctional healthcare system, dominated by investor-owned businesses and by market competition that has created a new commercialized environment. It is a system incompatible with the needs of community and personal medical care and with the values of medical professionalism that have traditionally shaped the behavior of our physicians. But we also have a new generation of physicians too ready to accept the replacement of professional values by market dogma—too willing to believe that medical care is just another economic commodity, of which they are simply “providers.” All in all, this bodes ill for the future of U.S. healthcare, which is becoming intolerably expensive, inequitable, and insensitive to the needs of our society.
To solve this problem, we will have to reform our healthcare system and reeducate our young physicians. There is a lot of work to be done by our medical academic institutions and professional societies, which have not sufficiently resisted the tide of commercialism. Medical ethicists belong in the vanguard of the struggle to reclaim the moral high ground for a profession in danger of losing its moorings. That is why the current commentaries are so welcome.
