Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:09:36.996Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Lift and drag forces acting on a particle moving in the presence of slip and shear near a wall

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 March 2021

Nilanka I.K. Ekanayake
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia
Joseph D. Berry
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia
Dalton J.E. Harvie*
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia
*
†Email address for correspondence: daltonh@unimelb.edu.au

Abstract

The lift and drag forces acting on a small spherical particle moving with a finite slip in single-wall-bounded flows are investigated via direct numerical simulations. This study is an extension of our previous work that considered the lift and drag forces acting on a sphere moving near a wall in the presence shear, but in the absence of slip (Ekanayake et al., J. Fluid Mech., vol. 904, 2020, A6). The effect of slip velocity on the particle force is analysed as a function of separation distance for low slip and shear Reynolds numbers ($10^{-3} \leq Re_{{slip}} \leq 10^{-1}$ and $10^{-3} \leq Re_{\gamma } \leq 10^{-1}$) in both quiescent and linear shear flows. A generalised lift model valid for arbitrary particle–wall separation distances and $Re_{\gamma }, Re_{{slip}} \leq 10^{-1}$ is developed based on the results of the simulations. The proposed model can now predict the lift forces in linear shear flows in the presence or absence of slip, and in quiescent flows when slip is present. Existing drag models are also compared with numerical results for both quiescent and linear shear flows to determine which models capture near-wall slip velocities most accurately for low particle Reynolds numbers. Finally, we compare the results of the proposed lift model to previous experimental results of negatively buoyant particles and to numerical results of neutrally buoyant (force-free) particles moving near a wall in quiescent and linear shear flows. The generalised lift model presented can be used to predict the behaviour of particle suspensions in biological and industrial flows where the particle Reynolds numbers based on slip and shear are ${O}(10^{-1})$ and below.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of a translating sphere of radius $a$ moving at velocity $u_{p}$ in (a) an unbounded linear shear flow (b) a wall-bounded quiescent flow and (c) a wall-bounded linear shear flow.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Comparison of $J(\epsilon )$ values from experimental and DNS data for $Re_{slip} <1$ with empirical and theoretical correlations. Asymptotic solution ($\circ$) and asymptotic limits (--------) by McLaughlin (1991). DNS: Legendre & Magnaudet (1998) ($\square$, red), Cherukat, McLaughlin & Dandy (1999) ($\square$, light blue), Kurose & Komori (1999) ($\square$, light green). Experiments: Cherukat, McLaughlin & Graham (1994) (+, light grey), empirical fits by Mei (1992) (--------, blue), Shi & Rzehak (2019) (--------, Lime green) and Legendre & Magnaudet (1998) (--------, red).

Figure 2

Table 1.Correlations for $J(\epsilon )$.

Figure 3

Table 2.Correlations for outer-region-based wall-slip lift coefficient $C_{L,3}^{wb,out}$.

Figure 4

Table 3.Numerical correlations for $f(\epsilon , L_{G})$.

Figure 5

Table 4.Slip-based lift coefficients ($C_{L,2}^{wb,in}$ and $C_{L,3}^{wb,in}$) of inner-region studies.

Figure 6

Table 5.Theoretical and empirical inertial corrections for $C_{D,2}^{ub}$.

Figure 7

Figure 3.Lift coefficient ($C_{{L,3}}$) for different shear Reynolds number as a function of non-dimensional separation distance (${l^{\ast }}$) for (a) non-rotating and (b) freely rotating spheres. Simulations: $Re_{slip} = 10^{-3}$ ($\circ$, red), $10^{-2}$ ($\triangle$, red) and $10^{-1}$ ($\square$, red). Numerical predictions by Fischer & Rosenberger (1987) that included small inertial effects at $Re_\gamma \ll 1$ ($\ast$, black star). Analytical predictions of Cox & Hsu (1977) ($\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot$, (2.23), (2.24)), Cherukat & McLaughlin (1994) (-$\cdot$-$\cdot$, grey, (2.25), (2.26)), Krishnan & Leighton (1995) (--------, grey, (2.27)) and Magnaudet et al. (2003) (- - -, grey, (2.29)). Present numerical fit for inner region (--------, blue, (4.3a), (4.3b)). Present numerical fit for all regions (--------, red, (4.4a), (4.4b)).

