The central argument of Leonard Cassuto's Hard-Boiled Sentimentality is that the apparently masculinist US hard-boiled crime stories of the twentieth century are inexorably linked to the apparently feminine, sentimental stories of the nineteenth-century domestic sphere. Intriguingly, Cassuto proposes that this preoccupation with sentimental sympathy – and the extent to which the private sphere of family can be reconciled with the demands of public life – can, in turn, be traced back to Scottish Enlightenment thinkers of the eighteenth century such as Hume and Smith; hence his claim that the book constitutes “an intellectual history of hard-boiled fiction” (2) or a master code by which the secret history of hard-boiled fiction can be explained. In doing so, Cassuto skilfully brings together or draws upon two related and highly productive approaches to crime fiction criticism. From Breu's Hard-Boiled Masculinities (2005) and Abbott's The Street Was Mine (2002) he demonstrates how a particular kind of initially white, male hard-boiled writing is founded upon what it seeks to disavow or repudiate (i.e. the feminine, sentimental, blackness, and so on), and from McCann's Gumshoe America (2000) he examines the ways in which hard-boiled crime stories are best understood as culturally loaded and politically ambivalent responses to changing sociohistorical circumstances (e.g. what McCann calls the rise and fall of New Deal populism).
The fact that Cassuto's book is ultimately more successful at the former is not necessarily a criticism. This is an erudite, illuminating and highly readable study which skilfully explores the ways in which the appropriation and, at times, the distortion or perversion of sentimental sympathy by hard-boiled writers constitutes an attempt both to engage with and to critique forms of community shaped by aggressive individualism and capitalist modernity. More particularly it is sensibly organized, both chronologically and thematically, to address the key moments and issues informing hard-boiled writing (e.g. the Depression, Cold War paranoia) and provides instructive and informed readings of, among others, Dreiser, Hemingway, Cain, Chandler, Goodis, Willeford, Woolrich, Thompson, Highsmith, Ross Macdonald and John D. MacDonald, Harris, Grafton, Block, Burke, Mosley and Himes. None the less, as much as Cassuto strives to show how the treatments in hard-boiled fiction of the public and private realms are linked, his insistent privileging of the latter over the former – and to use another formulation, civil society over the state – means that he is never quite able to show (as well as, say, McCann) how hard-boiled crime stories are centrally concerned with the efficacy of the state and the law. Cassuto is quite right to point out that a post-Discipline and Punish Foucauldian turn in crime fiction criticism has posited the genre as, first and foremost, a disciplinary mechanism and resulted in any inadequate sense of crime fiction's unruliness. However, in another sense, Foucault's insistence that normalizing power operates on self-policing subjects primarily through the private sphere and practices of everyday life is actually rather similar to Cassuto's claim that hard-boiled fiction ultimately reinforces the ideology of home. In both cases, the role played by the police and other advocates of the law and the state in both creating and maintaining the conditions necessary for collective life and perpetuating inequalities often via coercion is overlooked – and the genre's structuring tension between liberal and Marxist accounts of institutions is left unexamined. Accounts that focus, say, on state power, of course, allow other important aspects of hard-boiled crime stories to slip through their fingers and it is worth noting that certain novels and writers (e.g. Highsmith) whose focus is the private and often grotesquely distorted world of greed and perversion are better served by Cassuto's focus than others. It is also instructive to note that Cassuto's analysis is better able to account for The Maltese Falcon than for Red Harvest for these same reasons. Perhaps one should not expect or make claims for a master code that unlocks the secrets of all hard-boiled crime stories and simply accept that in a field of writing as diverse as this one, certain approaches will inevitably favour certain novels.
