In the fall of 2017 at the Harvard Art Museum, the Technologies of the Image exhibition brought together a collection of objects from nineteenth-century Iran, divided into four types of image-making: painting, photography, lithography, and lacquerware. Unlike the better-known large oil paintings of the Qajar dynasty (1789–1925), many of this exhibit's objects were diminutive, drawing the viewer in close to notice small details. As many major collections and installations of Islamic art peter out after 1800, the pointed grouping of nineteenth-century objects across media demonstrated that the period's rich image-world demands closer examination than it has been afforded previously. A particularly striking lacquerware mirror cover depicted the intimate scene of a baby boy's birth and circumcision. Only 9 inches high and 6 inches wide, the glossy watercolor composition portrays a woman, bare below the waist, reclining in the arms of an attendant while a small infant lies in a round dish below her. Most surprising, another female attendant wraps the afterbirth – the placenta and umbilical cord – in a floral textile. In many ways, this is an apt metaphor for the exhibit and catalogue: what was once discarded as messy and unimportant has now been carefully, and beautifully, packaged for us.
In conjunction with the exhibit, David Roxburgh and Mary McWilliams edited an excellent, exquisitely illustrated catalogue of essays. Roxburgh's introductory text frames the overarching goals of the exhibition, and the four detailed essays by McWilliams, Farshid Emami, Mira Xenia Schwerda, and Roxburgh delve into careful examinations of those four media: lacquerware, lithography, photography, and painting, respectively. Overall, the catalog puts forth an important and necessary intervention. Historically, the nineteenth century had been framed as a time of “decline” for Islamic art history in which assumed “classic” styles of art making shifted substantially under the growing onslaught of western European culture, disseminated through the mercantile and military expansion of colonialism. As a discipline founded in the study of medieval art, these narratives of decline also extended to the early modern period as well as the twentieth century. Roxburgh acknowledges this lack of scholarship in the first paragraph of his introductory essay, and highlights its roots in prejudiced contemporaneous nineteenth-century European perspectives. The book thus makes a timely and detailed contribution as a new generation of scholars are making strides in the study of nineteenth-century Islamic art. As such, the catalog will be an excellent resource for undergraduate and graduate coursework on this period through its incisive and clear essays, as well as because of its wealth of full-color images of all the exhibited artworks.
McWilliam's essay focuses on the lacquerware objects that proliferated in the Qajar era, providing a detailed account of the medium's material properties. She argues, through careful analyses of flowers, birds, and beautiful European ladies, that these luxurious, tactile objects easily borrowed and blended images from widely circulated European prints. These borrowings continue practices from earlier periods but at an increasing rate as the transmission of reproducible images grew. She dubs lacquerware a “flexible medium” (46) and likens it to twentieth-century American television in its ability to “recombine” sources and generate “a steady supply of spinoffs and reruns” (47). This lively essay brings fresh attention to lacquerware boxes, cases, and covers, which are widespread in museum collections but still not well understood. McWilliam's analysis will certainly provoke more thought on how these blended artworks engender meanings about femininity, domesticity, and beauty through these reflective, adorned surfaces.
The third chapter, by Emami, traces the nineteenth-century heyday of lithography in books, journals, and popular religious posters. Unlike the difficult and expensive moveable type printing press that had yet to be fully embraced in the Arabic script, Emami explains that lithography offered a cheaper and easier method of transforming hand-written illustrated books into reproducible texts. He argues that the introduction of this reproducible medium altered the very idea of an illustrated book along with how it was circulated and consumed (59). No longer was an illustrated book a “truly unique” handmade object: its reproducibility shifted its very signification. This argument, like many in the book, points back to the exhibition's title – “Technologies of the Image” – emphasizing how technological, not only colonial, developments in image-making precipitated major aesthetic paradigm shifts.
The last two chapters focus on photography's impact on image-making and circulation in Iran. Invented in Paris in 1839, photography spread swiftly, upending traditions of image-making worldwide. While these ramifications have been studied in depth in the context of the North Atlantic, these essays contribute to a growing body of scholarship on the proliferation of photography outside of Euro-American centers. While recent books by cultural historians Ali Behdad and Stephen Sheehi have analyzed Middle Eastern photography, the field of Islamic art history is just beginning to grapple with the medium's impact.
Schwerda's essay presents an overview of Iranian nineteenth-century photography from the introduction of daguerreotypes to the explosion of cheap paper postcards in 1900. By drawing links between royal photographic practice and photographs of mass circulation, Schwerda cogently argues that “photography evolved from a court curiosity to an agent for social and political change” (100). This detailed study exposes photography as crafting meaning also through its easy mobility. She illustrates this through her analysis of a photograph by the Russian-Armenian and Tehran-based photographer Antonin Sevruguin, which was reproduced as a colored photochrome in Zurich, and then ultimately graced the cover of the New York Tribune in 1907 (92–94).
The book culminates with Roxburgh's essay on “Painting after Photography,” which weaves together lithography, photography, and lacquerware with the longer history of Persianate painting. Roxburgh clearly and compellingly argues that nineteenth-century Iranian painters’ “combinatory” (117) incorporation of new technologies in photography and lithography did not represent a rupture. Rather, image-making through “sutur[ing]” appropriated and adapted models represents a continuation of prior Persianate artistic processes (119).
These detailed studies of the fluid mediums of image-making in nineteenth-century Iran trace the specificity of artistic and material responses to the period's technological developments. While the reader-viewer is left convinced of the deep historical and contemporary engagement, one might wonder how these transformations and continuations evolved in the twentieth century. The exhibit establishes nineteenth-century Iran as a significant area of study for Islamic art history, but also offers a bridge for future scholars to take into the next century.