Figure 8

Figure 4.Lift coefficient ($C_{{L,3}}$) for slip Reynolds number values of $Re_{slip} = 10^{-3}$ ($\circ$), $10^{-2}$ ($\triangle$) and $10^{-1}$ ($\square$) as a function of separation distance non-dimensionalised by the Stokes length scale ($l^{\ast }/{L_{{S}}}^{\ast }$). Red and blue symbols are for freely rotating and non-rotating particles, respectively. Asymptotic models for $Re_{slip} \ll 1$ by Vasseur & Cox (1977) (--------, grey, (2.10)), Takemura & Magnaudet (2003) (- - -, grey, (2.11)), Takemura (2004) ($\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot$, grey, (2.12)) and Shi & Rzehak (2020) (-$\cdot$-$\cdot$, grey, (2.13)). Present numerical fit for non-rotating particles (--------, blue, (4.4a)) and freely rotating particles (--------, red, (4.4b)).

Figure 9

Figure 5.Drag force coefficient of a spherical particle in the absence of shear ($C_{{D,2}}$). Simulations: non-rotating ($\circ$), freely rotating (+). Analytical prediction: Faxen inner-region correlation (Happel & Brenner 1981) (--------, (2.39)), Takemura (2004) outer-region correlation (--------, blue, (2.40)) and Takemura (2004) inner–outer-region correlation (- - -, red, (2.41)). Unbounded Stokes drag ($\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot$, (2.31)).

Figure 10

Figure 6.Non-dimensional lift force ($F_{{L}}^{\ast }$) of a freely rotating particle; $Re_\gamma$ and $Re_{slip}$ increase in the order of $10^{-3}, 10^{-2}, 10^{-1}$ from left to right and top to bottom respectively. Simulations: inner region ($\circ$, red) and outer region ($\bullet$, red) for each plot. Analytical predictions: inner-region model of Cherukat & McLaughlin (1995) (- - -, grey, (2.22)), outer-region model of Takemura et al. (2009) (-$\cdot$-$\cdot$, grey, (2.16)). Present model prediction (--------, red, (4.6)). (a) Leading particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } > 0$) and (b) lagging particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } < 0$).

Figure 11

Figure 7.Lift force coefficient ($C_{{L}}=F_{{L}}^{\ast }/Re_{slip}^2$) of a freely rotating particle as a function of separation distance non-dimensionalised by Saffman length scale ($l^{\ast }/{L_{{G}}}^{\ast }$). Simulations: inner region ($\circ$) and outer region ($\bullet$). Analytical outer-region correlation of Takemura et al. (2009) (- - -, (2.16)) and ($\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot \!\cdot$, (2.15)). Present model predictions (--------, (4.6)). (a) Leading particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } > 0$) and (b) lagging particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } < 0$).

Figure 12

Figure 8.Lift force coefficient $C_{{L,2}}$ of a freely rotating particle; $Re_\gamma$ and $Re_{slip}$ increase in the order of $10^{-3}, 10^{-2}, 10^{-1}$ from left to right and top to bottom respectively. Simulations: inner region ($\circ$, red) and outer region ($\bullet$, red) for each subplot. Analytical predictions: inner-region $C_{{L,2}}$ model of Cherukat & McLaughlin (1995) (- - -, grey, (2.26)), outer-region model of Takemura et al. (2009) (-$\cdot$-$\cdot$, grey, (2.15)). Present model prediction (--------, red, (4.5b)). (a) Leading particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } > 0$) and (b) lagging particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } < 0$).

Figure 13

Figure 9.Lift force coefficient $C_{{L,2}}$ of a freely rotating particle as a function of separation distance non-dimensionalised by the Saffman length scale ($l^{\ast }/{L_{{G}}}^{\ast }$). Simulations: inner region ($\circ$) and outer region ($\bullet$). Analytical outer-region correlation of Takemura et al. (2009) (- - -, (2.15)). Present model predictions (--------, (4.5)). (a) Leading particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } > 0$) and (b) lagging particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } < 0$).

Figure 14

Figure 10.Drag force coefficient ($C_{{D}}$) of a freely rotating particle as a function of separation distance non-dimensionalised by the Saffman length scale ($l^{\ast }/{L_{{G}}}^{\ast }$). Simulations: inner region ($\circ$) and outer region ($\bullet$). Inner-region analytical predictions when $C_{D,1}$ is evaluated by (2.44) (--------) and by (2.43) (- - -). For both cases $C_{D,2}$ is evaluated by (2.39). Outer-region analytical prediction when $C_{D,2}$ and $C_{D,1}$ are evaluated by (2.40) and (2.44), respectively (-$\cdot$-$\cdot$). (a) Leading particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } > 0$) and (b) lagging particle in a positive shear field (${\gamma }^{\ast } < 0$).

Figure 15

Figure 11.Lift force of a force-free particle translating in a linear shear flow near a wall when ${F_{L,tot}^{\prime }}$ is evaluated using (5.1) for $Re_\gamma =10^{-3}$ (--------, blue), $Re_\gamma =10^{-2}$ (--------), $Re_\gamma =10^{-1}$ (--------, red); Numerical results (Ekanayake et al.2020) (coloured hollow circles). $C_{L,2}$ and $C_{L,3}$ in (5.1) are evaluated using the inner-region-based Cherukat & McLaughlin (1995) models (dotted lines).

Figure 16

Figure 12.Analysis of a sedimenting particle in a quiescent single wall-bounded flow. Experiments: $Re_{{slip},\infty }=0.1005$ ($\circ$, blue), $Re_{{slip},\infty }=0.255$ ($\circ$, red), $Re_{{slip},\infty }=0.5$ ($\circ$). Outer-region data are indicated using solid circles, and inner-region data by hollow circles. (a) Slip velocity when $C_{D,2}^{wb}$ is evaluated using, (2.39) (dashed line), (2.40) (dashed and dotted line) and (2.41) (solid line) and $C_{D,2}^{ub}$ is evaluated by (2.35). (b) Migration velocity when $C_{L,3}$ is evaluated by present model ((4.4b) solid line) and by using inner-region correlation equation (2.29) (dashed line) and outer-region correlation equation (2.12) (dashed and dotted line) as given in Takemura (2004).

Figure 17

Figure 13.Analysis of a sedimenting particle in a linear single wall-bounded flow. (a) Drag coefficient when $C_{D,1}$ is evaluated by (2.44) (solid) and (2.43) (dashed). For all cases $C_{D,2}$ is evaluated by (2.39), (2.31). Experiments: $Re_{{slip},\infty }=0.029, {\gamma }^{\ast }_\infty = -0.116$ ($\circ$, blue), $Re_{{slip}},\infty =0.029, {\gamma }^{\ast }_\infty = 0.116$ ($\circ$, red). (b) Migration velocity when $C_{L}$ is evaluated by using proposed lift (4.6) (solid), inner-region model (2.22) using the Magnaudet et al. (2003) coefficients (dashed), outer-region model (2.16) using the Takemura et al. (2009) coefficients (dashed dotted) and empirical fit Takemura (2004) (dotted). Experiments: $Re_{{slip},\infty }=0.1, {\gamma }^{\ast }_\infty = -0.061$ ($\circ$, blue), $Re_{{slip},\infty }=0.17, {\gamma }^{\ast }_\infty = 0.044$ ($\circ$, red), $Re_{{slip}},\infty =0.55, {\gamma }^{\ast }_\infty = -0.033$ ($\circ$). Outer-region data are indicated using solid circles, and inner-region data by hollow circles.

Figure 18

Table 6.Effect of domain size on drag and lift coefficients for maximum and minimum separation distances (${l^{\ast }} = 1.2$ and $9.5$) and slip Reynolds number ($Re_{slip} = 10^{-3}$ and $10^{-1}$) at $Re_{\gamma }=0$. $\delta$ is the percentage error in coefficient, relative to results calculated using the largest domain size (${L^{\ast }}=120$).

Figure 19

Figure 14.Effect of mesh resolution around the sphere on $C_{L,3}$ for a non-rotating particle at ${l^{\ast }}=1.2$. $N_{p}$ = 15 (solid line square); 20 (solid line triangle); 25 (solid line star); 30 (solid line circle).